Producing Knowledge and Legitimacy: Country of Origin Information in Asylum Procedures
This thesis deals with "country of origin information" (or COI), a type of expert knowledge and a field of professional practices that has emerged since the late 1980s in the framework of West European and North American asylum administrations in order to support refugee status determination. This information is used to evaluate the credibility of asylum seekers and to assess their eligibility to international protection. Rather than focusing on this instrumental role of COI in asylum procedures, this research explores the norms and values that govern the works of COI units in several European asylum administrations. It also analyses the legitimation work involved in the production of COI, with reference to knowledge production, bureaucratic practices and state authority. The format of the thesis is a PhD by published work comprising three articles. This collection of articles is eclectic both from a disciplinary and methodological perspective. Published respectively in history, political science and social anthropology journals, the three articles are integrated in an accompanying text, which offers a common contextual, thematic and theoretical introduction, as well as a methodological discussion and an articulation of the main results of the thesis. The first article – the "history article" – adopts a diachronic approach and analyses the creation and development of the French COI unit within the Office français de protection des réfugiés et des apatrides, Ofpra. Based primarily on archival data collected at the French asylum administration, it examines the institutionalisation of the "documentation" on countries of origin in the French asylum administration between 1988 and 2008 and shows how this history reflects that of the bureaucratisation of asylum procedures. It also uncovers the role and dynamics of formal and informal cooperation with European COI units in the vertical and horizontal processes of Europeanisation of asylum policies. The second article – the "distance article" – looks at the separation ...