Suchergebnisse

The painter Francis Bacon (1909-1992) did a series of interviews during his career with David Sylvester. Some of them are presented in Interviews with Francis Bacon: 1962-1979, by David Sylvester, published in 1980. I’m both interested in the art and also pretty clueless, but when I’m interested, I don’t mind being clueless. (In fact, life … Continue reading “Destructive Criticism … Is Certainly the Most Helpful Criticism”
The post "Destructive Criticism … Is Certainly the Most Helpful Criticism" first appeared on Conversable Economist.

Research shows that women are less likely to point out and penalize mistakes in science, and publish fewer comments and failed replications in scientific journals. What does this mean for the social sciences?BITSS Program Manager Grace Han interviews David Klinowski (Visiting Assistant Professor at the University of Pittsburgh Katz Graduate School of Business) about his forthcoming publication, "Voicing Disagreement in Science: Missing Women."Credit: Suad Kamardeen via UnsplashWhat does it mean for the state of social science when half of all published studies fail to replicate? A recent Nature article reported that, according to some studies, 35–70 percent of published results don't support replication with new data. "Often, researchers cannot even reproduce results when using the same data and code as the original paper, because key information is missing," the authors wrote.Despite glaring issues with the credibility of published research, replicating results remains disincentivized, and stark inequalities in their production and publication exacerbate this challenge. At the 2023 BITSS Annual Meeting, David Klinowski, visiting assistant professor at the University of Pittsburgh Katz Graduate School of Business, discussed determinants of gender gaps in education and labor markets. His forthcoming publication, Voicing Disagreement in Science: Missing Women, shows that women are less likely to point out and penalize mistakes in science and publish fewer comments and failed replications in scientific journals.We talked to David about why women are missing from academic criticisms and what this means for the social sciences. Responses have been edited for length and clarity.Grace Han: Your research indicates that women are missing from critiques and failed replications. Why do you think that is?David Klinowski: Many factors may influence a researcher's decision to criticize a published paper, some of which may have a gender component. For example, a researcher may be more or less willing to express criticism depending on her level of seniority or whether she has coauthors to pursue the criticism with. If women tend to be more junior than men, or have fewer coauthors, then these differences could contribute to the gender gap in critiques and failed replications.Opportunity costs may also play a role. Our profession values critiques and replications much less than it values novelty. Researchers may naturally choose to focus on doing original work rather than attempting to replicate or criticize others' work.Women may also suffer backlash to a larger degree than men for criticizing work. Research has found that women are often penalized for displaying male-stereotypical behaviors, such as assertiveness. If writing a critique or a failed replication is perceived as confrontational, then women may be reluctant to write these papers for fear of backlash. It is also possible that women criticize as much as men do but their criticisms are more often rejected during peer review.What are the impacts of women's comparative absence from such criticisms?DK: It is hard to say. Publishing a critique in a top journal could advance the critic's career. She could gain recognition from her peers, and citations to her work. And the process of replicating someone's work could be a great learning experience. But if negative consequences such as backlash are larger for women, then it may be entirely rational for women not to participate.We should also worry about what impact the lack of female-authored critiques and failed replications has on science itself. Is the process of self-correction in science slower as a result? Are there views and insights that never emerge as a result?What does the relative absence of women from critical publications say about the scientific literature and publishing process at large?DK: One way to interpret the results is that they illustrate how difficult and fraught it is to express post-publication criticism. It is not always easy to find out whether a replication exists, or to know what a critique may imply about the original paper. Original authors may be terrified of scrutiny, and may not be eager to share their code, data, or other details of their work.What can be done to increase women's participation in academic criticisms? Is this wise given the potential risks and professional blowback?DK: I think a promising approach is to make it easier and more rewarding for researchers to participate. To even start to scrutinize or replicate a paper, researchers must be able to access its data, code, and methods. BITSS does a great job at educating scholars on why and how to do transparent and reproducible research.One way to prevent authors from feeling singled out when their work is criticized or replicated may be to conduct replications via a "replication audit," an organized effort by multiple researchers to replicate a large number of studies. The Replication Games [convened by I4R,] is one such effort. Researchers may find it more attractive to participate in replication audits than to replicate a single study on their own.Afterwards, replicators become coauthors of a meta-paper that combines the different replications conducted, but their names are not associated with the particular paper they replicated. To increase participation of women and other researchers in academic criticisms, we need more of this type of careful design of the incentives and institutions.In March, alongside the American Economic Association's Committee on the Status of Women in the Economics Profession and Economists for Equity at UC Berkeley, CEGA will co-host the Berkeley Replication Games, which will focus on the participation of underrepresented researchers.To find out more and register, check out our event page.The Gender Gap in Academic Criticism was originally published in CEGA on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.

Governments and government agencies are frequently the subject of criticism from the public, media, and politicians, over issues of inefficiency and bureaucracy. In new research, Jan Boon, Jan Wynen and Koen Verhoest find that exposure to these criticisms and the reputational damage that they can do can lead to government agencies having more rigid bureaucracies. … Continued

"Blocking entire sections of the internet based on the outdated belief that all Tor network traffic is indistinguishable or malicious is a mistake," the Tor Project spokesperson said.

A N.J. judge has thrown out the lawsuit, on the narrow grounds that, even if the newspaper deliberately discouraged people from attending the group's charity gala, the N.J. Law Against Discrimination doesn't apply to charity galas.

After the Oct. 7 murders, the first attempts to punish speakers focused on those who defended Hamas's murders. But, unsurprisingly, things have turned to trying to suppress criticism of Israel more broadly, including criticism of Israel's attacks on Gaza. (The slippery slope is a real phenomenon, in a culture where people reason by precedent and…

After three days of large-scale protests, domestic and international criticism the draft bill nevertheless passed the first reading at the parliament.

leads some readers to engage in "threats and harassment" against the business.

"We are adamant that the hiring committee...not extend a job offer to Dr. Yoel Inbar," reads the petition.

In 2021, the Goncourt Prize was awarded to a Senegalese author, Mohamed Mbougar Sarr. Does this, however, imply that Francophone African literatures are known and recognized at their true value?

It's been nearly 14 years since former President Barack Obama signed the Affordable Care Act into law. Why are some Republican presidential candidates again calling for its end?

"Senator Mitt Romney threatens to leave the Republican party and join Democrats."

"Senator Mitt Romney threatens to leave the Republican party and join Democrats."

So holds an Eleventh Circuit panel; Judge Andrew Brasher's concurring opinion that notes the potential First Amendment problems with imposing liability for such speech.

After a presence since 1972, China celebrates 51 years of cooperation with Togo in 2023. While Lomé and Beijing publicize an ideal relationship, the reality on the ground is more complicated.