JUSTICE, FEASIBILITY, AND IDEAL THEORY: A PLURALIST APPROACH
In: Social philosophy & policy, Volume 33, Issue 1-2, p. 32-54
ISSN: 1471-6437
Abstract:A qualified pluralism is defended that recognizes value in a variety of forms of political theory and resists arguments that purport to show that one particular approach should occupy a privileged position. Against realists, it is argued that abstract analyses of political values that bracket a wide range of facts about people and their circumstances can be both coherent and important, whereas against those who think "ideal theory" or the identification of ultimate principles should come first, it is argued that the case for always giving priority to either one of these is weak.