Suchergebnisse

학위논문(석사)--서울대학교 대학원 :사회과학대학 정치외교학부(외교학전공),2019. 8. 박성우. ; The study of Rousseau's international politics can largely be divided into two main branches: Realism with a pessimistic view towards peace in international politics and Cosmopolitanism via education as depicted in Emile. However, neither interpretation exhaustively covers Rousseau's international political thought. Accepting the framework that International Political Thought should coherently and consistently interpret the individual, national, and international levels of politics, this thesis embodies Stoicism's 'Theory of Oikeiosis' to assess Rousseau's international political thought, focusing on Emile. This study pays attention to Emile because the study of humans embodied in the work contains both a discussion of all three layers – the individual, national and the international - of Rousseau's international political thought, and enough materials to infer his 'Politics of Survival.' Previous studies of Emile has primarily been published by cosmopolitans to invoke idealistic ideas such as conscience, morality, and patriotism. If put under a more realist lens, however, the same ideas could be interpreted as a part of living his life for Emile, or the individual, under the goal of self-preservation. Early in his life, Emile grows up with only negative education as an isolated individual and learns how to live alone. Later, Emile gradually learns how to interact with the society, breaking from his isolated shell to live as a part of a community. In this process, Emile establishes a political society and utilizes concepts that he garnered while in it, such as morality and religion, according to his goal of self-preservation. Although Emile fulfills his duties as a citizen of a Republic, ideas such as civic virtue and patriotism that were created within the country do not initially extend to the outside world. With time, however, Emile's world view expands to encompass the entire human population, and Emile comes to care for even communities outside of his direct community. When the idea of a confederation of countries to resolve the state of war outside of the community turns out to be unfeasible, Rousseau adopts a new solution for the international political situation which is for each individual to strive to do their best in the given situation such as by finding a safe place for his or her freedom of survival. This thesis scrutinizes Emile to depict this process, of the individual striving for survival beyond the community and extending to the nation, international politics, and the entire universe. This research interprets Rousseau's international political thought as 'International Political Thought of Survival' by repurposing cosmopolitan internal mechanisms as tools for survival, while also distinguishing itself from realism by underlining Rousseau's negative pacifism. As such, this thesis provides a balance between the cosmopolitan and realist interpretations of Rousseau's international politics and also attempts to bridge the rift between his national and international political thought by extracting 'survival' as a consistent idea embedded throughout the levels. Moreover, this study criticizes the realist international political theorists' arbitrary selection and selective interpretation of Rousseau and argues the need for a more diversified approach to Rousseau's international political thought. ; 루소의 국제정치관에 대한 연구는 크게 국제정치 상황에서 평화를 비관적으로 바라보는 현실주의와 『에밀』에서의 교육을 통해 국제적 평화를 이룰 수 있다는 세계시민주의의 두가지 갈래로 나눌 수 있다. 그러나 이러한 해석들이 가지는 문제점은 루소의 정치사상이 두 극단의 측면을 모두 지니고 있는 점을 포괄하기 어렵기에, 루소의 국제정치사상을 좀 더 잘 이해할 수 있는 모습으로 재해석할 여지를 준다. 특히 국제정치사상이 개인과 국가 그리고 국제정치의 일관성있는 해석을 가져야 한다는 틀에 입각하여, 스토아사상에서 비롯된 '자기화 이론'을 참고해 『에밀』을 중심으로 루소의 국제정치사상을 살펴본다. 본 연구가 『에밀』에 주목하는 이유는 이 저작에서 드러나는 인간학이 루소 국제정치사상의 여러 층위(개인-국가-국제관계)에 대한 논의를 모두 포함하고 있으면서, '생존의 정치학'을 설명하기에 적합한 내용을 담고 있기 때문이다. 흔히 『에밀』은 세계시민주의자들에게 주로 사용되어 양심이나, 덕성, 애국심 등의 관념을 이상주의적 관점으로 해석하는 데 활용된다. 그러나 『에밀』의 내용을 좀 더 현실주의적 차원에서 논의해본다면, 이들은 모두 자기보존이라는 목표 아래 에밀 개인이 삶을 살아내기 위한 과정의 일부로 볼 수 있다. 초기 에밀은 고립된 개인으로서 소극적 교육을 받으며 자라는데, 이동안은 혼자서 사는 법을 배운다. 이후 에밀은 점차 주변 사회와 관계하는 법을 배우게 되는데, 인간의 마음과 사회를 알아가면서 점점 고립된 인간을 지나 공동체에서 살아가는 법을 깨닫는다. 주변 사회를 알아가게 된 에밀은 정치공동체를 세우고 그 안에서 배운 도덕성과 종교 등의 관념을 자신의 생존방식에 맞게 사용한다. 공화국 내 시민이 된 에밀은 책임감으로 국가 내에서의 의무를 다하지만, 시민적 덕성이나 애국심 등 한 국가 안에서 만들어질 수 있는 관념들은 외부 세계까지 확장되지 않는다. 그렇지만 에밀의 세계관은 인류 전체를 포함하는 인식으로까지 확대되고, 에밀은 공동체 밖의 공동체를 신경쓰는 인간이 된다. 공동체 밖의 전쟁상태에서 국가적 연합은 하나의 해결책으로 제시되지만 이는 실현불가능한 것으로 판명나고, 루소의 국제정치적 해결책은 '생존의 자유'를 위해 가장 안전한 장소를 찾는 등 개인이 생존을 위해 계속적으로 주어진 바에서 최선을 다하는 노력의 방식을 채택하고 있다. 결과적으로 본 연구에서는 『에밀』을 통해 개인이 공동체를 넘어 국가와 국제정치 그리고 우주 전체를 아우르는 세계관 안에서 생존이라는 목표를 위해 달려가는 모습을 보여준다. 본 연구는 세계시민주의자들이 사용하는 내적 기제들을 생존을 위한 도구적 측면에서 활용하면서도, 소극적 의미의 평화론을 통해 현실주의와도 거리를 두며 '생존의 국제정치사상'으로 루소 국제정치사상을 재해석하고 있다. 이는 횡으로는 루소 국제정치관의 해석에 대한 중도적 균형을 잡으면서도, 종으로는 생존이라는 매개를 통해 국내정치와 국제정치 간의 균열을 메울 수 있는 가능성을 제시한다. 더불어 본 연구는 지금까지 현실주의 국제정치이론에서 루소의 정치사상을 부분적으로 인용해왔던 것에 대해 비판을 던지면서 루소 국제정치사상을 좀 더 다각적으로 접근할 필요가 있음을 주장한다. ; Ⅰ. 서 론 1 1. 문제제기와 연구질문 1 2. 기존문헌 검토 및 분석 3 1) 루소의 국제정치관에 대한 연구 3 2) 루소의 국제정치를 현실주의 관점에서 바라본 연구 7 3) 루소의 국제정치를 세계시민주의 관점에서 바라본 연구 9 4) 본 연구의 방향성: 루소의 국제정치사상 재해석 12 3. 본 연구의 접근법 14 1) 일관성의 국제정치사상 14 2) 스토아철학과 히에로클레스의 동심원 16 4. 논문의 구성 18 Ⅱ. 예비적 고찰 21 1. 『에밀』의 중요성과 해석방법 21 2. 생존의 정치학 25 Ⅲ. 개인에서 공동체로 31 1. 고립된 개인과 소극적 자유 31 1) 소극적 교육 31 2) 고독한 인간 33 2. 인간의 마음을 알아가는 것 35 1) 생존과 자기애 35 2) 사회를 알아가는 것 38 Ⅳ. 공동체 속의 개인 41 1. 도덕성과 종교의 역할 41 1) 동정심을 기반으로 한 양심과 이성의 작용 41 2) 도덕성과 종교의 관계 45 3) 정치공동체 안에서 일반의지의 역할 47 4) 정치와 종교 49 (1) 정치적 도구로서의 시민종교 50 (2) 입법과 통치에서의 종교 활용 52 2. 이상국가 속의 개인 55 1) 이상국가의 설립 가능성 55 2) 공화국과 시민적 덕성 58 3) 애국심과 세계시민주의 60 Ⅴ. 공동체 밖의 개인 64 1. 인식의 확장 64 1) 공동체 밖의 공동체 64 2) 우주적 질서에 대한 인식 66 2. 국가적 연합과 영구평화를 위한 해결책 69 3. 생존을 위한 계획 73 1) 가장 안전한 장소 73 2) 소극적 평화론과 생존의 의미 76 Ⅵ. 결 론 78 1. 생존의 국제정치사상 78 2. 본 연구의 목적과 함의 79 참고문헌 82 Abstract 88 ; Master

