The Origins of Bank-Based and Market-Based Financial Systems: Germany, Japan, and the United States
Compares the organization of financial sectors in Germany, Japan, & the US to challenge the notion that bank-based financial systems are a product of late industrialization & the state's need to focus on financial investment. Differences between bank-based & market-based finance are described. It is noted that banking systems account for most of the financial-system assets in Japan & Germany but only for about 25% in the US. However, Germany is closer to the US than to Japan in relation to the state's role in credit allocation. An exploration of the timing of industrialization (TOI) thesis for explaining these differences shows that TOI understates the significance of varied patterns of state regulations & overstates both the importance of bank-based finance for rapid industrialization in Germany & Japan, as well as the degree of difference between them. The need for a more nuanced analysis of the emergence of different types of financial regimes is discussed, along with the potential for transformation toward a market system in both countries. 5 Tables, 1 Figure. J. Lindroth