Life in Claremont: An Interview with May Santon
In: African studies, Volume 60, Issue 1, p. 39-64
ISSN: 1469-2872
7 results
Sort by:
In: African studies, Volume 60, Issue 1, p. 39-64
ISSN: 1469-2872
In: http://hdl.handle.net/11427/26769
Background: The literature suggests that although the idea of using evidence to inform policy making has come into favour, actualising this idea in practice is complex. Within the framework of these debates this dissertation focuses on the uptake of findings from research into policy making for the use of magnesium sulphate in the treatment of eclampsia and pre-eclampsia within South Africa. Despite the publication over the past decade of evidence suggesting the effectiveness of magnesium sulphate as a treatment for eclampsia and pre-eclampsia, eclampsia remains a leading cause of maternal death in South Africa and in many other low and middle-income countries. This dissertation forms part of a larger study investigating the uptake of research into policy making in South Africa, Mozambique and Zimbabwe. Aim: To describe and analyse the actual and perceived utilisation of research information in policy making and guideline development for the use of magnesium sulphate in the treatment of eclampsia and pre-eclampsia. Methods: This qualitative study triangulated three techniques in order to understand research utilisation in contemporary policy making. The techniques employed were: policy document review, a historical overview and individual qualitative interviews with 15 key informants. Data generated through these methods are reflected upon in relation to each other and within the context of relevant scientific and intellectual debates. Findings: This study shows a positive example of research utilisation in policy making and guideline development. In the late 1990's in South Africa, prompted by factors such as the recent political change, policies and management guidelines were being developed for maternal health. Simultaneously evidence from randomized controlled trials and systematic reviews showed the effectiveness of magnesium sulphate for the treatment of eclampsia and pre-eclampsia. Policies developed during this period make explicit reference to the use of the most recent published evidence. The uptake of this evidence into national policy development is likely explained by the complex interaction of a range of factors: the existence of a previously established evidence-based culture among obstetricians; the movement of "networked" individuals immersed in that culture into key positions in the new government; the involvement of researchers in policy development; and the willingness of individuals and groups to lobby and advocate both for the development of policy and for the use of evidence in that policy. Discussion and Conclusions: The findings highlight the role played by researchers in developing evidence based policies and guidelines. It also points to the complexity of the relationship between knowledge production and the utilisation of research in policy. It suggests that while researchers may not be in control of factors such as political change, they are presented with windows of opportunity that may allow them to affect policy change. Their capacity to affect such change can be enhanced through collective action when researchers are organised through academic networks.
BASE
In: Children and youth services review: an international multidisciplinary review of the welfare of young people, Volume 98, p. 171-177
ISSN: 0190-7409
In: Child abuse & neglect: the international journal ; official journal of the International Society for the Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect, Volume 48, p. 131-139
ISSN: 1873-7757
Background There is increased international focus on improving the rigour of clinical practice guideline (CPG) development practices. However, few empirical studies on CPG development have been conducted in low- and middle-income countries. This paper explores national stakeholders' perceptions of processes informing CPG development for primary healthcare in South Africa, focusing on both their aspirations and views of what is actually occurring. Methods A qualitative study design was employed including individual interviews with 37 South African primary care CPG development role-players. Participants represented various disciplines, sectors and provinces. The data were analysed through thematic analysis and an interpretivist conceptual framework. Results Strongly reflecting current international standards, participants identified six 'aspirational' processes that they thought should inform South African CPG development, as follows: (1) evidence; (2) stakeholder consultation; (3) transparency; (4) management of interests; (5) communication/co-ordination between CPG development groups; and (6) fit-for-context. While perceptions of a transition towards more robust processes was common, CPG development was seen to face ongoing challenges with regards to all six aspirational processes. Many challenges were attributed to inadequate financial and human resources, which were perceived to hinder capacity to undertake the necessary methodological work, respond to stakeholders' feedback, and document and share decision-making processes. Challenges were also linked to a complex web of politics, power and interests. The CPG development arena was described as saturated with personal and financial interests, groups competing for authority over specific territories and unequal power dynamics which favour those with the time, resources and authority to make contributions. These were all perceived to affect efforts for transparency, collaboration and inclusivity in CPG development. Conclusion While there is strong commitment amongst national stakeholders to advance CPG development processes, a mix of values, politics, power and capacity constraints pose significant challenges. Contrasting perspectives regarding managing interests and how best to adapt to within-country contexts requires further exploration. Dedicated resources for CPG development, standardised systems for managing conflicting interests, and the development of a political environment that fosters collaboration and more equitable inclusion within and between CPG development groups are needed. These initiatives may enhance CPG quality and acceptability, with associated positive impact on patient care.
