Development of an OECD guidance document for the application of OECD Test Guideline 236 (Acute Fish Embryo Toxicity Test): final report
In: Texte 2020, 94
In: Ressortforschungsplan of the Federal Ministry for the Enviroment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety
In July 2013, the Fish Embryo Acute Toxicity Test (FET) was adopted by OECD as Test Guideline 236. The FET thus represents the first fully validated alternative method within the OECD Test Guidelines Programme in the ecotoxicology sector. However, the practical applicability of the FET has ever since been discussed with respect to a series of aspects, which are addressed in this report: With respect to the potential barrier function of the zebrafish chorion, the molecular size for a free passage of non-charged chemical substances across the chorion of the zebrafish could be set at 3,000 - 4,000 Da. The limit for the passage of charged molecules is lower than that of non-charged ones. DMSO concentrations of ≥ 0.1 % decrease the barrier function of the chorion. Zebrafish embryos, juveniles and adults have been studied to a different extent with respect to their biotransformation capacities. Our knowledge on biotransformation capacities in zebrafish is fragmentary. On this basis, transfer of biotransformation data from juvenile to adult fish is not possible. In zebrafish embryos, biotransformation could be documented whenever studied in more detail; only for rare exceptions, lack of biotransformation was demonstrated. Gene activation cannot be translated into biochemical functionality; mammalian data cannot be extrapolated to fish. The analysis of historical short-term (acute) Fish Toxicity Test (AFT) data produced according to OECD TG 203 within a dataset used for a corresponding FET study by ECHA started with 2936 studies on a total of 1842 substances. Applications of filters identical to those used for the FET analysis resulted in exclusion of 62.3 % of the AFT studies and 63.0 % of the substances. Data of the present report will be integrated into OECD project no. 2.54: "Guidance Document on an Integrated Approach on Testing and Assessment for Fish Acute Toxicity Testing" - Integration of the Fish Embryo Test into the Threshold Approach".