Bending the Rules: The Space between HQ Policy and Local Action in UN Civilian Peacekeeping
In: International peacekeeping, Band 17, Heft 3, S. 293-312
ISSN: 1380-748X
3 Ergebnisse
Sortierung:
In: International peacekeeping, Band 17, Heft 3, S. 293-312
ISSN: 1380-748X
In: Journal of international peacekeeping, Band 17, Heft 3-4, S. 293-312
ISSN: 1875-4112
Recent literature has argued that a 'dominant peacebuilding culture' has precluded the contextualisation of peacebuilding to local dynamics. The article explores the 'peacekeeping-peacebuilding nexus' in practice, where civilian peacekeepers are increasingly considered to be early peacebuilders. Drawing on examples from United Nations (UN) civilian peacekeeping involvement in local peacebuilding in South Sudan, this article argues for a less reductionist and more nuanced view of local peacebuilding and the social interactions and dynamics which take place. It recognises the discrepancies between official UN Headquarters (HQ) policy and action in the "field", and thus explores the relationship between policy and practice and the location of agency and authority in civilian peacekeeping. The article argues that the critique levelled against peacekeeping and peacebuilding for being focused on actors in host country capitals does not sufficiently take into consideration the relationship between capitals and the "field". Rather, local peacebuilding outcomes depend as much or more on negotiations, bargains and compromises between different actors at the "field" level, than on institutional policy decision-making deriving from headquarters.
In: Journal of peacebuilding & development, Band 7, Heft 2, S. 53-66
ISSN: 2165-7440
In recent literature on international peacekeeping and peacebuilding interventions, attention has been drawn increasingly to local level dynamics and the reciprocal relationships with national conflict dynamics. This article places local social structures and networks at the centre of analysis and action, while unpacking the category of the 'external actor'. Through a case study of UN civilian peacekeeping support to local peacebuilding in South Sudan, it argues that there are important efforts being made to contextualise peacebuilding activities for local circumstances, notwithstanding significant institutional obstacles limiting the impact of these efforts. It also argues for further empirical scrutiny of if and how international peacebuilders are engaging with the local dynamics of conflict, seeking to improve the understanding of the heterogeneity of and interaction between actors at these levels.