The idea of Vietnam's opening, cooperating and integrating into the world has been sprung up in the very early days of the modern Vietnamese diplomacy under the leadership of President Ho Chi Minh. In the Doi Moi era, with creative application of Ho Chi Minh's Thoughts on international cooperation and integration, the Communist Party of Vietnam has gradually supplemented, improved and developed its perception on international integration in accordance with the evaluation of the world situation, international relations, new trends, the interactive relations between Vietnam and the world, opportunities and challenges for Vietnam in realizing the goals of security, development and raising its position in the international arena. The research paper will focus on studying the evolution of the Communist Party of Vietnam's perception on international integration, a crucial factor contributing to significant achievements in the cause of national renovation in general and foreign policy renewal in particular. ; Tư tưởng mở cửa, hợp tác và hội nhập với thế giới của Việt Nam đã được hình thành từ những ngày đầu tiên của nền ngoại giao Việt Nam hiện đại, dưới sự lãnh đạo của Chủ tịch Hồ Chí Minh. Bước sang thời kỳ Đổi Mới, vận dụng sáng tạo Tư tưởng Hồ Chí Minh về hợp tác và hội nhập quốc tế, Đảng Cộng sản Việt Nam đã từng bước hoàn thiện, bổ sung và phát triển tư duy về hội nhập quốc tế trên cơ sở đánh giá tình hình thế giới, quan hệ quốc tế, các xu thế mới, các mối tương quan giữa Việt Nam và thế giới cũng như những cơ hội và thách thức đối với Việt Nam trong việc thực hiện các mục tiêu đảm bảo an ninh, phát triển và nâng cao vị thế của đất nước. Bài viết tập trung tìm hiểu quá trình phát triển tư duy của Đảng Cộng sản Việt Nam về hội nhập quốc tế, nhân tố quan trọng góp phần đem lại những thành tựu đáng kể trong sự nghiệp đổi mới đất nước nói chung và đổi mới về đối ngoại nói riêng.

International economic integration is one of the major policies of the Vietnam's Government and the Communist Party of Vietnam (CPV) in the time of doi moi (renovation). This policy has been mentioned in several important resolutions and been implemented intensively since the Ninth National Congress of CPV. Through the national congresses of CPV, the policy of international economic integration has had new developments with new contents which have met the requirements of the domestic situation and matched with the general trend of our time. The Eleventh National Congress of CPV have developed the policy of foreign relations to a new height, in which international integration has become a major orientation of foreign relations. With this orientation, the characteristics and the level of international intergation have been improved, the scope of international integration has been extended. ; Hội nhập kinh tế quốc tế là một chủ trương lớn của Đảng và Nhà nước ta trong thời kỳ đổi mới. Chủ trương đó đã được đề cập đến trong nhiều nghị quyết quan trọng và được triển khai mạnh mẽ từ Đại hội IX đến nay. Qua các kỳ Đại hội Đảng, chủ trương hội nhập kinh tế quốc tế đã có những bước phát triển mới với những nội dung mới, vừa đáp ứng đòi hỏi của tình hình trong nước vừa phù hợp với xu thế chung của thời đại. Đại hội XI của Đảng đã phát triển đường lối, chính sách đối ngoại lên một tầm cao mới, trong đó, hội nhập quốc tế trở thành định hướng đối ngoại lớn. Với định hướng này, tính chất và trình độ hội nhập quốc tế được nâng cao, phạm vi hội nhập quốc tế được mở rộng.

Δεν παρατίθεται περἰληψη στα ελληνικά. ; Lina Venturas – Dimitria Groutsis, The Cold War and international migration regulation: The establishment of the Intergovernmental Committee for European Migration The immediate post WWII period saw the establishment of the Inter-governmental Committee for European Migration (ICEM) (now International Organisation for Migration, IOM), as a key organisation in the management of post WWII migration. This paper examines the debates and policies surrounding the creation of the ICEM as an agent responsible for the facilitation and administration of labour migration from parts of Europe to a variety of overseas countries. At the conclusion of the Second World War, the problems surrounding 'surplus population' and unemployment in Europe were discussed in many international forums. It was from these discussions that a consensus emerged which saw emigration as a viable solution. To this end, in 1951, the International Labour Organisation convened a Migration Conference in Naples, bringing together key stakeholders. The Naples Conference failed, an outcome driven mainly by the US. The US was particularly concerned with economic stagnation and mounting social unrest related to the 'surplus population' in European countries in this Cold War period. At the same time however, it strived at limiting international influence over migration and refugee policies and on receiving countries retaining their sovereign immigration policies. In spite of the disagreements and through a process of negotiation, the US subsequently led the creation of an intergovernmental body, which was established at a conference convened in Brussels in 1951. This newly formed organisation, initially named the Provisional Intergovernmental Committee for the Movement of Migrants from Europe (PICMME), was open only to states with a 'liberal' political regime and had specifically designed functions based on inter-governmental negotiations. The US ensured its predominance in the organization through budgetary control and other means. In 1953, the PICMME became a permanent 'fixture' of migration regulation and was renamed the Intergovernmental Committee for European Migration (ICEM). Hereafter, ICEM offered operational and financial assistance for migrants' transportation, language training, reception facilities, settlement services and labour market placement.

