Amid heightened global uncertainties, Russia is experiencing a bumpy recovery. Domestic demand is rising, but unemployment remains high, and credit and investment remain limited. The budget has benefited from higher oil prices, but fiscal consolidation remains important in the medium term. Crumbling infrastructure, especially in transport, could hamper the economy's competitiveness and longer-term growth prospects. The debt crisis in Western Europe sharpens the downside risks to global recovery and oil prices. But the effects on Russia are likely to be blunted by its stronger fiscal and debt positions and by limited trade and financial links with the affected countries. Russia is likely to grow by 4.5 percent in 2010, followed by 4.8 percent in 2011, as domestic demand expands in line with gradual improvements in the labor and credit markets. Employment is expected to improve gradually, however, enabling some further reductions in poverty.
The Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) is an international standard to promote open and accountable management of natural resources. By encouraging governments, extractive companies, civil society and the public to engage in discourse around transparency of the extractive sector, it aims to facilitate the management of a country's natural resource wealth to benefit all its citizens. The objective of this report is to present, in a structured form, data categories and their reporting formats, that can be used to standardize information generated under each EITI Requirement. The review conducted for this study included a sample of recent EITI Country Reports, as well as other initiatives and industry standards. 'Good' refers to reporting standards that meet the minimum data to be provided under each EITI Requirement. 'Better' typically refers to reporting standards that are enhancements of data covered under the good category. 'Best' refers to standard formats for reporting data that represent the highest international benchmarks and are considered to provide comprehensive information, beyond the minimum data requirements. The research team recommends a step by step approach to this, starting with a specific set of Requirements, across a number of countries. This would allow the EITI International Secretariat to develop a set of comparable statistics for various reporting entities, as well as start constructing guidelines for EITI implementers.
Limited state capacity to carry out core government and service delivery functions poses a major constraint in post conflict countries, especially those with low income levels. With regard to scope, the research carried out for this note primarily focuses on developing a detailed understanding of how civil service institutes are established and function, and to reflect on available information about their impact. This note synthesizes the findings from case studies covering three countries and four public service training institutes: Rwanda (Rwanda Management Institute (RMI)); Uganda (Civil Service College Uganda (CSCU)); and Liberia (Liberia Institute of Public Administration (LIPA) and the Financial Management Training Program (FMTP)). The general policy rationale for establishing institutes of public service has been to improve national public sector capacity; while a key choice involves investing in longer and more in-depth or shorter-term training. To deliver training, a mix of some permanent staff with consultants recruited from the public sectors has worked well.
The purpose of this report on corporate financial reporting in Austria is to describe the key features of Austria's corporate financial reporting environment as well as its practical application in regard to small and medium enterprises (SMEs') financial reporting practices in Austria. This report builds on the World Bank accounting and auditing reports on standards and codes (ROSC) methodology to give an overview of the Austrian corporate financial reporting system. It selectively provides good practice examples that can give incentives to overcome impediments to financial reporting reform. Based on the findings of two surveys conducted among Austrian SMEs and Austrian financial institutions, the report focuses particularly on aspects relevant to SME financial reporting. This report forms part of the activities of the center for financial reporting reform (CFRR) within the road to Europe program of accounting reform and institutional strengthening (REPARIS), which also provided funding.
This paper examines the experiences of the World Bank Group in other countries, and explores its work in Iraq in light of its mandate and areas of impact. It outlines the objectives the Bank Group has sought to meet and the procedures used to adapt to the Iraqi context, while focusing on transparency, inclusiveness, and sustainability. While the Bank's current focus in Iraq is on reconstruction and essential services, the near term offers a chance to lay the groundwork for credible institutions of social inclusion, in addition to supporting sustainable reconstruction and reform. This paper looks at how Iraq, a country with ample natural and human capital, can look past the immediate needs of post-conflict reconstruction to an eventual return as a middle-income country that managed its own affairs and contributed assistance to other countries. Models for reconstruction are closely looked at as to how to move Iraq to country ownership. The paper also looks at how to adopt post conflict reconstruction experience and adapting it to Iraq. The final section of the paper deals with lessons of experience and lessons learned.
The World Bank is launching an initiative aimed at addressing the economic needs of adolescent girls and young women in poor or post-conflict countries. Working together with governments, donors, foundations, and private sector partners, the Bank proposes to develop and test a core set of promising interventions to promote the economic empowerment of adolescent girls and young women. This paper undertakes a review of existing policies and programs designed to promote labor force participation of young women in developing countries. While programs that directly address marriage or fertility can influence young women's labor force participation, the focus of this paper is on programs primarily addressing employment. Some programs for promoting young people's transition into the labor market take a minimalistic approach (for example, concentrating on skills training alone). Other employment programs, particularly those targeted to young women, simultaneously address multiple constraints limiting participation (for example, lack of skills, limited mobility, child care needs, and lack of sexual and reproductive health information). The goal of this paper is to unpack and assess what elements of program design are essential to promoting young women's transition to the labor market. The paper is organized as follows: section one gives introduction. Section two provides an overview of some of the major trends and issues facing young women in the labor market in an international context. Section three describes a selection of best practice programs, some of which are focused exclusively on employment training and others of which take a more integrated approach to providing gender-targeted adolescent services. Section four details the lessons learned from the implementation and evaluation of these programs, and considers the circumstances under which a minimalist versus comprehensive or integrated approach may be most effective. Section five concludes and summarizes the policy and program recommendations.
