MOVING RIGHT ALONG: THE ROOTS OF AMATETEURISM IN THE CANADIAN HOUSE OF COMMONS

In: Canadian journal of political science: CJPS = Revue canadienne de science politique : RCSP, Band 25, Heft 2, S. 295-319

Abstract

IT HAS BEEN ARGUED THAT RAPID MEMBERSHIP TURNOVER IN THE CANADIAN HOUSE OF COMMONS ROBS THE INSTITUTION OF A DEDICATED AND EXPERIENCED GROUP OF MPS AND PRODUCES A PARLIAMENT STOCKED WITH POLITICAL AMATEURS. BOTH ELECTORAL DEFEAT AND VOLUNTARY RETIREMENT HAVE BEEN SEEN TO PLAY A ROLE IN THE AMATEURISM PHENOMENON. THE AUTHORS EXPLORE THE ROOTS OF AMATEURISM AND CRITICALLY EXAMINE THE ARGUMENT THAT A FRUSTRATING CAREER STRUCTURE IN THE HOUSE OF COMMONS ENCOURAGES VOLUNTARY VACANCIES. USING A RANDOM SAMPLE OF FORMER MPS, THE AUTHORS FIND SUPPORT FOR BOTH A "FRUSTRATION" AND AN "EXHAUSTION" MODEL OF CAREER CHOICE. THE ARTICLE CONCLUDES THAT WHILE AMATEURISM MAY BE PROBLEMATIC, NOT ALL MPS ARE AMATEURS AND THE PROBLEM OF AMATEURISM CANNOT BE ADDRESSED SIMPLY BY SATISFYING FRUSTRATED AMBITION.