What's wrong with inequality? Some Rousseauian perspectives

In: European journal of political theory: EJPT, Band 14, Heft 3, S. 368-377

Abstract

In this article, I review Frederick Neuhouser's latest book, Rousseau's Critique of Inequality, while critically assessing the legacy of Rousseau's ideas on inequality and amour-propre for contemporary political philosophy. I challenge the widely held notion that the account of equality set out in the Social Contract should be read as a (partial) remedy to the problems generated by amour-propre, and suggest that we have to turn to Rousseau's other writings to reconstruct his own political remedies for these problems. I then draw attention to a much neglected dimension of Rousseau's critique of inequality, which concerns the effect inequality has on our ability to identify with other humans and feel compassion for them. Taken together, these considerations highlight some of the limitations of the dominant Kantian–Rawlsian strand of Rousseau interpretation within contemporary liberal political philosophy.