NEGATIVE ETHNOCENTRISM
In: The journal of conflict resolution: journal of the Peace Science Society (International), Band 5, Heft 1, S. 75-81
ISSN: 0022-0027, 0731-4086
The people of Romonum, Truk were found to compare themselves &--apparently--their culture unfavorably with US culture. This seems to contradict the widely held belief that ethnocentrism is universal. Attempts to explain the findings on the basis of flattery, assimilation, love of Amer's, & a general absence of ethnocentrism were unsatisfactory. An analysis of the concept 'ethnocentrism' as advanced by Sumner & as commonly used showed that this concept contains 2 elements: one's group is the standard by which all groups are judged, & each group thinks itself superior to all others. It is maintained that while the 1st requirement of the concept is met by the Trukese & the 2nd is not, no general devaluation of their culture takes place in their minds, & the belief that the notion of own-group superiority must accompany the use of own-group as a standard is incorrect. This false connection is shown to arise from the implicit assumption that the members of a group recognize basic value diff's between themselves & members of other groups. Data are introduced which show that at least in Truk, only specific diff in practice is perceived in foreigners & that general similarity in values is assumed by the Trukese. Given this belief in essential similarity between own & other groups, positive evaluation of some of the diff's which are noted in foreigners is shown to be enentirely compatible with the general concept of ethnocentrism since, far from attacking the basic values of own group, they are in support of those values. AA.