Graven Images: "The Hart Island Project"
In: Studies in law, politics, and society, Band 34, S. 179-200
Melinda Hunt's ongoing Hart Island Project, which commemorates individuals who are interred in the state-owned graveyard on New York's Hart Island because they were unknown or unclaimed or were too impoverished to be buried elsewhere, is interpreted as a cinematic & photographic text that unveils the conflict between the law & aesthetics regarding deceased individuals. An overview of the history of Hart Island is presented, revealing how local culture & law have attempted to render the bodies interred in the island's graveyard invisible, which is deemed a contrast with other cultures' public acknowledgment of dead bodies. It is argued that Hunt's work provides an aesthetic documentation of the deceased & forces the materialization of the dead bodies on the public despite legal mechanisms that keep them imperceptible. Even though Hunt's work forces the public to recognize these "others," it is stressed that the Hart Island Project also represents the narratives of another set of "others," namely, the prisoners who bury the dead at Hart Island. The study's implications for integrating aesthetics within existing legal understandings of the dead body are also pondered. 15 Figures, 25 References. J. W. Parker