[eng] The accelerated impact of human activities is causing increasing damages to the Earth's life support systems. Consequently, the policy-making and scientific communities have advocated the urgent need for a change towards the sustainable use of natural resources and ecosystems. This thesis deals with the institutional conditions necessary for that change in coupled social-ecological systems, through an in-depth case study: the Doñana region, an estuarine social-ecological system affected by intricate water resources and wetland conservation problems located in the Guadalquivir Estuary (south-west Spain). In particular, I focus on the need for transitions from command-andcontrol schemes towards more flexible, participatory and adaptive approaches to policy and decision making: specifically, adaptive governance and adaptive management. For this purpose, I address three interrelated questions of broad research interest, using a theoretical framework that combines elements from resilience and institutional path dependence theories. The first question has implications for the implementation of participatory processes in the course of transitional designs towards adaptive governance and management, while the other two have implications at a theoreticanalytical level. The first research question focuses on assessing the usefulness of an action-research program aimed at introducing adaptive management tenets at the research-management interface of the Doñana region (Chapter 4). The program, which paralleled an adaptive restoration in the context of the hydro-ecological restoration project Doñana 2005, combined a formalised process of networking, interviews, focus groups and System Dynamics techniques that proved useful to engage and build trust among a wide range of actors who finally participated in two adaptive management workshops. The participation of stakeholders and agencies entrenched in long-standing conflicts and power struggles up to that date was considered a major success of the program. During the workshops, the participants collaboratively developed a set of policy recommendations, offering potential avenues to improve the research-management interface, water resources management and wetland conservation practices in the Doñana region and Guadalquivir Estuary. The action-research program was supported by preparatory research aimed at analysing the practices of, and learning from, best-in-class practitioners on adaptive management from British Columbia (Canada), where this approach was first conceived and implemented on a large scale (Chapter 3). Such preparatory research, which was based on a document review, interviews and a final workshop at the University of British Columbia (Vancouver), revealed that adaptive management has cycled, during the last four decades, through alternate phases of theoretical development, practical implementation and feedback, to which many scholars and practitioners have contributed. In particular, the workshop allowed current opportunities and constraints for the testing and implementation of adaptive management in Canada to be elicited, based on the direct, on-the-ground experience of practitioners and analysts. The results of that research provided the grounds and support for the strategic development of the action-research program in the Doñana region. The preliminary identification, during the action-research program, of major rigidities within Doñana's institutional framework and management agencies triggered the second part of the thesis, which addressed, through institutional analysis, the two additional research questions mentioned above. The second research question of the thesis focuses on enhancing the understanding of the roots of institutional rigidity in maladaptive social-ecological systems. Institutional rigidity that hinders change and smothers innovation represents a major constraint for adaptive governance and adaptive management. Therefore, to facilitate potential transitions towards more sustainable social-ecological systems characterised by adaptive approaches to decision-making, it is of utmost importance to understand and explain the origins of such institutional rigidity. In Chapter 5, by constructing a historical pattern, I identify the existence of a rigid institutional regime for water resources management and wetland conservation in the Doñana region, and explain, through a first theoretical iteration, the mechanisms underlying the genesis, amplification and persistence of such institutional rigidity. My explanation has two distinguishable parts: on one side, the deep-historical genesis of the regime at a critical juncture in the 19th century; and on the other side, the formation and continuity of the regime up to the last decades of the 20th century, despite its dysfunctionality for coping with crises and its inability to harmonise wetland conservation, water management and economic development. The historical pattern confirms that the Doñana's regime has followed a path-dependent dynamic, largely characterised by the historical recurrence on the application of command-andcontrol schemes. In a seeming paradox, these schemes, instead of driving the regime towards an efficient outcome, led to the formation of a rigid institutional regime that drove the Doñana region into a sub-optimal systemic rigidity trap. This rigid outcome may be theoretically qualified as contingent, for it defies the traditional expectations of neoclassical economics that lie at the logical core of the concept of institutional path dependence. The third research question of the thesis focuses on the explanatory potential of entrepreneurship and discourses, in their relationship with political-economic interests and power, as factors contributing to shape outcomes in local social-ecological systems. In particular, I discussed the explanatory potential of those factors, when the core logic of path dependence (composed by the mainstream principles of neoclassical economics) fails to predict observed outcomes in historical, evolutionary perspective, and qualifies such outcomes as contingent. In Chapter 6, I undertake a second theoretical iteration that re-examines the historical explanatory pattern developed in Chapter 5, in order to show how the Doñana's rigid outcome can be understood as more predictable. In particular, I argue that three mechanisms constituted necessary and sufficient conditions for the transformational process that led to the Doñana's rigid outcome: (1) a contextual political-discursive mechanism that mobilised power top-down and signalled increasing returns to actors downstream of the institutional regime; (2) the operation of increasing returns and self-reinforcing mechanisms bottom-up; (3) an endogenous entrepreneurial component that acted as a mechanism for action in an environment of extreme uncertainty. In the general discussion of the thesis (Chapter 7), I make the case for systematising the role of discourses and entrepreneurship factors, in their relationship with politicaleconomic interests and power, into the analysis. I argue that such systematisation contributes significantly to diminishing the degree of contingency associated to the Doñana's rigid outcome. More generally, my discussion deals with contingency as a property of the path dependence concept that can be modulated in explanations of institutional dynamics. This type of advancements could inform future policy and institutional designs for successful transitions towards adaptive governance and management in social-ecological systems, hence improving the prospects for the sustainable use of natural resources and ecosystems. Enriching the knowledge gathered during the action-research program with the in-depth analysis of institutional constraints rooted in historical factors, allowed a number of potential avenues to be identified that may aid the transition towards adaptive governance and management in the Doñana region (Chapter 9). It also allowed an informed speculation to be made about the potential role of action-research programs such as the one described in this thesis, to comply with (and complement) the requisites for public participation and social learning of European Union legislation: notably, the Water Framework Directive (Chapter 7, Section 7.4). ; [spa] El impacto acelerado de las actividades humanas está causando el aumento de los daños a los sistemas de soporte vital de la Tierra. En consecuencia, gestores y científicos gestores han defendido la necesidad urgente de un cambio hacia el uso sostenible de los recursos naturales y los ecosistemas. Esta tesis trata sobre las condiciones institucionales necesarias para dicho cambio en sistemas socio-ecológicos, a través de un estudio de caso en profundidad: la región de Doñana, un sistema socio-ecológico afectado por problemas complejos en términos de recursos hídricos y conservación de humedales, situado en el Estuario del Guadalquivir (suroeste de España). En particular, en esta tesis me centro en la necesidad de transiciones desde estrategias de mando y control hacia enfoques más flexibles, participativos y adaptativos para la elaboración de políticas y la toma de decisiones: específicamente, gobernanza adaptativa y gestión adaptativa. Para ello, abordo tres preguntas de interés de investigación, amplias e interrelacionadas, utilizando un marco teórico que combina elementos de las teorías de dependencia de la trayectoria institucional y la resiliencia. La primera pregunta tiene implicaciones para la implementación de procesos de participación en el curso del diseño de transiciones hacia la gobernanza y la gestión adaptativas, mientras que las otras dos tienen implicaciones a nivel teórico-analítico. La primera pregunta de investigación se centra en la evaluación de la utilidad de un programa de investigación-acción cuyo objetivo fue introducir principios de gestión adaptativa en la interfaz investigación-gestión de la región de Doñana (Capítulo 4). El programa, que se desarrolló paralelamente a una restauración adaptativa en el contexto del proyecto de restauración hidro-ecológica Doñana 2005, combina un proceso formalizado de networking, entrevistas, grupos focales y técnicas de Dinámica de Sistemas, que demostró ser útil para fomentar la confianza entre un amplio rango de actores que finalmente participaron en dos talleres de gestión adaptativa. La participación de partes interesadas y organismos que se habían visto anteriormente envueltos en situaciones conflictivas y disputas de poder fue considerada un gran éxito del programa. Durante los talleres, los participantes desarrollaron en colaboración una serie de recomendaciones de política, ofreciendo posibles vías para mejorar la interfaz investigación-gestión, la gestión de los recursos hídricos y la conservación de humedales en la región de Doñana y el Estuario del Guadalquivir. El programa de investigación-acción fue apoyado por una investigación preparatoria dirigida a analizar y aprender de las prácticas de profesionales líderes en gestión adaptativa de la Columbia Británica (Canadá), donde este enfoque fue concebido e implementado por primera vez a gran escala (Capítulo 3). Dicha investigación preparatoria se basó en una revisión documental, entrevistas y un taller final en la Universidad de la Columbia Británica (Vancouver), y reveló que la gestión adaptativa ha completado varias fases alternas de desarrollo teórico, aplicación práctica y retroalimentación durante las últimas cuatro décadas, a las que muchos académicos y profesionales han contribuido. En particular, el taller permitió extraer lecciones sobre oportunidades y limitaciones actuales para la implementación y evaluación de la gestión adaptativa en Canadá, basadas en la experiencia directa de profesionales y analistas sobre el terreno. Los resultados de esa investigación sirvieron de base y apoyo para el desarrollo estratégico del programa de investigación-acción en la región de Doñana. La identificación preliminar de importantes rigideces en el marco institucional y las agencias de gestión de Doñana durante el programa de investigación-acción, motivó la segunda parte de la tesis, la cual abordó las dos preguntas de investigación adicionales mencionadas anteriormente, mediante análisis institucional. La segunda pregunta de investigación de la tesis se centra en mejorar la comprensión de las raíces de la rigidez institucional en sistemas socio-ecológicos maladaptativos. La rigidez institucional representa un obstáculo importante para la gobernanza y gestión adaptativas, ya que impide el cambio y dificulta la innovación. Por lo tanto, para facilitar potenciales transiciones hacia sistemas socio-ecológicos más sostenibles caracterizados por enfoques adaptativos para la toma de decisiones, es de suma importancia entender y explicar los orígenes de la rigidez institucional. En el Capítulo 5, a través de la construcción de un patrón histórico, identifico la existencia de un régimen institucional rígido para la gestión de los recursos hídricos y la conservación de los humedales en la región de Doñana, y explico, a través de una primera iteración teórica, los mecanismos subyacentes a la génesis, amplificación y persistencia de tal rigidez institucional. Mi explicación tiene dos partes diferenciadas: por un lado, la génesis histórica profunda del régimen en una coyuntura crítica en el siglo XIX; y por otro, la formación del régimen y su continuidad hasta las últimas décadas del siglo XX, a pesar de su disfuncionalidad para hacer frente a las crisis y su incapacidad para armonizar la conservación de humedales, la gestión del agua y el desarrollo económico. El patrón histórico confirma que el régimen institucional de Doñana ha seguido una dinámica dependiente de la trayectoria, ampliamente caracterizada por la aplicación recurrente de estrategias de mando y control a lo largo de la historia. En una aparente paradoja, estas estrategias, en lugar de conducir al régimen hacia un resultado eficiente, llevaron a la formación de un régimen institucional rígido que condujo la región de Doñana a una trampa subóptima de rigidez sistémica. Este resultado rígido puede ser calificado por la teoría como contingente, ya que desafía las expectativas tradicionales de la economía neoclásica que yacen en el núcleo lógico del concepto de dependencia de la trayectoria institucional. La tercera pregunta de investigación de la tesis se centra en el potencial explicativo del emprendimiento y los discursos en su relación con los intereses político-económicos y el poder, como factores que contribuyen a la formación de sistemas socio-ecológicos a nivel local. En particular, centro mi discusión en el potencial explicativo de estos factores, cuando la lógica base de la dependencia de la trayectoria (compuesta por los principios dominantes de la economía neoclásica) fracasa en predecir los resultados observados desde una perspectiva evolutiva histórica, calificando estos resultados como contingentes. En el Capítulo 6, emprendo una segunda iteración teórica que reexamina el patrón explicativo histórico desarrollado en el Capítulo 5, con el fin de mostrar como el régimen institucional rígido Doñana puede entenderse como más predecible. En particular, sostengo que tres mecanismos constituyeron condiciones necesarias y suficientes para el proceso de transformación que llevó a la rigidez en Doñana: (1) un mecanismo político-discursivo contextual que movilizó el poder desde arriba hacia abajo e indicó rendimientos crecientes a los actores de los niveles operacionales del régimen institucional; (2) el funcionamiento de los rendimientos crecientes y mecanismos de auto-refuerzo de abajo hacia arriba; (3) un componente endógeno de emprendimiento que actuó como mecanismo de acción en un entorno de incertidumbre extrema. En la discusión general de la tesis (Capítulo 7), presento argumentos para la sistematización, en el análisis, de los discursos y el emprendimiento en relación con factores político-económicos y de poder. Sostengo que tal sistematización contribuye significativamente a disminuir el grado de contingencia asociado a la rigidez en Doñana. Más en general, mi discusión trata sobre la contingencia como una propiedad del concepto de dependencia de la trayectoria que se puede modular en explicaciones sobre dinámica institucional. Este tipo de avances podría informar futuras políticas y diseños institucionales para una transición exitosa hacia la gobernanza y la gestión adaptativas de los sistemas socio-ecológicos, y, por lo tanto, para incrementar la posibilidad de gestionar los recursos naturales y los ecosistemas de forma más sostenible. El enriquecimiento del conocimiento adquirido durante el programa de investigaciónacción con el análisis en profundidad de las limitaciones institucionales arraigadas en factores históricos, permitieron la identificación de una serie de posibles vías que pueden ayudar a la transición hacia la gobernanza y la gestión adaptativas en la región de Doñana (Capítulo 9). Asimismo, este enriquecimiento permitió una especulación informada sobre el papel potencial de programas de investigación-acción como el que se describe en esta tesis, para cumplir con (y complementar) los requisitos para la participación pública y el aprendizaje social de la legislación de la Unión Europea – en particular, la Directiva Marco del Agua (Capítulo 7, Sección 7.4).
La ciudad estimó su población de 345.769 pobladores para 1934, habitando 38.000 viviendas en 2100 manzanas con tas solo 1640 instalaciones telefónicas. Tuvo una extensión de 15 km. entre Santa Lucía y Rionegro, por 5 km. de ancho en 1935, con muchos y grandes intersticios vacíos y sin desarrollos al sur y al occidente. El Centro de la ciudad tuvo alta congestión vehicular, a pesar de sus buses y 48,59 km. de líneas de tranvía en 1933. Poseía un aeropuerto privado de Scadta, en el Municipio de Bosa. No contó a comienzos de los treintas con las infraestructuras urgentes en acueducto, alcantarillado ni manejo de residuos sólidos. Las formas de crecimiento urbano características en 1932 fueron la "informal" y la "barraca", que aplazaban el proceso de urbanización y privilegiaban la construcción de las edificaciones. En 1933, se creó el Instituto de Acción Social de Bogotá, para resolver el problema de vivienda y obras públicas en los barrios obreros. Los obreros llevaron una existencia sórdida, antihigiénica, hacinada, con 5,2 miembros por familia, bajos ingresos y con niños y niñas trabajadores. Se relacionó pobreza con hambre y por primera vez con la nutrición. Se asociaron la higiene y la moral en las habitaciones paupérrimas. Se relocalizaron los moradores pobres de los cerros de Bogotá, del proyecto del Paseo Bolívar, en el barrio Centenario en 1938. La urbanización posterior a la ciudad existente fue la gran oportunidad para modernizar la ciudad y que fuera digna de denominarse Capital de la República. Se creó del Departamento de urbanismo en 1933, con Karl Brunner como su primer director al inicio de 1934, y se dispusieron en este Departamento las secciones de Urbanizaciones, Plano Futuro y Arquitectura. Se demandó "el proyecto de planeamiento". Brunner adelantó estudios para urbanizar el occidente y sur de la ciudad, pero no se aprobó ni se conoció bajo su dirección, un plano del futuro desarrollo de la ciudad. La ciudad contó con un Plan de Obras para el Cuarto Centenario propuesto y aprobado inicialmente en 1933 y finalmente modificado en 1935, tras el cual se siguieron proponiendo nuevas obras. En 1938 Bogotá contó con un plano actualizado de la ciudad existente. La ciudad adelantó estadísticas y estudios sociales con el "Departamento de Estadística e Investigación Social" y consideró imprescindible la elaboración de un "censo general". Se modernizaron las entidades municipales, se reorganizaron el Laboratorio de Sanidad, los roperos y restaurantes escolares, los Institutos profesionales para varones y para mujeres y, las licencias y policías específicos para el Departamento de Circulación y Tránsito. Ante el atraso de la urbanización, del acueducto, sus obras de captación, embalse, purificación y conducción, la Nación aportó recursos. Ésta también financió la construcción de la Biblioteca Nacional y del Campus de la Universidad Nacional. Sobre predios donados, el Municipio, con algunos recursos de la Gobernación, construyó el Estadio Municipal El Campín. Se construyeron tramos cortos pero importantes del Paseo Bolívar, Av. Jiménez, Av. Liévano, Av. Caracas, carrera Norte (séptima), Santiago de Chile. En alcantarillado se planteó la construcción de colectores y canales de cuerpos de agua. Respecto de la energía, el tema central crítico fue su ensanche, por el aumento de la demanda, que hicieron necesarias las plantas de El Charquito, y la de El Salto. Se continuó extendiendo la red del tranvía hasta 1938. Se construyeron edificios de la Bolsa de Bogotá y del Instituto Federico Lleras Acosta, el teatro al aire libre de la Media Torta y las 500 casas para obreros en el barrio del Centenario. Se construyeron escuelas para niños y para niñas. Se terminaron y dotaron plazas de mercado, nuevo matadero y pabellón par expendio de carnes. Se construyeron hornos crematorios de basuras. Las Juntas de Mejoras públicas de los barrios continuaron gestionando las obras de pavimentos, alcantarillas, escuelas públicas, plazas de mercado y kioscos sanitarios. La ciudad jardín y el movimiento moderno estuvieron presentes durante la discusión del Plan de Obras del IV Centenario. El Registro Municipal refirió congresos, conferencias internacionales y nacionales, artículos y reseñas, con las diferencias conceptuales de Ciudad Jardín y el Movimiento Moderno de la Arquitectura. Se abordaron: el urbanismo, la vivienda popular, los barrios insalubres y su higienización y las 'casas baratas', el crecimiento de las ciudades y de sus centros, su historia y evolución, el patrimonio natural y construido y la arquitectura. Se mencionaron las ciudades satélites, sus "cinturones verdes", los suburbios, la relación ciudad campo, el planeamiento regional, el metropolitalismo, el régimen especial para la ciudad capital, la zonificación, las vías radiales o diagonales versus los trazados ortogonales. Se redujeron las exenciones para aumentar la tributación y financiar las obras del Centenario, imponiendo normas científicas y modernas de cálculo tributario. Se organizó el sorteo de la Lotería del Centenario para costear las obras. Se creó el Fondo Rotatorio de Fomento social y el Banco Central Hipotecario para estimular el ahorro para vivienda. También se aprobó el impuesto de valorización. Nos comparamos con otras naciones con relación a las migraciones a sus ciudades capitales, las ventajas y desventajas de las ciudades modernas, el ensanche de las calles, la sanidad, el estado del bienestar social, la pobreza, los barrios populares, las finanzas municipales, el tráfico y las condiciones habitables de las viviendas. Se recibieron muchos saludos al Centenario de Bogotá, desde otros municipios nacionales y ciudades extranjeras. Se decretó para 1938 levantar el "censo civil de la República" de edificaciones y población. Se realizó la Exposición Nacional del IV Centenario, con el apoyo de la Nación y del Departamento. La modernización fue la tarea central que se propuso Bogotá para considerarse de manera diferenciada La Capital de la República. Se discutía la municipalización o privatización de los servicios municipales, la elección de alcaldes por los Concejos y no por el Gobernador. El nuevo espíritu cívico dejo de ser de los empresarios o asociaciones privadas para estar desarrolladas por las entidades municipales. Algunas élites municipales dieron importancia a las condiciones sociales de la propiedad, su función social, discutiendo privilegiar prioritariamente a las clases bajas sobre las medias. Se pretendió modernizar las costumbres, el aseo, divulgar el deporte y las granjas urbanas. Se mencionó modernizar la demografía con la pasterización de la leche, "las prácticas anticoncepcionales, el aborto y la esterilización". Se impulsó un "sistema de ahorro postal". El Paseo Bolívar se planteó como una franja sanitaria y una bella vía sobre el paisaje de la ciudad, y como un reconocimiento de las clases menos pudientes con derecho a vivienda urbanizada, como el barrio Centenario. Se llevaron a cabo la construcción de Barrios para empleados Muequetá, Las Mercedes, y para obreros, entre otros el Calderón Tejada. Se continuó insistiendo en otorgarle a Bogotá el carácter de Distrito Capital. Se llevaron a cabo las festividades del Centenario entre el 20 de julio y el 7 de agosto de 1938 en muchos lugares distintos de la ciudad. Se reconoció al Fundador y a los indígenas Chibchas. La celebración de los Juegos Bolivarianos en los nuevos estadios de la Universidad Nacional y el Nemesio Camacho, acogieron de forma permanente el foot ball en la cultura Bogotana. Se modernizó el manejo del tránsito en la ciudad con la compra de buses. ; Abstract: The city: In 1934, the city estimated that its population was 345,769 inhabitants, living in 38,000 homes over 2,100 blocks, and with 1,640 telephone lines. In 1935, the city was 15 km long from Santa Lucía to Rionegro, and 5 km wide, with many large vacant areas and no development to the south and west. In 1933, the city center had considerable traffic congestion, despite its buses and 48.59 km of tram lines. Scadta private airport operated in the municipality of Bosa. In the early 1930s, the city lacked urgently needed aqueduct, sewer, and solid waste management infrastructure. In 1932, the main styles of urban growth were "informal" and "slums," which delayed urbanization and favored self-build construction. In 1933, the Institute of Social Action of Bogotá was created to solve housing and public works problems in the working-class neighborhoods. The workers lived in sordid, unhygienic, overcrowded conditions, with 5.2 members per family, low income, and child labor. Poverty gave rise to hunger, and the impact of nutrition was understood for the first time. Poor hygiene and dubious morals were associated with the housing of the very poor. In 1938, the impoverished residents living on the slopes of Bogotá's mountainsides were relocated to the Paseo Bolivar project in the Centenario neighborhood. Urbanization: The city's subsequent urbanization was a great opportunity to modernize and make the city worthy of its denomination Capital of the Republic. The Department of Urban Planning was created in 1933, with Karl Brunner at the helm as the first director in early 1934. The department included divisions for Urbanization, Future Plans, and Architecture. "Project Planning" was in demand. Brunner led studies to urbanize the western and southern parts of the city, but no plan for the future development of the city was approved or distributed under his direction. The city's Quadricentennial Work Plan was initially approved in 1933 and modified in 1935, after which new works continued to be proposed. By 1938, Bogotá had an up-to-date map of the existing city. The Department of Statistics and Social Research gathered statistics and undertook social studies on the city, and decided that it was essential to do a general census. The municipal agencies were modernized, and reorganization was done of the Health Laboratory, school clothing and food programs, professional institutes for men and women, licenses, and the Traffic and Transit Police force was created. Given the shortcomings in the urban aqueduct system, the nation contributed resources for channeling water, reservoirs, purification, and water distribution. It also financed the construction of the National Library and the National University campus. The municipality, with some resources from the departmental government, built the Nemésio Camacho El Campín Stadium on donated land. Short but important sections of the roads Paseo Bolívar, Av. Jiménez, Av. Liévano, Av. Caracas, Carrera Norte (Carrera 7), and Av. Santiago de Chile were built. The construction of water collectors and channels was considered for the sewage system. In terms of electricity, the critical issue was increasing production to meet increasing demand, which made the El Charquito and El Salto plants necessary. The tramway network continued to spread until 1938. The Bogotá Stock Exchange, the Federico Lleras Acosta Institute, and the Media Torta amphitheater were built, as well as 500 houses for workers in the Centenario neighborhood. Schools for boys and girls were built. Markets were built and provisioned, along with a new slaughterhouse and meat dispensary. Garbage incinerators were built. Neighborhood Public Improvement Boards continued to organize paving projects, sewer systems, public schools, markets, and healthcare posts. The Garden City and the Modern Movement were part of the discussion of the Quadricentennial Public Works Plan. Municipal records mention congresses, national and international conferences, articles and reviews, addressing the different concepts of the Garden City and the Modern Architecture Movement. The issues examined included: urbanism, self-build housing, sanitation and unhealthy neighborhoods and "cheap housing," the growth of cities and their centers, their history and evolution, natural and constructed heritage, and architecture. Satellite cities, green belts, suburbs, city-greenspace proportions, regional planning, metropolitanism, a special planning regime for the capital district, zoning, and radial or diagonal roadways versus grid plan roadways were discussed. Modern and scientific tax calculation standards were used to reduce tax exemptions and increase revenues to finance the Quadricentennial works. The Centennial Lottery was created to help finance the works. The Revolving Fund for Social Development and the Central Mortgage Bank were created to encourage savings for housing. The land betterment tax was created. Colombia looked to other countries to compare itself in terms of migration to the capital cities, the advantages and disadvantages of modern cities, the widening of the streets, healthcare, social welfare, poverty, working-class neighborhoods, municipal finances, traffic, and housing conditions. Many municipalities around the country and foreign cities sent greetings to Bogotá for the Quadricentennial. It was decided that a census of buildings and people would be done in 1938. The Quadricentennial National Exhibition was held, with the support of the nation and the department. Modernization was Bogotá's main goal so that the Capital of the Republic would be seen as different. The municipalization or privatization of municipal services was discussed, as was the proposal to have City Council elect the mayor, instead of being appointed by the departmental governor. Municipal agencies set the tone for the new civic spirit, instead of businesses or private associations. Some municipal decision-makers stressed the importance of the social aspects of property, its social function, arguing in favor of prioritizing the lower-income classes over the middle classes. The aim was to modernize practices, cleanliness, encourage sports and urban gardens. The population would be modernized with the pasteurization of milk, "contraceptive practices, abortion and sterilization." A postal savings bank was created. Paseo Bolívar was conceived to be a greenspace and a beautiful lookout over the city, and also as recognition that the less affluent classes have the right to urban development, such as the Centenario neighborhood. Neighborhoods such as Muequetá and Las Mercedes were built for company employees, and others were built for laborers, such as Calderón Tejada, among others. Importance was placed on continuing to transform Bogota into a Capital District. The Quadricentennial festivities were held between July 20 and August 7, 1938 in locations throughout the city. The city's founder and the Chibcha indigenous origins were commemorated. The Bolivarian Games were hosted in the new stadium at the National University and the Nemésio Camacho El Campín stadium, which is the permanent home of "football" in Bogota. Traffic management in the city was modernized with the purchase of buses. Keywords: Bogotá, urban history, modernization, urban planning. ; Maestría
This 68th issue of the journal Cuadernos de Administración corresponds to the September-December 2020 period and gives closure to volume 36 on its 44th year. Twenty-twenty was a different year in many respects and with regards to past editorial processes, as it was faced with limitation and challenges associated with situation-specific constraints, new issues, and problems to be addressed, such as research in the sciences of administration, among other areas of the knowledge.As with past issues, the 16 papers published in issue 68 come from the previous months' call, whose authors - from several countries and different regions of Colombia - entrusted their manuscripts to our editorial process. I thank our peer reviewers who supported us through their experience and expertise in assessing each paper for what we believe is an objectivity-based academic dialogue that seeks to recognize the quality of the scientific output proposed for each issue of Cuadernos de Administración. The first three papers in this issue are "Development of typical vacuum-packed and frozen Boyaca soups", "Territorial Governance: A bibliometric analysis" and "University reports in Colombia: a contribution to accountability" The first paper's authors study gastronomy and tourism in the department of Boyacá, Colombia, and their production processes to facilitate product handling and increase their offer to tourists. The second one is a bibliometric literature study analyzing territorial governance by analyzing papers from the Web of Science. The third paper presents the current state of accountability in Colombian public universities through research carried out analyzing university reports using the content analysis method.The second group of papers includes those entitled "The effect of human resource management practices and innovation: Colombian small and medium-sized enterprises", "Quality Assessment in the Context of Banking Services" and "Performance appraisal: an experience between recognition and contempt" The first paper of that group accounts for the research carried with SME 492 managers in Cali, Bogotá, and Medellín on human resources management practices and their innovation effect. The second paper uses theoretical systematization to approach the quality assessment of services, banking services in this case, from a critical standpoint. The third article is a case study that uses qualitative interviews on a group of workers from a Colombian company in the energy generation and distribution sector. It examined the recognition or contempt experienced by and evidenced in the workers' discourse after undergoing a performance appraisal designed under the Strategic Human Resources Management (SHRM) logic. The third group of articles consists of those entitled "A comprehensive tax reform under OECD parameters for Colombia", "Updating the strategic framework for the Spanish port system using a SWOT analysis" and "Correlating affective commitment with prosocial behavior: Does it matter to perceive that work has meaning?" The first one studies tax reforms in Colombia, the orientation of these, and identifies structuring-related problems. The second paper uses the SWOT analysis and benchmarking to analyze the Spanish port system. Finally, in the third paper, a study was conducted on 144 professional employees across various Colombian industries to analyze their prosocial behavior and attitudes in different organizational environments and under varying management practices, which may or may not promote prosocial behavior."Absenteeism at work, remuneration, and equity: a confusing relationship", "The role of family dynamics and culture in the psychological ownership of family shareholders in family businesses" and "Prospective and its valuation in public policy of two regional development strategies in Chile" are the papers that follow in this number. The first paper presents the results of a study conducted in a higher education institution that analyzes the relationship between absenteeism, workers' compensation, and equity variables using statistical methods and based on 840 inputs. The second article studies 14 cases of Colombian and 5 Finns shareholders using qualitative and exploratory methods to analyze the role of family dynamics and culture in developing psychological ownership in family shareholders. The third article studies Chilean public officials' perception of prospective from a qualitative approach, which is considered a tool for public policies in two regional development strategies. The following two papers are "Social commitment in organizations: a look at Universidad del Valle" and "Current Challenges of the Social Function of Accounting" The first of the aforementioned papers' authors study social commitment in a case study applied to the Universidad del Valle through interviews with officials and using content analysis on the Outreach Office's management reports and the University's Strategic Development Plans. The second article aims to determine potential social costs and financial statements' models for social accounting.The last group of articles includes "Strengths and opportunities of sustainable entrepreneurship in Colombia" and "Institutional isomorphism in IPSAS adoption" The first case is an analysis of the strengths and opportunities of sustainable entrepreneurship in Colombia based on the review of papers published in the Colombian context, as available in the primary databases (national journals and university repositories were also included). The last article presents the results of a systematic literature review to study institutional isomorphism in governments' implementation of IPSAS into their accounting model.The publication of Universidad del Valle's Faculty of Administration's 68th issue of Cuadernos de Administración consolidates us as a means of dissemination for scientific knowledge in that area. Twenty twenty-one will see our 45th year of publication, for which there will be a thematic issue on Circular Economy, with the support of HEC Montreal and the ITESM. In that anniversary framework, the first issue will present an analysis of these 45 years' publications, among other activities. Once again, we thank each of the authors of these 16 papers and the peer reviewers who supported our editorial process, always bearing in mind that each article's content is its authors' responsibility. We hope that this issue will contribute to our readers' academic work and that it will drive our research, reflections, or reviews in the sciences of administration. ; Este número 68 de la revista Cuadernos de Administración, corresponde al período septiembre-diciembre del año 2020, cerrando el volumen 36, y con 44 años de publicación. El 2020 termina siendo un año distinto desde muchos aspectos, en relación con los procesos editoriales anteriores, con limitaciones y retos asociados con las restricciones propias de la situación y con nuevos temas y problemas para abordar, como las investigaciones en las ciencias de la administración, entre otras áreas del conocimiento. Como en los diferentes números, los 16 artículos que publicamos en el 68 son el resultado del llamado artículos de meses anteriores, donde autores de varios países y de distintas regiones de Colombia, confiaron sus manuscritos a nuestro proceso editorial. Agradezco a los árbitros que con su experiencia y experticia nos acompañaron en la evaluación de cada uno de ellos, en lo que para nosotros es un diálogo académico, que busca desde la objetividad, reconocer la calidad de la producción científica propuesta para cada número de Cuadernos de Administración. Los tres primeros artículos de este número son: "Desarrollo de sopas típicas boyacenses empacadas al vacío y congeladas", "Gobernanza Territorial: Un análisis bibliométrico" y "Reportes universitarios en Colombia: un aporte a la rendición de cuentas". En el primero, los autores estudian la gastronomía y el turismo en el departamento de Boyacá, Colombia, desde su proceso de producción para facilitar el manejo del producto y aumentar la oferta a los turistas. El segundo, corresponde a un estudio bibliométrico de literatura, donde, desde el análisis de artículos de Web of Science, se analiza el campo de la gobernanza territorial. El tercer, presenta el estado actual de la rendición de cuentas de universidades públicas colombianas, en una investigación realizada desde los reportes universitarios aplicando cómo método, un análisis de contenido. El segundo grupo de artículos incluye: "Efecto de las prácticas de gestión humana e innovación: Pequeñas y Medianas Empresas colombianas", "La evaluación de la calidad en el contexto de los servicios bancarios" y "La evaluación del desempeño: una experiencia entre el reconocimiento y el menosprecio". El primer artículo de este grupo, es una investigación realizada a 492 gerentes de las Pymes de Cali, Bogotá y Medellín, sobre las prácticas de gestión humana y su efecto de innovación. En el segundo, se utiliza la sistematización teórica, para, desde una postura crítica, abordar el estudio de la evaluación de la calidad de los servicios, para este caso, los bancarios. El tercer artículo es un estudio de caso, donde, por medio de entrevistas cualitativas a un grupo de trabajadores de una empresa colombiana del sector de generación y distribución de energía, se examinan las experiencias de reconocimiento o de menosprecio que se evidencian en el discurso de los trabajadores luego de haber sido sujetos de una práctica de evaluación del desempeño diseñada bajo la lógica de la Administración Estratégica de Recursos Humanos (AERH). En el tercer grupo de artículos, se encuentran: "Una reforma tributaria integral con parámetros OECD para Colombia", "Actualización del marco estratégico para el sistema portuario español empleando un análisis DAFO" y "Correlacionando el compromiso afectivo con el comportamiento prosocial: ¿Importa percibir que el trabajo tiene significado?" El primero, es un estudio sobre las reformas tributarias en Colombia, la orientación de estas y se identifican problemas asociados con la estructuración. El segundo, utilizando el análisis DAFO y el benchmarking se analiza el sistema portuario español. Finalmente, en el tercero, se realiza un estudio a 144 empleados profesionales de varias industrias colombianas, para analizar su comportamiento prosocial, y actitudes en los diferentes entornos organizacionales y bajo distintas prácticas gerenciales, que pueden o no, fomentar el comportamiento prosocial. "Ausentismo laboral, remuneración y equidad: una relación confusa", "El rol de las dinámicas familiares y la cultura en la propiedad psicológica en accionistas familiares" y "La prospectiva y su valoración en la política pública de dos estrategias regionales de desarrollo chilenas", son los siguientes artículos de este número. En el primero, se presentan los resultados de un estudio realizado en una institución de educación superior, donde, desde 840 datos, se analiza la relación existente entre las variables ausentismo, compensación y equidad de los trabajadores, utilizando métodos estadísticos. En el segundo, se estudian 14 casos de accionistas colombianos y 5 finlandeses, desde métodos cualitativos y exploratorios para analizar el rol de las dinámicas familiares y la cultura en el desarrollo de la propiedad psicológica en accionistas familiares. En el tercer artículo, desde un enfoque cualitativo se aborda el estudio de la percepción desde los funcionarios públicos chilenos, que se tiene de la prospectiva como herramienta para las políticas públicas en dos estrategias regionales de desarrollo. Los dos siguientes artículos: "Compromiso social en las organizaciones: una mirada a las instituciones de educación superior" y "Retos actuales de la función social de la contabilidad". En el primero, los autores estudian el compromiso social en un estudio de caso aplicado a la Universidad del Valle, por medio de entrevistas a funcionarios, y del análisis de contenido a los informes de gestión de las Oficinas de Extensión y de los Planes Estratégicos de Desarrollo de la Universidad. El segundo artículo, tiene como propósito determinar posibles costos sociales y modelos de estados financieros para la contabilidad social. El último grupo de artículos, incluye: "Fortalezas y oportunidades del emprendimiento sostenible en Colombia" y "El isomorfismo institucional en la adopción de las IPSAS". En el primer caso es un análisis de las fortalezas y las oportunidades del emprendimiento sostenible en Colombia, desde una revisión documental de artículos publicados en el contexto colombiano, disponibles en las principales bases de datos, también se incluyeron revistas nacionales y repositorios universitarios. El último artículo, presenta los resultados de una revisión sistemática de la literatura, para estudiar el isomorfismo institucional en la adopción de las IPSAS en el modelo contable por parte de los gobiernos. La publicación del número 68 de Cuadernos de Administración de la Facultad de Ciencias de la Administración de la Universidad del Valle, hace que nos consolidémonos como un medio de divulgación del conocimiento científico en el área. En el año 2021, cumpliremos 45 años de publicación, por este motivo se publicará un número temático sobre Economía Circular, con el apoyo de HEC Montreal y TEC de Monterrey. En el marco de esta celebración, en el primer número se presentará, entre otras actividades, un análisis de las publicaciones en estos 45 años. De nuevo agradecemos a cada uno de los autores de estos 16 artículos y a los árbitros que nos acompañaron en el proceso editorial, recordando que el contenido de los diferentes artículos es responsabilidad de sus autores. Esperamos que para nuestros lectores este número sea un aporte en su trabajo académico y que motive nuestras investigaciones, reflexiones o revisiones en las ciencias de la administración.
