Can States and Civil Societies Deliver?
In: New political economy, Volume 7, Issue 3, p. 441-445
ISSN: 1469-9923
A comment on Robin Theobald's essay, 'Can the State Deliver?,' contends that the current discourse of good governance, which renews attention on the state & promotes the efficiency of governmental agencies, is an enormous improvement over the 'state bashing' of Reaganism & Thatcherism. However, expressing the need for an effective state is much simpler than creating one, & Theobald offers an excellent critique of failed efforts, especially how New Public Management serves to undermine institutional continuity & stability. However, his dismal view of anti-corruption prospects in less developed countries is too severe. The huge differences in the character of postcolonial states suggest some have a much stronger basis than others to promote institutionalized patterns of administration. The historical complexities of reform are discussed, along with the neoliberal tendency to minimize the need to build stronger political institutions through the glorification of civil society; corrupt elements of civil society; & situations in which civil society might play an anti-corruption role. J. Lindroth