LEADERSHIP AND MODERNIZATION: THE EMERGING BLACK POLITICAL ELITE IN THE AMERICAN SOUTH
In: The journal of politics: JOP, Band 35, Heft 3, S. 615-646
ISSN: 0022-3816
DRAWING ON INSIGHTS GENERATED BY STUDENTS OF THE "DEVELOPING SOCIETIES," WHO HAVE IDENTIFIED THE EMERGENCE OF NEW POLITICAL ELITES AS A CENTRAL FEATURE OF THE WHOLE MODERNIZATION PROCESS, THE NEW BLACK POLITICAL LEADERS WHO HAVE EMERGED FROM THE RECENT SOUTHERN CIVIL RIGHTS MOVEMENT ARE ANALYZED TO DETERMINE HOW CLOSELY THEY RESEMBLE THE TRADITIONAL BLACK ELITES IN THIS REGION IN TERMS OF SE BACKGROUND, ATTITUDES, & RISK-TAKING PROPENSITIES. THE IMPACT OF RAPID POLITICAL MOBILIZATION ON LEADERSHIP RECRUITMENT PATTERNS IN "DEVELOPING NATIONS" IS ASSESSED & ITS GENERAL APPLICABILITY TO THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF BLACKS IN THE US SOUTH IS ANALYZED. AGAINST THIS BACKGROUND, DATA FROM A QUESTIONNAIRE ADMINISTERED TO A SAMPLE OF THE 336 BLACK CANDIDATES FOR ELECTED OFFICE IN MISS BETWEEN 1965 & 1970--THE FIRST CROP OF BLACK OFFICE-SEEKERS SINCE RECONSTRUCTION--ARE ANALYZED. THE INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE FILLED THE NEW POLITICAL ROLES CREATED BY RAPID BLACK POLITICAL MOBILIZATION IN THE US SOUTH, LIKE THEIR COUNTERPARTS IN THE "DEVELOPING SOCIETIES," SHARE MANY OF THE SE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE TRADITIONAL, PREPOLITICAL BLACK LEADERSHIP, DESPITE SOME INFUSION OF NEW BLOOD FROM OTHER SOCIAL STRATA. ALTHOUGH THESE NEW ELITES DIFFER FROM THE TRADITIONAL LEADERSHIP GROUPS IN TERMS OF ATTITUDES, A SIZEABLE PROPORTION ARE SUFFICIENTLY AVERSE TO PERSONAL RISK-TAKING TO RAISE QUESTIONS ABOUT HOW VIGOROUSLY THEY WILL PUSH FOR CHANGES IN LOCAL POLICY IN THE FACE OF OPPOSITION FROM LOCAL POWERS-THAT-BE. FINALLY, THE SUCCESSFUL CANDIDATES SEEM EVEN MORE CONSERVATIVE & MORE LIKE THE OLD ELITE THAN THE DEFEATED ONES, SUGGESTING THAT THE ELECTORAL PROCESS ACTS AS A KIND OF SCREENING MECHANISM, SYSTEMATICALLY FILTERING OUT THE LESS TRADITIONAL CANDIDATES. BY CHANNELLING NEW DEMANDS FOR CHANGE THROUGH THE ELECTORAL PROCESS, ELECTORAL SYSTEMS AVOID INSTABILITY BUT AT THE PRICE OF POTENTIALLY BLUNTING THE IMPETUS FOR REFORM. AA.