Δεν παρατίθεται περίληψη στα ελληνικά. ; Alexandros N. Teneketzis, Art and Politics in Cold War. The International Sculpture Competition for the Monument to the Unknown Political Prisoner The gradual transfer of the metropolis of the western art world from Paris to New York and specifically in circles around the Museum of Modern Art (MOMA) under the leadership of Alfred H. Barr Jr. and with the theoretical foundation by Clement Greenberg, but practically under the guidance and financing from the CIA, was also visible in the case of public memory and art about the Second World War. The international institution that was the cause for the widespread diffusion of the artistic standards grown in USA was the "International Sculpture Competition for the Monument to the Unknown Political Prisoner", which was organized under the auspices of the Institute of Contemporary Arts (ICA) in London and the Tate Gallery, but actually with the encouragement, blessings and supervision of the CIA. The competition was from the beginning a large turnout and the proposals submitted until January 1953 surpassed 3.500 –mainly abstract or semi­abstract stylistic suggestions. The biggest names at the time in the international arena of sculpture in West took part, while artists from the Eastern Bloc boycotted the process. Therefore were precluded any realistic academic representative works and of course any relationship with socialist realism, giving thus the tone for both the style, and for all other future monuments in the western world. Eventually, the first prize of 2.500 pounds awarded to the British sculptor Reg Butler, unknown to the general public until that time but with a decisive commitment to abstraction. However, the work of Butler was never completed, principally because of the changing international circumstances and relationships after the death of Stalin in '53 and Khrushchev's secret speech in '56. The new "Thaw" era in East­West relations imposed the final rejection in 1960. A public monument like that of Butler's, which would refer to the previous tense situation, was no more possible. Nevertheless, the dual objective of recognition and legitimization of abstract art in the western world and at the same time of the weakening of socialist realism and therefore of communism was promoted and achieved up to a certain degree.

Zoi Mella, The Greek Civil War and the Spanish Press during Franco's DictatorshipIn this article we would like to approach a quite unknown subject: the presence of the Greek Civil War in the Spanish Press. Our objective was to ascertain the impact this event had at the post war Spanish Press. How would react Spain in view of such a confrontation, especially since it had already experimented a Civil War? It was a complicated period for Greece, as well as for Spain, a time when both countries experienced problems of different nature but equally serious: Greece was suffering the devastating consequences of the Second World War and Spain was trying to encounter the contempt of the international political world. The Greek Civil War was the first confrontation between two worlds that were exiting reinforced from the Second World War. It became the field of conflict between the USSR and the Anglo-Saxon allies during several years. The interior problem of some rebels, who couldn't, or wouldn't, adapt themselves to the new post war situation or were discontented with the new regime, was transformed to an international matter of great impact, that managed to confront USSR, on one hand, and the US and Great Britain, on the other, in the International Organism of the United Nations. Our interest was centred in the various approaches that the newspapers and the magazines of the time made. Moreover we were interested in the points of view and the conclusions manifested by the diverse papers, according to their political and ideological affinities, without forgetting the strict regime of control and censure that was in force at that moment. This investigation forms part of a broader subject that is the bilateral relations of these two countries, rather different at first sight, that during the XX century were affected by very similar events, such as a civil war. ; Zoi Mella, The Greek Civil War and the Spanish Press during Franco's DictatorshipIn this article we would like to approach a quite unknown subject: the presence of the Greek Civil War in the Spanish Press. Our objective was to ascertain the impact this event had at the post war Spanish Press. How would react Spain in view of such a confrontation, especially since it had already experimented a Civil War? It was a complicated period for Greece, as well as for Spain, a time when both countries experienced problems of different nature but equally serious: Greece was suffering the devastating consequences of the Second World War and Spain was trying to encounter the contempt of the international political world. The Greek Civil War was the first confrontation between two worlds that were exiting reinforced from the Second World War. It became the field of conflict between the USSR and the Anglo-Saxon allies during several years. The interior problem of some rebels, who couldn't, or wouldn't, adapt themselves to the new post war situation or were discontented with the new regime, was transformed to an international matter of great impact, that managed to confront USSR, on one hand, and the US and Great Britain, on the other, in the International Organism of the United Nations. Our interest was centred in the various approaches that the newspapers and the magazines of the time made. Moreover we were interested in the points of view and the conclusions manifested by the diverse papers, according to their political and ideological affinities, without forgetting the strict regime of control and censure that was in force at that moment. This investigation forms part of a broader subject that is the bilateral relations of these two countries, rather different at first sight, that during the XX century were affected by very similar events, such as a civil war.

Konstantinos Katsoudas, "A Dictatorship that is not a Dictatorship". Spanish Nationalists and the 4th of August The Spanish Civil War convulsed the international public opinion and prompted most foreign governments to take measures or even intervene in the conflict. Greek entanglement either in the form of smuggling war materiel or the participation of Greek volunteers in the International Brigades has already been investigated. However, little is known about a second dimension of this internationalization of the war: the peculiar forms that the antagonism between the two belligerent camps in foreign countries took. This paper, based mainly on Spanish archival sources, discusses some aspects of the activity developed in Greece by Franco's nationalists and the way Francoist diplomats and emissaries perceived the nature of an apparently similar regime, such as the dictatorship led by general Metaxas. The main objectives of the Francoist foreign policy were to avoid any escalation of the Spanish civil war into a world conflict, to secure international assistance for the right-wing forces and to undermine the legitimacy of the legal Republican government. In Greece, an informal diplomatic civil war broke out since Francoists occupied the Spanish Legation in Athens and Republicans took over the Consulate in Thessaloniki. The Francoists combined public and undercover activity: they worked hard to achieve an official recognition of their Estado Nuevo, while at the same time created rings of espionage and channels of anticommunist propaganda. The reason of their partial breakthroughs was that, contrary to their Republican enemies, the Nationalists enjoyed support by a significant part of the Greek political world, which was ideologically identified with their struggle. Francoist anti-communism had some interesting implications for Greek politics. An important issue was the Francoist effort to reveal a supposed Moscow-based conspiracy against Spain and Greece, both considered as hotbeds of revolution in the Mediterranean, in order to justify both Franco's extermination campaign and Metaxas' coup. Although this effort was based on fraudulent documents, forged by an anti-Bolshevik international organization, it became the cornerstone of Francoist and Metaxist propaganda. General Metaxas was the only European dictator to invoke the Spanish Civil War as a raison d'etre of his regime and often warned against the repetition of Spanish-like drama on Greek soil. Nevertheless he did not approve of Franco's methods and preferred Dr. Salazar's Portugal as an institutional model closer to his vision. For Spanish nationalist observers this was a sign of weakness. They interpreted events in Greece through the disfiguring mirror of their own historic experience: thus, although they never called in question Metaxas' authoritarian motives, the 4th of August regime was considered too mild and soft compared to Francoism (whose combativeness and fanaticism, as they suggested, the Greek General should have imitated); it reminded them the dictatorship founded in Spain by General Primo de Rivera in 1920s, whose inadequacy paved the way for the advent of the Republic and the emergence of sociopolitical radicalism. Incidents of the following years, as Greece moved towards a civil confrontation, seemed to strengthen their views. ; Konstantinos Katsoudas, "A Dictatorship that is not a Dictatorship". Spanish Nationalists and the 4th of AugustThe Spanish Civil War convulsed the international public opinion and prompted most foreign governments to take measures or even intervene in the conflict. Greek entanglement either in the form of smuggling war materiel or the participation of Greek volunteers in the International Brigades has already been investigated. However, little is known about a second dimension of this internationalization of the war: the peculiar forms that the antagonism between the two belligerent camps in foreign countries took. This paper, based mainly on Spanish archival sources, discusses some aspects of the activity developed in Greece by Franco's nationalists and the way Francoist diplomats and emissaries perceived the nature of an apparently similar regime, such as the dictatorship led by general Metaxas. The main objectives of the Francoist foreign policy were to avoid any escalation of the Spanish civil war into a world conflict, to secure international assistance for the right-wing forces and to undermine the legitimacy of the legal Republican government. In Greece, an informal diplomatic civil war broke out since Francoists occupied the Spanish Legation in Athens and Republicans took over the Consulate in Thessaloniki. The Francoists combined public and undercover activity: they worked hard to achieve an official recognition of their Estado Nuevo, while at the same time created rings of espionage and channels of anticommunist propaganda. The reason of their partial breakthroughs was that, contrary to their Republican enemies, the Nationalists enjoyed support by a significant part of the Greek political world, which was ideologically identified with their struggle. Francoist anti-communism had some interesting implications for Greek politics. An important issue was the Francoist effort to reveal a supposed Moscow-based conspiracy against Spain and Greece, both considered as hotbeds of revolution in the Mediterranean, in order to justify both Franco's extermination campaign and Metaxas' coup. Although this effort was based on fraudulent documents, forged by an anti-Bolshevik international organization, it became the cornerstone of Francoist and Metaxist propaganda. General Metaxas was the only European dictator to invoke the Spanish Civil War as a raison d'etre of his regime and often warned against the repetition of Spanish-like drama on Greek soil. Nevertheless he did not approve of Franco's methods and preferred Dr. Salazar's Portugal as an institutional model closer to his vision. For Spanish nationalist observers this was a sign of weakness. They interpreted events in Greece through the disfiguring mirror of their own historic experience: thus, although they never called in question Metaxas' authoritarian motives, the 4th of August regime was considered too mild and soft compared to Francoism (whose combativeness and fanaticism, as they suggested, the Greek General should have imitated); it reminded them the dictatorship founded in Spain by General Primo de Rivera in 1920s, whose inadequacy paved the way for the advent of the Republic and the emergence of sociopolitical radicalism. Incidents of the following years, as Greece moved towards a civil confrontation, seemed to strengthen their views.

