Moral Principles and Political Institutions: Perspectives on Ethics and International Affairs
In: Millennium: journal of international studies, Band 31, Heft 2, S. 347-357
ISSN: 0305-8298
A review essay on books by (1) Jean-Marc Coicaud & Daniel Warner (Eds), Ethics and International Affairs: Extent and Limits (Tokyo: United Nations U Press, 2001); & (2) Hakan Seckinelgin & Hideaki Shinoda (Eds), Ethics and International Relations (London: Palgrave-Millennium, 2001). Both books allow the works of important authors in the field of ethics & international affairs to be assembled. The results are, in general, both strong & satisfyingly diverse. However, each book suffers from the lack of a unifying theme. The reviewed works can be understood as contributions to a continuing dialogue between analytical & critical perspectives, to research in ethics & international affairs, with a lot to say about whether ethics, morals, & principles can be successfully applied to this arena & about the potential morality of institutions. While both books are worthwhile, the volume by Coicaud & Warner is thematically superior to that by Seckinelgin & Shinoda, but Seckinelgin & Shinoda's work features more daring articles. D. Weibel