BASE
BACKGROUND: Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) are common tools in policy and clinical practice informing clinical decisions at the bedside, governance of health facilities, health insurer and government spending, and patient choices. South Africa's health sector is transitioning to a national health insurance system, aiming to build on other primary health care initiatives to transform the previously segregated, inequitable services. Within these plans CPGs are an integral tool for delivering standardised and cost effective care. Currently, there is no accepted standard approach to developing, adapting or implementing CPGs efficiently or effectively in South Africa. We explored the current players; drivers; and the context and processes of primary care CPG development from the perspective of stakeholders operating at national level. METHODS: We used a qualitative approach. Sampling was initially purposeful, followed by snowballing and further sampling to reach representivity of primary care service providers. Individual in-depth interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim. We used thematic content analysis to analyse the data. RESULTS: We conducted 37 in-depth interviews from June 2014-July 2015. We found CPG development and implementation were hampered by lack of human and funding resources for technical and methodological work; fragmentation between groups, and between national and provincial health sectors; and lack of agreed systems for CPG development and implementation. Some CPG contributors steadfastly work to improve processes aiming to enhance communication, use of evidence, and transparency to ensure credible guidance is produced. Many interviewed had shared values, and were driven to address inequity, however, resource gaps were perceived to create an enabling environment for commercial interests or personal agendas to drive the CPG development process. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings identified strengths and gaps in CPG development processes, and a need for national standards to guide CPG development and implementation. Based on our findings and suggestions from participants, a possible way forward would be for South Africa to have a centrally coordinated CPG unit to address these needs and aspects of fragmentation by devising processes that support collaboration, transparency and credibility across sectors and disciplines. Such an initiative will require adequate resourcing to build capacity and ensure support for the delivery of high quality CPGs for South African primary care.
BASE
INTRODUCTION: Indoor residual spraying (IRS) and insecticide-treated nets (ITNs), two principal malaria control strategies, are similar in cost and efficacy. We aimed to describe recent policy development regarding their use in Mozambique, South Africa and Zimbabwe. METHODS: Using a qualitative case study methodology, we undertook semi-structured interviews of key informants from May 2004 to March 2005, carried out document reviews and developed timelines of key events. We used an analytical framework that distinguished three broad categories: interests, ideas and events. RESULTS: A disparate mix of interests and ideas slowed the uptake of ITNs in Mozambique and Zimbabwe and prevented uptake in South Africa. Most respondents strongly favoured one strategy over the other. In all three countries, national policy makers favoured IRS, and only in Mozambique did national researchers support ITNs. Outside interests in favour of IRS included manufacturers who supplied the insecticides and groups opposing environmental regulation. International research networks, multilateral organizations, bilateral donors and international NGOs supported ITNs. Research evidence, local conditions, logistic feasibility, past experience, reaction to outside ideas, community acceptability, the role of government and NGOs, and harm from insecticides used in spraying influenced the choice of strategy. The end of apartheid permitted a strongly pro-IRS South Africa to influence the region, and in Mozambique and Zimbabwe, floods provided conditions conducive to ITN distribution. CONCLUSIONS: Both IRS and ITNs have a place in integrated malaria vector management, but pro-IRS interests and ideas slowed or prevented the uptake of ITNs. Policy makers needed more than evidence from trials to change from the time-honoured IRS strategy that they perceived was working. Those intending to promote new policies such as ITNs should examine the interests and ideas motivating key stakeholders and their own institutions, and identify where shifts in thinking or coalitions among the like-minded may be possible.
BASE