Δεν παρατίθεται περίληψη στα ελληνικά. ; Anna Mahera, Émigration et développement économique dans la Grèce d'après guerre. L'approche du problème par le milieu politique de Centre-gauche Dans les premières années de l'après guerre, en Grèce se pose de nouveau le problème du mode de développement économique. En effet, la perspective de l'arrivée massive des capitaux américains en combinaison avec la disponibilité d'une main-d'oeuvre autochtone créent des conditions favorables à un projet d'industrialisation. C'est au sein des milieux politiques grecques qu'un tel projet est élaboré, alors que les instances internationales —comme le Food and Agriculture Organisation des Nations Unies— signalent les graves difficultés à surmonter. Progressivement, dans le climat de la guerre froide des années 1950, la quasi-totalité des forces politiques grecques ont abandonné l'idée d'un développement industriel, admettant la position subalterne occupée par le pays dans la division internationale du travail. Celui-ci doit se contenter au rôle de fournisseur de main-d'oeuvre vers les pays européens, en particulier vers l'Allemagne, en phase de reconstruction économique, à travers Γ émigration du travail qui prend une grande ampleur dans les années 1950 et 1960. Tout au plus, la Grèce peut-elle envisager le développement du secteur des services. Contrairement aux autres forces politiques, le Centre-gauche a parcouru ce chemin avec une décennie de retard, en raison de la présence en son sein d'une réflexion économique affirmée, émanant d'économistes de haut niveau, orientés vers l'économie de la planification, et peut-être aussi à cause de l'éloignement de ce milieu du jeu politique immédiat. Le rangement du Centre-gauche à la politique officielle d'émigration intereuropéenne a marqué la fin d'une période de fermentation sur le projet d'industrialisation de la Grèce dont l'origine remonte à l'entre-deux-guerres.

학위논문 (석사)-- 서울대학교 대학원 : 외교학과, 2012. 2. 신범식. ; 본 논문의 핵심 질문은 색깔 혁명 발생으로 민주화에 성공한 그루지야와 우크라이나의 이후 민주주의 발전 양상은 왜 달랐는가이다. 색깔 혁명 이후, 우크라이나의 민주주의는 진전을 보였지만, 그루지야는 그렇지 못했다. 본 연구는 색깔혁명 이후 미국과 러시아의 갈등 구도와 양국의 대(對) 그루지야, 우크라이나 정책이 각국의 국내 엘리트-대중 관계에서 엘리트 자율성, 그리고 민주화에 미친 영향에 주목하였다. 9.11 테러 이후 미국과 러시아는 협력 체제에 있었지만, 색깔 혁명의 발생으로 인해 양국은 갈등 구도에 들어서게 된다. 그루지야와 우크라이나는 미․러 갈등 구도의 중심에 있었다. 활용가능성의 요인으로 인해, 그루지야는 우크라이나보다 전략적 가치가 더 큰 곳이었다. 미․러 갈등 구도 속에서 그루지야 집권 엘리트들은 높은 엘리트 자율성을 가질 수 있었다. 미국은 그루지야에게 큰 경제 원조, 정치적 지원을 하였다. 또한 그루지야-러시아 관계 악화와 2008년 전쟁 발발은 정권의 권위주의 정책을 정당화하고 국내를 결집시키는 기제로 작용하여 그루지야 집권 엘리트들이 높은 자율성을 갖게 해주었고, 이는 민주화 저해로 이어졌다. 우크라이나는 그루지야와 반대였다. 미․러 갈등 구도 속에서 우크라이나 엘리트들은 낮은 자율성을 가졌다. 우크라이나의 집권 엘리트들은 서방과 러시아 양측 모두로부터 확고한 정치적, 경제적 지원을 얻을 수 없었다. 오히려 러시아의 정책으로 인해 국내의 반 오렌지, 대항 엘리트가 공고해지면서, 집권 엘리트의 자율성은 낮아졌다. 엘리트들의 낮은 자율성과 대중에 대한 높은 의존성은 대중 영합주의 정책과 정국 불안의 결과를 낳았으나, 이는 오렌지 혁명 이후 우크라이나 민주주의의 발전을 제한적으로나마 가능하게 해주었다. 본 연구는 민주화 연구에서 그동안 비교적 주목을 덜 받아온 국제적 요인을 다루고, 외교 정책, 국내 엘리트-대중 관계, 민주화의 연계를 통합적으로 보여준다는 점에서 함의가 있다. 본고는 많은 기존 연구들이 상정해 온, 민주화에 대한 서구 민주화 증진 정책의 긍정적 영향과 권위주의 국가의 부정적 영향이라는 단순한 명제의 한계를 드러내주고 있다. 또한 민주주의 지원 정책에서 민주화 단계별로 정책을 달리할 필요성에 대해서 시사한다. ; What caused the difference in democratic trajectories between Georgia and Ukraine after the Color Revolutions? Since the occurrence of the Color Revolutions, Georgia's democracy has laid in tatters, whereas Ukraine has achieved a relatively successful democracy. Georgia and Ukraine share similar domestic determinants which have been discussed in previous democratization literature. This study, however, focuses on the international factor as an explanation for the different democratic fates of democracy between the two countries. Comparing both countries, this thesis uses a framework that integrates international factors, elite autonomy in domestic elite-mass relations, and democratization. The study argues that international factors, specifically the foreign policies of the US and Russia, provide an explanation for the difference in democratic outcomes for the two countries. Following the events of September 11, 2001, US-Russian relations improved. However, the occurrence of the Color Revolutions caused deterioration in the ties between the two countries, and both started to adopt different foreign policies towards the post-Soviet region. Caught in the middle of this conflict between the two great powers were Georgia and Ukraine. The unconditional US support for Georgia and Russia's assertive policy towards Georgia which culminated in the Russian-Georgian War in 2008 enabled the Georgian elites to attain high elite autonomy, thus resulting in democratic stagnation for Georgia. In contrast, Ukraine did not garner the support of either the US or Russia; rather, it was pressured by Russia. The anti-Orange elites in Ukraine were effectively supported by Russia, and, thus, were able to function as a forceful political opposition to the incumbent elites. Therefore, the Ukrainian elites only garnered low autonomy, which resulted in democratic progress in Ukraine despite domestic political chaos. This study contributes to further understanding of the impact of international factors upon democratization. In addition, this thesis creates implications for democracy promotion policy. The conclusion of the thesis challenges the predominant assumption that Western democracy promotion is conducive to actually democratization, and that authoritarian countries' authoritarian promotion policy is harmful to democratization. In the process of democracy promotion policy, policymakers and implementers need both careful monitoring of the process of democratic assistance and coordination with other countries. ; Master

