Sorting Out Mechanical and Psychological Effects in Candidate Elections: An Appraisal with Experimental Data
In: British journal of political science, Band 43, Heft 4, S. 937-944
ISSN: 1469-2112
150 Ergebnisse
Sortierung:
In: British journal of political science, Band 43, Heft 4, S. 937-944
ISSN: 1469-2112
In: Electoral Studies, Band 31, Heft 4, S. 829-837
The paper assesses the influence of electoral rules on vote choice and election outcomes using a quasi-experiment conducted during a recent Canadian provincial election. Respondents were invited to vote under three voting systems (first past the post, alternative voting and proportional representation) and to answer a short questionnaire. We examine how the distribution of votes and seats is affected, and we ascertain how much of the total difference is due to psychological and mechanical effects. We find that a PR system would have increased legislative fractionalization by the equivalent of one effective party and that the mechanical effect is much more important than the psychological effect. As for AV, its mechanical and psychological effects act in opposite directions. [Copyright Elsevier Ltd.]
In: Electoral Studies, Band 31, Heft 4
The paper assesses the influence of electoral rules on vote choice and election outcomes using a quasi-experiment conducted during a recent Canadian provincial election. Respondents were invited to vote under three voting systems (first past the post, alternative voting and proportional representation) and to answer a short questionnaire. We examine how the distribution of votes and seats is affected, and we ascertain how much of the total difference is due to psychological and mechanical effects. We find that a PR system would have increased legislative fractionalization by the equivalent of one effective party and that the mechanical effect is much more important than the psychological effect. As for AV, its mechanical and psychological effects act in opposite directions. [Copyright Elsevier Ltd.]
In: Electoral Studies, Band 27, Heft 2, S. 337-343
The paper compares three alternative approaches employed by the Canadian Election Study to measure voters' perceptions of parties' chances of winning in their local constituency. The first approach, used in 2000, consists of asking respondents to rate parties' chances on a 0 to 100 scale in a random sequence. The second, used in 2004, entails first asking whether each party had a chance of winning and then inviting people to rate the chances. In the third approach, adopted in 2006, respondents are first asked which two parties had the best chance of winning and, then, if any other party has a chance, before requesting that they rate the mentioned parties. By comparing 'objective' and 'perceived' chances of winning, the paper concludes that the third approach provides a more valid measure of voters' expectations. The paper discusses the implications for the measurement of expectations in different types of electoral systems. [Copyright 2008 Elsevier Ltd.]
In: Political psychology: journal of the International Society of Political Psychology, Band 32, Heft 5, S. 885-919
ISSN: 1467-9221
This article examines whether a public opinion survey can improve the quality of political attitudes. More specifically, we argue that simply positioning a summary attitudinal question after a balanced series of relevant items can increase people's ability to answer in a way that better reflects their underlying interests, values, and predispositions. By manipulating the location of the vote preference question in two separate national election campaign surveys, we find that there are fewer undecided respondents when the question is asked at the end of the survey rather than early on, that some people are changing their mind during the questionnaire, that a larger set of determinants is structuring late‐survey vote choice, and that voting preferences based on the later question are a better predictor of the actual vote. The findings carry important lessons for students of deliberation and of citizen decision making.
In: Electoral Studies, Band 29, Heft 1, S. 1-12
We test two competing hypotheses about the impact of partisanship and information on people's political judgments and perceptions of facts using Canadians' reactions to a major scandal. Our findings with respect to subjective political judgments confirm the argument that partisan predispositions are crucial. But there is no evidence to support the argument that the polarizing effect of partisanship is most evident among the most informed. When it comes to perceptions of 'objective' facts, the results are consistent with Zaller's reception axiom: the more informed people are, the more likely they are to correctly perceive objective facts. Partisanship does not appear to affect these perceptions. [Copyright Elsevier Ltd.]
In: French politics, Band 5, Heft 3, S. 278-286
ISSN: 1476-3427
In: Canadian public policy: Analyse de politiques, Band 25, Heft 1, S. 151
ISSN: 1911-9917
In: Canadian Journal of Sociology / Cahiers canadiens de sociologie, Band 19, Heft 1, S. 135
In: Electoral Studies, Band 36, S. 39-50
We test the rational choice model of turnout in the lab. We performed laboratory experiments in which participants had to decide whether to vote or not in a number of first past the post and proportional representation elections. We test the predictions of rational choice theory from three different angles: (i) First, we compare aggregate turnout with the Nash equilibrium predictions. (ii) Second, we compare individual decisions with those derived from a rational calculus and count the number of decisions which are consistent with the rational recommendation, and. (iii) Third, we determine, still at the individual level, whether, at the margin, people are more likely to vote as the expected payoff increases. The overwhelming thrust of the evidence is inconsistent with the rational calculus paradigm. [Copyright Elsevier Ltd.]
In: Political research quarterly: PRQ ; official journal of the Western Political Science Association and other associations, Band 64, Heft 3
ISSN: 1938-274X
The authors test a model of strategic vote choice in which the decision to support or not to support a candidate depends on the benefit associated with the election of a given candidate and the candidate's perceived viability. They test the model with data collected in a series of experiments in which the participants voted in eight successive elections, four in one round and four in two rounds. Results show that the same model applies to both voting systems, although the impact of perceived viability is slightly weaker in two-round elections. The authors conclude that strategic considerations are almost as important in two-round as in one-round elections. Adapted from the source document.
In: Canadian public policy: Analyse de politiques, Band 19, Heft 4, S. 475
ISSN: 1911-9917
In: Comparative political studies: CPS, Band 43, Heft 1, S. 61-90
ISSN: 1552-3829
Based on recent work that suggests that voters in proportional representation (PR) systems have incentives to cast strategic votes, the authors hypothesize that levels of strategic voting are similar in both first-past-the-post (FPTP) and PR systems. Comparing vote intentions in majoritarian elections in the United States, Mexico, Britain, and Israel to PR elections in Israel and the Netherlands, the authors find that a substantial proportion of the voters desert their most preferred candidate or party and that patterns of strategic voting across FPTP and PR bear striking similarities. In every election, smaller parties tend to lose votes to major parties. Because there tend to be more small parties in PR systems, tactical voting is actually more common under PR than under FPTP. The findings suggest that whatever the electoral system, voters focus on the policy consequences of their behavior and which parties are likely to influence policy outcomes following the election. [Reprinted by permission of Sage Publications Inc., copyright holder.]
In: American political science review, Band 101, Heft 4, S. 621-636
ISSN: 0003-0554
In: American political science review, Band 101, Heft 3, S. 373-391
ISSN: 0003-0554
World Affairs Online