This 68th issue of the journal Cuadernos de Administración corresponds to the September-December 2020 period and gives closure to volume 36 on its 44th year. Twenty-twenty was a different year in many respects and with regards to past editorial processes, as it was faced with limitation and challenges associated with situation-specific constraints, new issues, and problems to be addressed, such as research in the sciences of administration, among other areas of the knowledge.As with past issues, the 16 papers published in issue 68 come from the previous months' call, whose authors - from several countries and different regions of Colombia - entrusted their manuscripts to our editorial process. I thank our peer reviewers who supported us through their experience and expertise in assessing each paper for what we believe is an objectivity-based academic dialogue that seeks to recognize the quality of the scientific output proposed for each issue of Cuadernos de Administración. The first three papers in this issue are "Development of typical vacuum-packed and frozen Boyaca soups", "Territorial Governance: A bibliometric analysis" and "University reports in Colombia: a contribution to accountability" The first paper's authors study gastronomy and tourism in the department of Boyacá, Colombia, and their production processes to facilitate product handling and increase their offer to tourists. The second one is a bibliometric literature study analyzing territorial governance by analyzing papers from the Web of Science. The third paper presents the current state of accountability in Colombian public universities through research carried out analyzing university reports using the content analysis method.The second group of papers includes those entitled "The effect of human resource management practices and innovation: Colombian small and medium-sized enterprises", "Quality Assessment in the Context of Banking Services" and "Performance appraisal: an experience between recognition and contempt" The first paper of that group accounts for the research carried with SME 492 managers in Cali, Bogotá, and Medellín on human resources management practices and their innovation effect. The second paper uses theoretical systematization to approach the quality assessment of services, banking services in this case, from a critical standpoint. The third article is a case study that uses qualitative interviews on a group of workers from a Colombian company in the energy generation and distribution sector. It examined the recognition or contempt experienced by and evidenced in the workers' discourse after undergoing a performance appraisal designed under the Strategic Human Resources Management (SHRM) logic. The third group of articles consists of those entitled "A comprehensive tax reform under OECD parameters for Colombia", "Updating the strategic framework for the Spanish port system using a SWOT analysis" and "Correlating affective commitment with prosocial behavior: Does it matter to perceive that work has meaning?" The first one studies tax reforms in Colombia, the orientation of these, and identifies structuring-related problems. The second paper uses the SWOT analysis and benchmarking to analyze the Spanish port system. Finally, in the third paper, a study was conducted on 144 professional employees across various Colombian industries to analyze their prosocial behavior and attitudes in different organizational environments and under varying management practices, which may or may not promote prosocial behavior."Absenteeism at work, remuneration, and equity: a confusing relationship", "The role of family dynamics and culture in the psychological ownership of family shareholders in family businesses" and "Prospective and its valuation in public policy of two regional development strategies in Chile" are the papers that follow in this number. The first paper presents the results of a study conducted in a higher education institution that analyzes the relationship between absenteeism, workers' compensation, and equity variables using statistical methods and based on 840 inputs. The second article studies 14 cases of Colombian and 5 Finns shareholders using qualitative and exploratory methods to analyze the role of family dynamics and culture in developing psychological ownership in family shareholders. The third article studies Chilean public officials' perception of prospective from a qualitative approach, which is considered a tool for public policies in two regional development strategies. The following two papers are "Social commitment in organizations: a look at Universidad del Valle" and "Current Challenges of the Social Function of Accounting" The first of the aforementioned papers' authors study social commitment in a case study applied to the Universidad del Valle through interviews with officials and using content analysis on the Outreach Office's management reports and the University's Strategic Development Plans. The second article aims to determine potential social costs and financial statements' models for social accounting.The last group of articles includes "Strengths and opportunities of sustainable entrepreneurship in Colombia" and "Institutional isomorphism in IPSAS adoption" The first case is an analysis of the strengths and opportunities of sustainable entrepreneurship in Colombia based on the review of papers published in the Colombian context, as available in the primary databases (national journals and university repositories were also included). The last article presents the results of a systematic literature review to study institutional isomorphism in governments' implementation of IPSAS into their accounting model.The publication of Universidad del Valle's Faculty of Administration's 68th issue of Cuadernos de Administración consolidates us as a means of dissemination for scientific knowledge in that area. Twenty twenty-one will see our 45th year of publication, for which there will be a thematic issue on Circular Economy, with the support of HEC Montreal and the ITESM. In that anniversary framework, the first issue will present an analysis of these 45 years' publications, among other activities. Once again, we thank each of the authors of these 16 papers and the peer reviewers who supported our editorial process, always bearing in mind that each article's content is its authors' responsibility. We hope that this issue will contribute to our readers' academic work and that it will drive our research, reflections, or reviews in the sciences of administration. ; Este número 68 de la revista Cuadernos de Administración, corresponde al período septiembre-diciembre del año 2020, cerrando el volumen 36, y con 44 años de publicación. El 2020 termina siendo un año distinto desde muchos aspectos, en relación con los procesos editoriales anteriores, con limitaciones y retos asociados con las restricciones propias de la situación y con nuevos temas y problemas para abordar, como las investigaciones en las ciencias de la administración, entre otras áreas del conocimiento. Como en los diferentes números, los 16 artículos que publicamos en el 68 son el resultado del llamado artículos de meses anteriores, donde autores de varios países y de distintas regiones de Colombia, confiaron sus manuscritos a nuestro proceso editorial. Agradezco a los árbitros que con su experiencia y experticia nos acompañaron en la evaluación de cada uno de ellos, en lo que para nosotros es un diálogo académico, que busca desde la objetividad, reconocer la calidad de la producción científica propuesta para cada número de Cuadernos de Administración. Los tres primeros artículos de este número son: "Desarrollo de sopas típicas boyacenses empacadas al vacío y congeladas", "Gobernanza Territorial: Un análisis bibliométrico" y "Reportes universitarios en Colombia: un aporte a la rendición de cuentas". En el primero, los autores estudian la gastronomía y el turismo en el departamento de Boyacá, Colombia, desde su proceso de producción para facilitar el manejo del producto y aumentar la oferta a los turistas. El segundo, corresponde a un estudio bibliométrico de literatura, donde, desde el análisis de artículos de Web of Science, se analiza el campo de la gobernanza territorial. El tercer, presenta el estado actual de la rendición de cuentas de universidades públicas colombianas, en una investigación realizada desde los reportes universitarios aplicando cómo método, un análisis de contenido. El segundo grupo de artículos incluye: "Efecto de las prácticas de gestión humana e innovación: Pequeñas y Medianas Empresas colombianas", "La evaluación de la calidad en el contexto de los servicios bancarios" y "La evaluación del desempeño: una experiencia entre el reconocimiento y el menosprecio". El primer artículo de este grupo, es una investigación realizada a 492 gerentes de las Pymes de Cali, Bogotá y Medellín, sobre las prácticas de gestión humana y su efecto de innovación. En el segundo, se utiliza la sistematización teórica, para, desde una postura crítica, abordar el estudio de la evaluación de la calidad de los servicios, para este caso, los bancarios. El tercer artículo es un estudio de caso, donde, por medio de entrevistas cualitativas a un grupo de trabajadores de una empresa colombiana del sector de generación y distribución de energía, se examinan las experiencias de reconocimiento o de menosprecio que se evidencian en el discurso de los trabajadores luego de haber sido sujetos de una práctica de evaluación del desempeño diseñada bajo la lógica de la Administración Estratégica de Recursos Humanos (AERH). En el tercer grupo de artículos, se encuentran: "Una reforma tributaria integral con parámetros OECD para Colombia", "Actualización del marco estratégico para el sistema portuario español empleando un análisis DAFO" y "Correlacionando el compromiso afectivo con el comportamiento prosocial: ¿Importa percibir que el trabajo tiene significado?" El primero, es un estudio sobre las reformas tributarias en Colombia, la orientación de estas y se identifican problemas asociados con la estructuración. El segundo, utilizando el análisis DAFO y el benchmarking se analiza el sistema portuario español. Finalmente, en el tercero, se realiza un estudio a 144 empleados profesionales de varias industrias colombianas, para analizar su comportamiento prosocial, y actitudes en los diferentes entornos organizacionales y bajo distintas prácticas gerenciales, que pueden o no, fomentar el comportamiento prosocial. "Ausentismo laboral, remuneración y equidad: una relación confusa", "El rol de las dinámicas familiares y la cultura en la propiedad psicológica en accionistas familiares" y "La prospectiva y su valoración en la política pública de dos estrategias regionales de desarrollo chilenas", son los siguientes artículos de este número. En el primero, se presentan los resultados de un estudio realizado en una institución de educación superior, donde, desde 840 datos, se analiza la relación existente entre las variables ausentismo, compensación y equidad de los trabajadores, utilizando métodos estadísticos. En el segundo, se estudian 14 casos de accionistas colombianos y 5 finlandeses, desde métodos cualitativos y exploratorios para analizar el rol de las dinámicas familiares y la cultura en el desarrollo de la propiedad psicológica en accionistas familiares. En el tercer artículo, desde un enfoque cualitativo se aborda el estudio de la percepción desde los funcionarios públicos chilenos, que se tiene de la prospectiva como herramienta para las políticas públicas en dos estrategias regionales de desarrollo. Los dos siguientes artículos: "Compromiso social en las organizaciones: una mirada a las instituciones de educación superior" y "Retos actuales de la función social de la contabilidad". En el primero, los autores estudian el compromiso social en un estudio de caso aplicado a la Universidad del Valle, por medio de entrevistas a funcionarios, y del análisis de contenido a los informes de gestión de las Oficinas de Extensión y de los Planes Estratégicos de Desarrollo de la Universidad. El segundo artículo, tiene como propósito determinar posibles costos sociales y modelos de estados financieros para la contabilidad social. El último grupo de artículos, incluye: "Fortalezas y oportunidades del emprendimiento sostenible en Colombia" y "El isomorfismo institucional en la adopción de las IPSAS". En el primer caso es un análisis de las fortalezas y las oportunidades del emprendimiento sostenible en Colombia, desde una revisión documental de artículos publicados en el contexto colombiano, disponibles en las principales bases de datos, también se incluyeron revistas nacionales y repositorios universitarios. El último artículo, presenta los resultados de una revisión sistemática de la literatura, para estudiar el isomorfismo institucional en la adopción de las IPSAS en el modelo contable por parte de los gobiernos. La publicación del número 68 de Cuadernos de Administración de la Facultad de Ciencias de la Administración de la Universidad del Valle, hace que nos consolidémonos como un medio de divulgación del conocimiento científico en el área. En el año 2021, cumpliremos 45 años de publicación, por este motivo se publicará un número temático sobre Economía Circular, con el apoyo de HEC Montreal y TEC de Monterrey. En el marco de esta celebración, en el primer número se presentará, entre otras actividades, un análisis de las publicaciones en estos 45 años. De nuevo agradecemos a cada uno de los autores de estos 16 artículos y a los árbitros que nos acompañaron en el proceso editorial, recordando que el contenido de los diferentes artículos es responsabilidad de sus autores. Esperamos que para nuestros lectores este número sea un aporte en su trabajo académico y que motive nuestras investigaciones, reflexiones o revisiones en las ciencias de la administración.