Between 1995 and 2011, Peruvian GDP grew by 4.9% each year, driven by exports and private investment's increase. However, it only grew by 3.3% in 2015 and by 4% in 2016 due to a reduction in the international price of metals that the country exports. In this scenario, the government elected in 2011 faced the challenge of replacing private investment with public investment as a growth engine. However, this decision revealed two structural problems of the Peruvian economy: 1) the limited spending capacity of central and regional governments; and 2) the difficulty of increasing tax collection due to a very significant informal sector in the country. However, trade liberalization, stability in domestic prices and reforms in public management are strengths of the Peruvian economy, which would enable it to return in the next few years to growth rates of around 4% or more.

학위논문(석사)--서울대학교 대학원 :행정대학원 행정학과(정책학전공),2019. 8. 권혁주. ; Korea's official development assistance (ODA) budget has been steadily expanding since its accession to the OECD in 2010. Meanwhile, Korea's ODA has been diversified by various implementing agencies. There have been many previous researches on effective implementation system to improve the effectiveness of ODA projects. In 2010, through the establishment of the Act on International Development Cooperation, the function of organizing and coordinating policies in ODA of the International Development Cooperation Committee has been strengthened. However, little case-based research has been done on what adjustments are actually made in the committee. The purpose of this study is to analyze the policy coordination cases of the International Development Cooperation Committee and to examine the factors influencing policy coordination in international development cooperation. The target of the analysis is the case of the integration of the overseas volunteer dispatch project into the WFK(World Friends Korea), which started in 2009 and has been in progress until 2019. In 2008, the Lee Myung-bak government set up a national policy task to dispatch 20,000 volunteer overseas. In this regard, discussions have begun on the need to integrate the overseas volunteer dispatch projects being promoted by all ministries into WFK program, which is being promoted by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and primary integration by the leadership of the President in 2009 ~ 2010 was achieved. In the meantime, since 2016, the International Cooperation Committee has been discussing the integration of volunteer dispatch projects that have not been integrated yet. As a result, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs has promoted discussions on integrated promotion. The related projects were programs of the Ministry of Health and Welfare, Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, Ministry of Patriots and Veterans Affairs, Korea Meteorological Administration, Fair Trade Commission, Ministry of Education. The research methodology first outlines the theories and researches on the influencing factors of policy coordination and selected the factors that might influence the policy coordination of international development cooperation. Based on the selected factors, the analysis framework was established and hypotheses were established. The analysis was conducted based on the analysis framework and the hypothesis was verified for the eight projects of six ministries in the case. In this study, the concept of policy coordination was focused on the integrated promotion aspect of inter-ministerial policies for enhancing synergy rather than solving policy conflicts among ministries considering the characteristics of international development cooperation issues. According to the theoretical discussion, the policy coordination is based on the hierarchical system, the network system, and the market system, and the International Development Cooperation Committee is considered as a coordinating mechanism for interactions among various participants in network system. In the previous researches on the factors influencing the general policy adjustment, it was pointed out that attributes of the issue and participant, leadership are important in policy coordination. On the other hand, previous researches in the field of international development cooperation have been studied mainly in terms of improvement of the institutional aspects, and prior studies on the factors influencing the adjustment are rare. Based on the previous research and theoretical discussions of network view on policy coordination, three factors were identified as factors influencing the policy coordination of international development cooperation. Those are the degree of internalization of the unique policy viewpoint of the network participants, disposition tendency of the participants on the policy, and the leadership level of the President and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs. For each factor, detailed sub-indicators were set up. First, we considered the existence of dedicated implementation agencies, the use of specific policy resources, and the presence of interest groups as criteria for the degree of internalization of the unique policy view. In case of domain dispute tendency, the absolute amount and proportion of budget and the key policy areas. Third, in the case of leadership, the level of leadership of the president and the policy coordination institute (Ministry of Foreign Affairs) was considered. Eight projects from the six ministries had different degrees for each of the three factors, which affected the results of the strategies and adjustments chosen by the individual ministries in the policy coordination network. First, the Ministry of Health and Welfare carries out its own voluntary work by a non-profit corporation called the Korean Oriental Medical Service Group, but its degree of internalization of the policy perspective is not so high due to the small grant amount and the existence of multiple sponsors in the corps. In addition, and the number of stakeholders in Korea was not so high. However, the MHW restructured its business due to the President 's overseas trip, and the MHW stopped the business. The project is now integrated into the WFK platform. In the case of the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, there is a high level of internalization of the policy perspective. The program is implemented by the traditional performing arts promotion foundation, which is a nonprofit foundation under MCST. In addition, it utilizes related majored students and its Korean Culture Center abroad. Moreover, the program is closely related to the main policy areas of MCST such as the operation of overseas Korea Cultural Center. As a conclusion, MCST decided to leave the network and converted the program into non-ODA domain to continue the program. In the Ministry of Patriots and Veterans Affairs, there were two projects: the medical service project of the 6.25 participating countries and the medical service project in Vietnam. First, the medical service project of 6.25 participating countries, which had relatively low importance in MPVA, and which did not have any interest groups, was abandoned. However, the Vietnamese medical service project, which has a dedicated agency and strong interest group, and was chosen to be remained by being moved into non-ODA domain. The Korea Meteorological Administration utilizes unique policy resources and the KMA also adopted the non-ODA method to continue the project. In the case of the Fair Trade Commission, the proram is about dispatching FTC's internal employees overseas. Therefore, both the degree of internalization of the viewpoint and the tendency to dispute the domain were high. However, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs did not promote the integration of the FTC project, and it seems that mutual recognition is made that the project is not subject to integration between the two ministries. In the case of the Ministry of Education, there is a high degree of internalization of the policy perspective due to the fact that the responsible administration agency is in operation, utilizes its own policy resources, and there is a strong teacher interest group. In addition, the amount of the program's budget is very large, and the tendency to dispute the policy region is also high. