Objective Problems, Subjective Values, and Global Environmentalism: Evaluting the Postmaterialist Argument and Challenging a New Explanation
In: Social science quarterly, Band 80, Heft 4, S. 793-809
ISSN: 0038-4941
Examines the viability of the latest explanation for global environmentalism, which sees it as the combined product of direct experiences of the citizens of poorer nations (objective problems thesis) with the subjective values shift of the citizens of wealthier countries (postmaterialist values thesis). Using two statistical tests, data from the 1992 Gallup Health of the Planet survey & a two-dimensional (local/global) measure of environmental concern, attitudes of citizens from 12 relatively wealthy &12 relatively poor countries are compared on 15 different items. Analysis indicates that, while citizens from poorer countries (with relatively low numbers of postmaterialists) were far more concerned about local environmental problems than citizens from wealthier countries (with relatively high numbers of postmaterialists), no statistically significant differences between the two groups were found on questions concerning more symbolic global environmental problems. Using an objective problems + subjective values explanation fails to describe adequately the bases of southern & northern environmental concern, respectively, & hence, environmental concern globally. In addition, using a postmaterialist explanation for environmentalism at the wider cultural level becomes incoherent vs the much more modest claims found at the social-psychological level. In sum, global environmentalism is a complex social phenomenon consisting of multiple movements, driven by multiple engines requiring further specification & discussion. 5 Tables, 34 References. Adapted from the source document.