World System History, The Papacy, and the Transition from Transitions

In: Journal of developing societies: a forum on issues of development and change in all societies, Band 24, Heft 1, S. 57-82

Abstract

In a very controversial argument, Andre Gunder Frank suggested that scholars abandon ideas like 'transitions' and 'modes of production' in favor of more accurate, less Eurocentric concepts. This work reviews three relevant debates on the use of these concepts. The class backgrounds of 64 popes from 1300 to 1900 are then analyzed to see if leaders of a powerful, non-hereditary office altered over that time. The analysis offers no support regarding the role of transitions or modes of production in helping to understand elite recruitment. This finding supports Frank's suggestion that we consider alternative conceptual foundations for understanding development.