WHAT IS RIGHT IN HEGEL'S PHILOSOPHY OF RIGHT?
In: American political science review, Band 83, Heft 1, S. 3-18
ISSN: 0003-0554
THE AUTHOR PROVIDES A THEMATIC RECONSTRUCTION OF HEGEL'S POSITIVE CONCEPT OF RIGHT. AGAINST THOSE WHO CHARGE THAT HEGEL DENIES ANY ROLE TO SUBSTANTIVE POLITICAL EVALUATION, HE ARGUES THAT THE "PHILOSOPHY OF RIGHT" ARTICULATES A NOTION OF THE RIGHT TO RECOGNITION AS THE CENTRAL FEATURE OF THE MODERN STATE. THE CONCEPT OF RECOGNITION REQUIRES NOT JUST TOLERATION OF OTHERS BUT A MORE ROBUST NOTION OF RESPECT FOR THE "FREE PERSONALITY" THAT IS THE PHILOSOPHICAL GROUND OF RIGHT. THE RIGHT TO RECOGNITION IS, FURTHERMORE, INTENDED TO PROVIDE THE FOUNDATION OF A NEW FORM OF ETHICAL LIFE, HEGEL'S MODERN ANALOGUE TO CLASSICAL CONCEPTIONS OF CIVIC VIRTURE. THE AUTHOR ALSO BRIEFLY EXAMINES TWO OBJECTIONS THAT STAND IN THE WAY OF A CONTEMPORARY REHABILITATION OF HEGELIAN POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY.