'Whereas it may be true that a picture is worth a thousand words, this is only the case if the picture is taken in a particular way and is then properly analysed.'
Reply Reply This contribution is a reply on the article 'De waarde van kwalitatieve strategieën voor het praktijkgericht onderzoek', written by Piet J.M. Verschuren. Using the concepts of framing, indolence, dialogue and polyphonic causality Kuiper and Houweling aim at enriching the discourse of causality perceptions in qualitative research presented by Verschuren.
Ruim een jaar geleden zagen wij een aankondiging voor een cursus Q-methodologie. Geprikkeld door de enthousiaste verhalen van AnneLoes en Susan schreven we ons in. Het leek ons de ultieme test. Twee (relatieve) tegenpolen in de collegezaal: een voornamelijk kwantitatief onderzoeker zij aan zij met de kwalitatieve onderzoeker bij de cursus Q-methodologie. Even fraai kan het worden samen tweestemmig een reactie te schrijven op het artikel van dezelfde AnneLoes en Susan.
Sounding polyphonic stories. Part 3. Method of analysis Sounding polyphonic stories. Part 3. Method of analysis In this study an unconventional qualitative, narrative methodology is applied to shed a new light on the significance of having a job and working in elderly care for health care professionals and to use this as a source of inspiration for labor market policy makers.The methodology is rather unconventional because it doesn't focus only on the lingual content of the stories, but also includes other significant aspects of storytelling (e.g., voice and sound). Therefore musical work forms (e.g., music listening and singing) are used additionally.In the first phase of data collection stories of care professionals about the intertwining of their lifeline and career have been collected. In the second, listening phase HR professionals listened to the stories told by the care professionals and used them as a source of inspiration for HR policy innovation. The applied method of analysis connects analysis methods from both arts-based research and voice-centered research. In two previous articles the theoretical domains underlying this study and the methodology of both the story-telling and story-listening phase have been presented. This article treats the method of analysis.
Sounding polyphonic stories, part II. The phase of listening in data collection Sounding polyphonic stories, part II. The phase of listening in data collection In the Netherlands, future staffing of elderly care will demand a big effort and a lot of creativity of health care organizations and the government. In this study an unconventional qualitative, narrative methodology is applied to throw a new light on the significance having a job and working in elderly care has for health care professionals and to use this as a source of inspiration for labor market policymakers. The methodology is rather unconventional because it doesn't only focuses on the lingual content of the stories, but also includes other significant aspects of storytelling (e.g., voice and sound). Therefore musical work forms (e.g., music listening and singing) are used additionally.In the first phase of data collection stories of care professionals about the intertwining of their lifeline and career have been collected. In the second, listening phase HR-professionals listened to the stories told by the care professionals and used them as a source of inspiration for HR policy innovation.In a former article the methodology of the storytelling phase has been described. This article treats the methodology of the listening phase in the data collection. Later on the analysis methods will be described.
Sounding polyphonic stories: what can be learned about the HR policy of elderly care organizations? Sounding polyphonic stories: what can be learned about the HR policy of elderly care organizations? In the Netherlands, future staffing of elderly care will demand a big effort and a lot of creativity of health care organizations and the government. In this study an unconventional qualitative, narrative methodology is applied to throw a new light on the significance having a job and working in elderly care has for health care professionals and to use this as a source of inspiration for labour market policy makers. The methodology is rather unconventional because it not only focuses on the lingual content of the stories, but also includes other significant aspects of storytelling (e.g., voice and sound). Therefore musical work forms (e.g., music listening and singing) are used additionally.In the first phase of data collection stories of care professionals about the intertwining of their lifeline and career have been collected. In the second phase HR professionals listened to the stories told by the care professionals and used them as a source of inspiration for HR policy innovation. This article treats the theoretical domains underlying this study and the methodology of the first stage of data collection, the storytelling phase. Later on the methodology of the listening phase and the analysis methods will be described.
'Werkkunst in de ouderenzorg' is een organisatieontwikkeling en promotieonderzoek in De Steenplaat, een verzorgingshuis van stichting Humanitas in Rotterdam Feyenoord. Doel van deze organisatieontwikkeling is verhoging van de kwaliteit van werk én zorg. In de eerste fase van dit project staan de werknemers centraal. Onderzoeksvraag in deze fase is: 'Wat leeft er onder medewerkers in De Steenplaat? Wat vinden zij zelf van hun werk?' Om daarachter te komen hebben we gebruikgemaakt van de Social Photomatrix (SPM) (Sievers, 2008). Deze bijdrage gaat over onze ervaring met deze boeiende methode.
AbstractBackgroundIn the Netherlands, Flexible Assertive Community Treatment (FACT) teams have been established for people with mild intellectual disability (MID) or borderline intellectual functioning (BIF) and mental health problems or challenging behaviour. Little is known yet about service users' experiences with FACT.MethodAn inductive grounded theory approach was used to explore how service users valued the treatment and their own functioning, and which factors were perceived as supportive. Semi‐structured interviews were held with 15 service users.ResultsMost service users highly appreciated the contact with the staff and the practical and emotional support. Persistent involvement, availability and humanity, and respect for autonomy were distinguished as core values in the relationship with the staff. Most service users experienced improvement in time and attributed this to intrapersonal changes and/or less stress in life.ConclusionsFrom the perspective of service users with MID/BIF, FACT appears to have an added value.