Heller, Habermas and Justice
In: Praxis international: a philosophical journal, Band 8, Heft 4, S. 491-497
ISSN: 0260-8448
A review essay on a book by Agnes Heller, Beyond Justice (Basil Blackwell, 1987 [see IRPS No. 44/88c01005; also see listing in IRPS No. 52]). In this work the philosophical issues in the debate over justice between neocommunitarians & rights-oriented liberals receive a broad historical analysis. Heller argues that a comprehensive, ethical-political concept of justice, fusing moral & legal norms, is neither possible nor desirable today because of: (1) the absence of an overarching definition of the good; (2) the dissolution of totalizing worldviews heralded by cultural modernity; & (3) the openness of all norms to critical reflection. However, Heller's call for a revision of the discourse ethic is based on a one-sided interpretation, her consequent claims are broader & less defensible, & her system tends to refuse the morality & justice she elsewhere differentiates. It is concluded that the book points squarely in the direction of democratic legitimacy grounded by the discourse ethic. J. White