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs has shown a strong commitment to coordinate with the MOE's program since 2019, but the MOE is keep refusing it. We analyzed the cases of 8 projects of these 6 departments through analysis framework. The different factors that existed on each department triggered different strategies within the network for each department, and we observed that the result of the policy adjustment was different. In addition, the original hypothesis was verified. First, the greater the discrepancy in the viewpoint of the policy, the more unfavorable the policy coordination. Second, the larger the ministry's domain dispute tendency, the more disadvantageous the policy coordination. Third, the greater the leadership of the president and the policy coordination institute, the more favorable the policy coordination. Although this study was intended to detail the processes and achievements of policy coordination in the international development cooperation of Korea through actual cases, it was difficult to access the every minutes of the network participants' meetings, and inference was used to deduce the behavior of individual participants (ministries) through the review of official document. Therefore, it was only a rough explanation. However, the purpose of this study is to suggest that the main variables that actually affect the results of policy coordination in the International Development Cooperation Committee in Korea, the understanding of the process of policy coordination through committee among participants from a network perspective, and the microstatement of the behavior of the representatives of individual ministries in the course of the policy coordination. In the future, we look forward to expanding the scope of the research, including another example of policy coordination through the International Development Cooperation Committee, so that the results of the study can be generalized. ; 우리나라의 공적개발원조(ODA) 예산은 2010년 OECD 가입 이후로 지속적으로 확대되어 왔다. 한편 우리나라의 ODA는 다양한 시행기관에서 분산적으로 추진하고 있는 상황으로, ODA 사업의 효과성 제고를 위하여 그간 효과적 추진체계에 대한 선행연구가 다수 이뤄져 왔다. 이와 궤를 같이하여 2010년에는 국제개발협력기본법의 제정을 통해 국제개발협력위원회에 ODA의 총괄적 추진을 위한 정책의 총괄 및 조정 기능이 강화되었다. 그러나 본 위원회에서 실제로 어떤 조정이 이루어지는지에 대한 사례 기반의 연구는 거의 이루어지지 않은 상황이다. 본 연구의 목적은 국제개발협력위원회의 정책 조정 사례를 분석하여 국제개발협력에서 정책 조정에 영향을 미치는 요인이 무엇인지 알아보는 것이다. 분석 대상은 2009년에 시작되어 2019년 현재까지 진행되고 있는 이다. 2008년 이명박 정부에서는 글로벌리더 10만 양성을 국정과제로 정하고 해외 봉사단 2만명 육성 사업을 추진하였다. 이와 관련하여 전 부처에서 개별 추진 중인 해외 봉사단 파견 사업의 KOICA의 WFK로의 통합에 대한 논의가 시작되었고, 2009~2010년 경 대통령 리더십에 의한 1차적 통합이 이루어졌다. 한편 2016년 경 부터는 아직 통합되지 않은 봉사단 파견 사업들에 대하여 국제개발협력위원회에서 2차적 통합 논의가 시작된 바, 외교부가 주관부처로서 통합 추진 논의를 추진하였으며 통합 대상이 되었던 사업 들은 총 6개의 부처(보건복지부, 문화체육관광부, 국가보훈처, 기상청, 공정거래위원회, 교육부)의 8개 사업이었다. 연구의 진행 방식은 먼저 정책 조정의 영향 요인에 대한 이론과 연구를 개관하고, 국제개발협력의 정책 조정에서 주요한 영향을 미치리라 생각되는 요인들을 선별하였다. 선별된 요인을 바탕으로 분석 틀을 설정하고 가설을 수립하였으며 사례에 존재하는 6개의 부처의 8개 사업에 대하여 분석틀에 기반하여 분석을 수행하였고 가설을 검증하였다. 이를 위해 2014년부터 2020년까지의 국제개발협력위원회 조정 과정에서 생산된 문건인 무상원조 관계기관 협의회 및 국제개발협력위원회 의결 종합시행계획 등을 분석하였다. 본 연구에서는 정책 조정의 개념에 대하여 국제개발협력 이슈의 특성을 고려하여 부처 간 정책 갈등 해결 측면 보다는 시너지 제고를 위한 부처 간 정책의 통합적 추진 측면을 중시하였다. 이론적 논의에 따르면 정책 조정은 위계에 의한 방식, 네트워크에 의한 방식, 시장에 의한 방식 등이 존재하는 바, 국제개발협력위원회제도는 다양한 참여자 간 협의체를 통한 상호 작용의 조정 기제로 보아 네트워크적 관점에서 분석하고자 하였다. 한편 일반적인 정책 조정 영향 요인에 대한 선행연구에서는 이슈 및 참여자의 속성, 조정 환경, 조정 주체 요인 등이 주요 영향 요인으로 지적되어 왔다. 한편 국제개발협력 분야의 선행연구는 주로 제도적 측면의 개선점에 주안을 두고 그간 연구되어온 바, 조정 영향 요인에 대한 선행 연구가 드물었다. 결국 분석모형틀로서 이론적 논의의 네트워크 관점의 정책 조정 영향 요인과, 일반 정책 조정 선행 연구에서 논의된 영향 요인을 종합하여 국제개발협력의 정책 조정 영향 요인으로서 세 가지를 도출하였다. 이는 네트워크 참여자의 고유한 정책 관점 내재화의 정도, 참여자의 정책에 대한 영역권 다툼 성향, 대통령 및 주관부처(외교부)의 리더십의 수준 이다. 각 요인에 대하여는 세부 하부 지표를 설정하였는바, 먼저 고유한 정책 관점 내재화의 정도의 판단 기준으로 전담 사업 수행기관의 존부, 고유 정책 자원의 활용 여부, 이익집단의 존부를 고려하였다. 영역권 다툼 성향의 경우 예산의 절대 액수 및 비중, 사업 관련 기성사실의 발생 정도를 고려하였다. 셋째로 리더십의 경우 대통령 및 정책 조정 촉발 기관(외교부)의 리더십의 수준을 고려하였다. 통합 대상이 되었던 6개 부처 8개의 사업들은 이 세 요인에 대하여 각각 다른 정도를 가지고 있었으며 이는 개별 부처가 정책 조정 네트워크에서 택한 전략 및 조정의 결과에 영향을 미쳤다. 먼저 보건복지부의 사업은 대한한방해외의료봉사단이라는 비영리사단법인이 전담 수행하며 고유 자원을 활용하나 소규모의 보조금 교부 액수 및 봉사단에 복수 후원처의 존재 등으로 정책 관점 내재화 정도는 그리 높지 않다고 보인다. 또한 사업 수행이 오래되었으나 국내 이해관계자의 수는 많지 않아 영역권 다툼 성향도 높지 않다고 볼 것이다. 그러나 결정적으로 대통령의 해외 순방에 따른 보건복지부의 자체 사업 구조조정이 조정 결과에 영향을 미쳤다고 보이며, 보건복지부는 2018년부터 사업을 중단하였고 해당 사업은 현재 WFK 플랫폼에 통합된 상태이다. 문화체육관광부의 경우 전통공연예술진흥재단 등 소관 비영리재단법인이 사업을 전담하고 전통문화 전공 학생 및 재외 한국문화원을 활용하는 등 고유 정책 자원을 활용하며 이익집단도 존재하는 등 정책 관점 내재화 정도가 높다. 또한 예산은 소규모이나 한국문화원 등 연관 정책이 문화체육관광부의 중점 정책 영역에 해당한다. 이에 외교부가 해당 사업에 대한 강경한 검토 의견을 제시하였을 때, 문화체육관광부는 WFK와 통합하거나 사업을 중단하는 대신, 사업을 비ODA사업으로 전환하여 국제개발협력 조정네트워크에서 이탈한 후 지속 추진하는 전략을 택하였다. 국가보훈처에서는 6.25참전국 의료봉사 사업 및 베트남 의료봉사 사업의 두 사업을 논의하였다. 국가보훈처에서는 상대적으로 중요도가 낮고 전담 수행기관과의 밀착도가 낮으며 이익단체가 없었던 6.25 참전국 의료봉사 사업은 수행을 포기하였다. 그러나 국가보훈처는 베트남 의료봉사 사업의 경우 상이군경회라는 고유 정책 자원을 전담 기관으로 활용하는 점, 강력한 이익단체가 존재하는 점, 한-베 민간협력은 부처 차원의 주요 정책 영역에 해당하는 점 등으로 인해 사업을 포기하지 않고 비ODA방식으로 전환하여 지속 추진하는 방식을 택하였다. 기상청의 사업도 한국기상산업기술원이 전담하며 고유한 정책 자원을 활용하는 형태이나 이익단체가 특별히 없고 예산 비중이 낮았다. 한편 기상청도 본 사업을 비ODA방식으로 전환하여 지속 추진하는 방식을 택하였다. 공정거래위원회의 경우 부처가 직접 내부 직원을 파견하는 사업으로 고유 관점 내재화 정도와 영역권 다툼 성향이 모두 높았다. 그러나 외교부는 공정거래위원회 사업에 대해 통합을 추진하지 않은 바, 양 부처 간에 본 사업은 통합이 가능한 유형의 사업이 아님에 대한 상호간의 인지가 이뤄진 것으로 보인다. 교육부의 경우 소속 책임운영기관이 사업을 실시 중이며, 고유 정책 자원을 활용하고 있고 강력한 교원 이익단체가 존재하여 정책 관점 내재화 정도가 크다. 또한 사업의 액수가 매우 크고 부처의 중점 정책 영역에 해당하는 등 영역권 다툼 성향도 크다. 외교부는 2019년 시행계획부터 교육부 사업에 대하여 강력한 조정 의지를 보이고 있으나 교육부는 네트워크에 참여하여 협의를 통해 이를 지속적으로 반대하는 모습을 보이고 있다. 이러한 6개 부처 8개 사업의 사례를 분석모형틀을 통해 분석하였다. 영향 요인에 대하여 부처 별로 상이한 여건은 개별 부처가 네트워크 내에서 다른 전략을 취하도록 촉발하였고 이에 따라 정책 조정의 결과가 다르게 나타나는 것을 관찰하였다. 또한 당초 설정한 가설을 검증하였다. 첫째, 정책의 관점 단절의 차이가 클수록 정책 조정(통합)에 불리하였다. 둘째, 소관 부처의 영역 다툼 성향이 클수록 정책 조정(통합)에 불리하였다. 셋째, 주관부처 및 대통령의 리더십이 클수록 정책 조정(통합)에 유리하였다. 본 연구는 우리나라의 국제개발협력에서 정책 조정의 과정 및 성과를 실제 사례를 통해 세밀하게 기술하고자 하였으나, 실질적으로 네트워크 참여자들의 세부적인 회의록에는 접근하기 어려워, 단계 별로 조정에 대한 검토 결과를 통해 개별 참여자(부처들)의 행태를 추론하는 방법을 사용하여 대략적인 설명에 그친 한계점이 있다. 그러나 우리나라의 국제개발협력에서 실제로 국제개발협력위원회라는 정책조정의 수단, 즉 네트워크적 관점에서 참여자들 간의 회의체 운영을 통한 정책 조정의 과정을 파악한 점, 이 과정에서 개별 부처의 사업 담당자들이 보이는 행태들을 미시적으로 기술하였고, 우리나라의 정책 조정에서 실질적으로 정책 조정 결과에 영향을 미치는 주요 변인이 무엇인지 원형을 제시하였다는 점에서 연구의 의의가 있다. 향후에는 국제개발협력위원회를 통한 정책 조정의 또 다른 사례 등 연구 대상을 확장하여 연구 결과가 일반화 될 수 있기를 기대하여 본다. ; 제 1 장 서 론 1 제 1 절 연구의 배경과 목적 1 제 2 절 연구의 범위 4 제 3 절 연구의 방법 7 제 2 장 이론적 논의 및 연구 설계 9 제 1 절 정책 조정의 개념 9 1. 정책 조정의 개념 및 유형 9 2. 정책 조정의 수단 11 제 2 절 국제 개발 협력 이론 18 1. 국제개발협력 추진체계 18 2. ODA 분절화 19 3. 해외의 국제개발협력 추진 체계 21 제 3 절 정책 조정 영향 요인에 대한 연구 24 1. 일반적 정책 조정 영향 요인 연구 24 2. 국제개발협력 정책 조정 영향 요인 연구 25 제 4 절 연구분석틀 30 제 3 장 봉사단 파견 사업 WFK 통합 추진 사례 36 제 1 절 WFK 통합 추진 배경 36 제 2 절 2008~2013년도 추진 과정 37 1. 2009~2010년도 추진 과정 37 2. 2011~2013년도 추진 과정 40 제 3 절 2014~2020년도 추진 과정 43 1. 쟁점 사업 43 2. 2014년도 종합시행계획 46 3. 2015년도 종합시행계획 47 4. 2016년도 종합시행계획 48 5. 2017년도 종합시행계획 49 6. 2018년도 종합시행계획 50 7. 2019년도 종합시행계획 51 8. 2020년도 종합시행계획 51 제 4 장 분석 결과 및 논의 52 제 1 절 보건복지부의 정책 조정 참여 활동 52 제 2 절 문화체육관광부의 정책 조정 참여 활동 60 제 3 절 국가보훈처의 정책 조정 참여 활동 68 제 4 절 기상청의 정책 조정 참여 활동 80 제 5 절 공정거래위원회의 정책 조정 참여 활동 86 제 6 절 교육부의 정책 조정 참여 활동 92 제 7 절 외교부(주관기관)의 정책 조정 참여 활동 102 제 8 절 분석 결과 요약 104 제 5 장 결론 112 제 1 절 연구의 시사점 112 제 2 절 연구의 한계점 및 향후 연구 114 참고문헌 116 Abstract 119 ; Master

