Human Rights as a Holistic Concept
In: Human rights quarterly: a comparative and international journal of the social sciences, humanities, and law, Band 14, Heft 1, S. 1-20
ISSN: 0275-0392
An argument for a reconceptualization of "human rights," examining the great eighteenth-century French & American texts in which generalized rights declarations contrasted with selective recognition of rights in the real world. It is contended that rights are social practices that must be understood in their historical & situational contexts, & that the subject of human rights is always the individual human being, but that the human being is a political/social animal. Thus the argument is made for a holism that recognizes the social richness of the individual subject. While abstract or idealist foundations (eg, natural law or rights) for human rights are insufficient because they ignore human beings as historical/social beings, so is the completely relativistic position, which totally gives up on the individual as the struggler for, & bearer of, human rights. Some problems posed for human rights by modern constitutional government & the new world order are explicated. AA