Four Cosmopolitanism Moments
Discusses four contexts or "moments" wherein cosmopolitanism took purchase to expose the limits & potential of some currently relevant cosmopolitan ideas/ideals & practices. Detailed are Zeno's moment in antiquity, Kant's moment circa the French Revolution, Arendt's moment in light of Nazism & Stalinism & the notion of crimes against humanity, & Nussbaum's moment related to educational reform & as exemplary of late North American thought. Following their explication, brief comments are offered. In connection to Zeno's moment, issues of political community are touched on. For Kant's moment, three related problems of his philosophy of history & metaphysics of justice are addressed. A sense of disembodiment is apparent in Arendt's moment & her treatment of cosmopolitan law in relation to crimes against humanity. In Nussbaum's moment, the paradox that states, via the educational system, employed strong ideologies of assimilation & integration with immigrants is recognized. In this light, it is suggested that cosmopolitanism cannot provide the one solution to problems related to nationalism, racism, ethnic conflict, or religious fundamentalism; however, in reflecting on these moments, the moral requirement for a cosmopolitanism is evident & a call is made for cautious advance. J. Zendejas