Is it an anarchist act to call oneself an anarchist? Judith Butler, John Turner and insurrectionary speech
In: Contemporary political theory: CPT, Band 13, Heft 4, S. 339-357
ISSN: 1470-8914
Anarchists and homosexuals have periodically occupied similar positions in relation to US laws and policies: both have functioned as the needed outside against which the proper inside of political order can be established and maintained. Both have blurred the relation of words to deeds, speaking words that are forbidden because the words themselves are seen as dangerous deeds. Examining the deportation case of anarchist John Turner in 1903 and the 1993 Pentagon ban on homosexuals serving openly in the military, and utilizing the intellectual tools provided by Judith Butler in her analysis of speech acts, this article investigates the process of criminalizing an identity category as well as the political context from which that criminalization can be challenged. My goals are to make use of Butler's arguments about insurrectionary speech to understand anarchism's historical role in the American political imaginary, and to supplement Butler's analysis with greater attention to the histories of anarchist struggle. Adapted from the source document.