Ernest Gellner and the Escape to Modernity
(Originally published in John A. Hall & Ian C. Jarvie's [Eds], Transition to Modernity, 1992 [see abstract 93c01707].) Ernest Gellner's specification of the uniqueness of modern industrial-capitalist civilization (1975, 1988) is criticized for relying too heavily on a rigid philosophy of history. Gellner identifies the ascendancy of rationality as the first marker of modernity; the second is the artificial separation of the institutions of kinship, politics, religion, & economics. An explanation of the origin of these particular features of modern society eludes Gellner, who describes the transition to modernity as a series of near-miraculous accidents. Gellner's model of human history, based on the three stages of human development (hunting-gathering, agrarian, & industrial), fails to account for the differences between societies that fall within the same stage. Once this model is abandoned, the wholly contrived or accidental separation of institutions emerges as the crucial element of modernity. 6 References. H. von Rautenfeld