Lambros Flitouris, The Suez Crisis and the Greek-French Relations The Suez crisis in 1956 constitutes an important point in the development of the international relations at the period of the cold war. 1956 is a landmark year for the appointment of the Arabic nationalism as a basic constitutive element of the anti-colonialist wave that convulsed the world. During this period, the relations of Greece with the states involved in the crisis were to a large extent precarious. The anti-imperialists tones of Nasser found impression in the Greek common opinion that was exceptionally irritated from the EOKA's fight in Cyprus. In the present article we examine one particular aspect of the crisis: the relations of Greece with France. The agreements of economic collaboration that was achieved by Markezinis in 1953 signalled a new era in the activation of French capital in Greece. In combination with the big cultural tradition that Prance had in the country but also with the crisis in the relations of Greece with the UK because of the Cypriot question, the French factor in Greece acquired a great importance. However, the French diplomacy followed the policy of London and because of this the relations between Greece and France faced their more important post-war crisis. The Greek common opinion also turned against France, while the French diplomacy lost a great opportunity to strengthen her place in Greece. In the sector of economic relations and cultural exchanges befell a period of algidity with extensions in the Greek internal political life. The crisis of the period 1956-1958 constituted a negative parenthesis in the traditionally good relations between Athens and Paris, while it could be characterized as an adjacent negative result of the anti-colonial struggle and the Cypriot affair. ; Lambros Flitouris, The Suez Crisis and the Greek-French RelationsThe Suez crisis in 1956 constitutes an important point in the development of the international relations at the period of the cold war. 1956 is a landmark year for the appointment of the Arabic nationalism as a basic constitutive element of the anti-colonialist wave that convulsed the world. During this period, the relations of Greece with the states involved in the crisis were to a large extent precarious. The anti-imperialists tones of Nasser found impression in the Greek common opinion that was exceptionally irritated from the EOKA's fight in Cyprus. In the present article we examine one particular aspect of the crisis: the relations of Greece with France. The agreements of economic collaboration that was achieved by Markezinis in 1953 signalled a new era in the activation of French capital in Greece. In combination with the big cultural tradition that Prance had in the country but also with the crisis in the relations of Greece with the UK because of the Cypriot question, the French factor in Greece acquired a great importance. However, the French diplomacy followed the policy of London and because of this the relations between Greece and France faced their more important post-war crisis. The Greek common opinion also turned against France, while the French diplomacy lost a great opportunity to strengthen her place in Greece. In the sector of economic relations and cultural exchanges befell a period of algidity with extensions in the Greek internal political life. The crisis of the period 1956-1958 constituted a negative parenthesis in the traditionally good relations between Athens and Paris, while it could be characterized as an adjacent negative result of the anti-colonial struggle and the Cypriot affair.

