Translation Terrain and Pied Piper Detour: How Experts Eliminated a Norwegian Digital City Project
In: Science, technology, & human values: ST&HV, Band 29, Heft 2, S. 213-241
ISSN: 1552-8251
The analysis of contemporary socio-technical processes can benefit greatly, methodologically speaking, from considering past processes and solutions. Obviously, all technological projects have a prehistory upon which they depend to a certain extent. In some cases, the prehistory might even take on the shape of a translation terrain, which technical experts employ explicitly to sidestep inexperienced nonexperts. Also, mechanisms that can best be described as a pied piper detour, rather than as an obligatory passage point, are relied on by technical experts who want to exclude the views and participation of nonexperts for themselves to assume a dominating position in the Machiavellian tradition. The relevance and operation of these socio-technical mechanisms were amply illustrated in the Norwegian town of Fredrikstad, where plans for establishing an IT highway project—a digital city concept developed and supported by users (both bureaucrats and laypersons)—came to nothing after technical experts intervened in the shape of a mediating agency and introduced their own scenarios.