An Ethical Framework for Economic Intelligence
In: International journal of intelligence and counterintelligence, S. 1-26
ISSN: 1521-0561
7 Ergebnisse
Sortierung:
In: International journal of intelligence and counterintelligence, S. 1-26
ISSN: 1521-0561
In: Ethics & international affairs, Band 37, Heft 2, S. 116-133
ISSN: 1747-7093
AbstractThe ethical value of intelligence lies in its crucial role in safeguarding individuals from harm by detecting, locating, and preventing threats. As part of this undertaking, intelligence can include protecting the economic well-being of the political community and its people. Intelligence, however, also entails causing people harm when it violates their vital interests through its operations. The challenge, therefore, is how to reconcile this tension, which Cécile Fabre's recent book Spying through a Glass Darkly does by arguing for the "ongoing and preemptive imposition of defensive harm." Fabre applies this underlying argument to the specifics of economic espionage to argue that while states, businesses, and individuals do have a general right over their information that prevents others from accessing it, such protections can be forfeited or overridden when there is a potential threat to the fundamental rights of third parties. This essay argues, however, that Fabre's discussion on economic espionage overlooks important additional proportionality and discrimination concerns that need to be accounted for. In addition to the privacy violations it causes, economic espionage can cause harms to people's other vital interests, including their physical and mental well-being and autonomy. Given the complex way in which the economy interlinks with people's lives and society, harms to one economic actor will have repercussions on those secondary economic entities dependent on them, such as workers, buyers, and investors. This, in turn, can produce further harms on other economic actors, causing damages to ripple outward across society.
In: Intelligence and national security, Band 37, Heft 6, S. 863-873
ISSN: 1743-9019
In: Polity, Band 51, Heft 1, S. 62-94
ISSN: 1744-1684
In: International journal of human rights, Band 22, Heft 4, S. 574-602
ISSN: 1744-053X
In: Journal of international political theory: JIPT, Band 14, Heft 1, S. 60-84
ISSN: 1755-1722
One of the biggest challenges facing modern societies is how to monitor one's intelligence community while maintaining the necessary level of secrecy. Indeed, while some secrecy is needed for mission success, too much has allowed significant abuse. Moreover, extending this secrecy to democratic oversight actors only creates another layer of unobserved actors and removes the public scrutiny that keeps their power and decision-making in check. This article will therefore argue for a new type of oversight through a specialised ethical whistleblowing framework. This includes, first, outlining what intelligence wrongdoings justify whistleblowing; second, whether whistleblowing is the correct remedy – something not necessarily clear with intelligence; and finally, what form the whistleblowing should take. This framework will examine the Snowden case to determine whether he was correct leaking intelligence data and whether the means were appropriate, and second, whether those involved in the Central Intelligence Agency use of torture should have blown the whistle and if they now face blame for failing to act.
In: Journal of military ethics, Band 15, Heft 4, S. 299-319
ISSN: 1502-7589