The database Cretan Institutional Inscriptions was created as part of the PhD research project in Ancient Heritage Studies Kretikai Politeiai: Cretan Institutions from VII to I century BC, carried out at the University of Venice Ca' Foscari by Irene Vagionakis from 2016 to 2019, under the supervision of Claudia Antonetti and Gabriel Bodard. The research project aimed at collecting the epigraphic sources related to the institutional elements of the many political entities of Crete, with a view to highlighting the specificity of each context in the period between the rise of the poleis and the Roman conquest of the island. The main component of the database consists of the epigraphic collection of the 600 inscriptions constituting the core of the documentary base of the study, for each of which an XML edition compliant with the TEI EpiDoc international standard was created. Each EpiDoc edition includes a descriptive and a bibliographic lemma, the text of the inscription, a selective apparatus criticus and a commentary focused on the institutional data offered by the document. In addition to the epigraphic collection, the database includes a collection of the main related literary sources, a catalogue of the attested Cretan institutions (assemblies, boards, officials, associations, civic subdivisions, social statuses, age classes, months, festivities and other celebrations, institutional practices, institutional instruments, public spaces) and a catalogue of the political entities of Crete (poleis, koina, dependent communities, extra-urban sanctuaries, hegemonic alliances). Data and SW available at https://github.com/IreneVagionakis/CretanInscriptions

Δεν παρατίθεται περίληψη στα ελληνικά. ; Juan Suriano, Cultural practices and politics of the argentine anarchism The writer attempts to establish the basic characteristics of the argentine anarchism, analyze its cultural dimensions and show the limits of its strategies. The basic concepts of the anarchism in Argentina were developed during the years 1870-1920, within a constantly changing and cosmopolitan social environment, since it was in that period that the country became part of the international market place. The anarchists' discourse, being flexible and out of rigid structures, based on the principles of class heterodoxy, individualism and universality, as well as on the spontaneous action, achieved to interpret, during the years 1890-1910, not only the demands of the working class, but also the discontent and frustration of the lower classes and oppressed social groups, in general. The anarchists undertook the mission to «illuminate» and educate morally the working class, through the doctrinaire press and a network of a considerable number of circles, clubs and alternative schools, which offered not only economic help but also education and entertainment to the workers and their families. On the other hand, the constant rejection, by the anarchists, of the concepts of citizenship, representation and political participation had a negative effect on the popularity of the movement: because of the new political situation during the 1910s —in 1912 all men obtained the right to vote—, the working class changed its attitude towards the electoral process and got interested in the social measures taken by the radical governments of the period; as a result, the anarchism faced serious difficulties to attract the interest of the lower classes.

Accounting for nearly 80% of the global population and occupying three quarters of the world' area, the developing countries are affirming their roles in the global progress. However, the independence and sovereignty of these countries are often faced with many challenges stemming from upheavals in the international security environment, globalization, violence policies of big countries and power competition among them. In this context, in order to preserve their independence and sovereignty, the developing countries need to build democratic and progressive states, improve their real national strengths, struggle against the "peaceful evolution" of the powerful nations. This paper analyzes factors which influence the independence and sovereignty as well as the current process of struggling and defending the independence and sovereignty of the developing countries ; Chiếm khoảng 80% dân số và ¾ diện tích toàn cầu, các nước đang phát triển đang khẳng định vai trò, vị thế của mình trong đời sống quốc tế. Tuy nhiên, độc lập, chủ quyền của các nước đang phát triển luôn đứng trước nhiều thách thức đến từ những biến động của môi trường an ninh quốc tế; chính sách cường quyền của các nước lớn; quá trình toàn cầu hóa; sự cạnh tranh quyền lực của các nước lớn. Trong bối cảnh đó, để giữ được độc lập, chủ quyền, các nước đang phát triển cần xây dựng một nhà nước dân chủ, tiến bộ; tăng cường thực lực quốc gia; đấu tranh chống "diễn biến hòa bình" của các nước lớn. Bài viết phân tích những nhân tố tác động đến độc lập, chủ quyền và quá trình đấu tranh bảo vệ độc lập, chủ quyền của các nước đang phát triển hiện nay.