Private Education and Public Administration
In: Telos, Heft 111, S. 63-68
ISSN: 0040-2842, 0090-6514
Considers the politics behind recent US efforts to publicly finance private education in the form of school vouchers or tax relief, suggesting that these proposals are marked by a consistently high-handed use of state power to intervene in the affairs of private education. In small-scale experiments with these tools, it has been found that they routinely become a kind of transfer payment from the middle & working classes to the inner-city poor overseen by state bureaucrats. Efforts to privatize education are doomed because they do not account for the fact that education has become a primary vehicle of social indoctrination that the managerial state is loathe to relinquish. Thus, the privatization of schooling will fail because a political space does not now exist in which it might succeed. Comparison of the US with Europe, where the administrative state has been more naturalized, illuminates the difficulties privatization boosters face. Given these difficulties, it may be more useful to promote social change by advocating governmental support for parochial institutions through the distribution of highly restricted grants. D. Ryfe