Ladies and GentlemenGood morningAt the outset of my speech, I'd like to personally welcome all the respected attendees, from our home country Iran and abroad, respected invitees from ISESCO and the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology, researchers and scientists from Iranian universities, editor-in-chiefs of ISC-indexed journals from Iran and the regional countries, my colleagues from ISC and RICEST and all those who participated in one way or another to make this unique event come true. I firmly believe that bringing inspired people together in a forum like this would ensure that ISC always remains at the cutting edge.Before I commence I tend to name those humble people for whose association and help we here at ISC are so proud as well as grateful. To me, such public thank you is a veiled declaration of intimacy with those who have been in a position to lend assistance to ISC since its establishment in 2008.First, my sincerest thanks go to H, E, Dr.Othman Altwijiri, Director General of ISESCO for the key role His Excellency played in the establishment of the Islamic World Science Citation Center (ISC).Second, I am much indebted to Dr.Faiq Bilal, Director of Science Directorate of ISESCO, for his contribution to the holding of this conference.Third, my appreciations Vahid Ahmadi, the MSRT's Vice-Minister for Research and Technology, for full support of ISC and its programs. Also, I am appreciative of the helps we received from Dr, Salar Amoli for producing Visa for our respected guests from the OIC countries.Finally, I thank my colleagues at the ISC and RICEST, the editor-in-chiefs of ISC-indexed journals, researchers and colleagues from Iranian universities and all the attendees without whose presence this whole program could be nothing but a fail.The idea of founding a citation center to assess research performance of OIC countries' research output was first conceived in the third Islamic Conference of Ministers of Higher Education and Scientific Research, held in Kuwait City, State of Kuwait, between November 19-21, 2006. There, the delegate from the Islamic Republic of Iran took the initiative and put forward the idea of founding such a center to assess OIC countries research performance. This idea was welcomed by all members of ISESCO and was hence included in the agenda.The proposal was worked on successfully and put on the table during the fourth Islamic Conference of Ministers of Higher Education and Scientific Research, held in Baku, Capital of the Republic of Azerbaijan, in October, 2008. During that meeting, the proposal was discussed and verified with absolute majority and the I. R. of Iran was bestowed with the responsibility to establish such a citation center. And that is in brief how ISC was established in Shiraz, south of Iran.ISC seeks to assess research performance of OIC countries. Great strides have been made by the directing body of ISC to provide the infrastructure required for the successful fulfillment of this objective.I am obliged here to avow here that ISC's achievements during its short life have been phenomenal, in need, owing to the constant help and support received from Iran's Ministry of Science, Research and Technology as well as Iran's High Council for Cultural Revolution. These two supporting bodies guaranteed ISC's accomplishments by adopting scientific, administrative and financial policies required.Assessment of research performance is a complicated phenomenon involving an array of variables and indicators. In general, citation systems – like ISI, Scopus and ISC - undertake various types of assessments and rankings through a number of indicators including researchers, scientific journals, subject fields, universities, research institutions and countries. Currently, ISC ranks third, after ISI (from Thomson Reuters with a history of more than half a century) and Scopus (in the Netherlands, with a history of about two decades) in the whole world. Both ISI and Scopus are well known citation systems embodying a number of interesting products and services of which the scientific community can avail it. Despite these advantages, they fail to cover local languages and concentrate only on English resources. In contrast, ISC, despite its short history, has endeavored to cover languages other than English as well. The long term objective has of course been to cover all national languages in OIC has been produced such that it can be expanded, on demand to cover OIC languages. No doubt, this is time-taking process due to the linguistic difficulties embedded in such practices. This difficulty is well justifiable when we observe that even global ranking systems like ISI and SCOPUS have avoided local languages despite the long time and better resources they have had for development.I would like to announce here that ISC currently processes journals in three languages, i.e. Persian, Arabic and English and seeks to cover French shortly since it is used in a number of OIC countries. This is a non-stop process and having covered French we will seek to include other languages from the OIC region.Having OIC region as its scope has not acted of course as a restriction for the realm of our activities. Interestingly, we have been receiving requests from non-OIC countries (including America, England, Finland, Poland, Russia, India, …) as well to have their journals indexed in ISC. So, the regional ISC has now upgraded into a global ranking system ranking universities, journals, etc. from all over the world.To date, 1117 Arabic journals, 1056 English ones and 403 journals from other languages are indexed in ISC. The number of Iranian journals indexed in ISC is also remarkable – 1046 journals affiliated to the Ministry of Science, Research and Technology, 331 journals from the Ministry of Health, Treatment and Medical Training, and 250 journals affiliated to the Islamic Azad University.This simply means that ISC currently indexes more than 4000 journal titles from Iran, OIC and of course non-OIC countries. Of course, this sum is a fraction of the whole journals available in the international scientific community, and hence not that bulky in its present status, nevertheless it provides good ground for implementation of various types of scientometrics analyses and will provide more information as we move on.It is axiomatic that development of citation systems is time taking process. By this I am not focusing on issues like budget, building, etc. since such requirements have always been provided to ISC by the Iranian government with ease and on demand. Rather, I would like to focus on the time required to develop the software needed and of course the need for man power who have a good grip on scientometrics analysis.Regarding ISC's software, it has been developed by our own staff here. We consistently improve and enrich it by adding new features and new products. Regarding the staff, the M.S. program for Scientometrics was commenced at RICeST last year. Currently 12 students are studying in this program and this trend will be continued to train the man power required to fill-in-the-gap between ISC and ISI (and Scopus) in the shortest time possible.An important scheme here at ISC is to open up its branches in ISESCO member states to accelerate the enlargement of ISC database. This will, of course, require training of expertise in Scientometrics for which I am honored to introduce our M.S. program for Scientometrics. This program, in the long run, intends to train staff from the OIC countries to represent ISC branches in their relevant countries. I invite here the respected participants from the OIC countries to assist by introducing to us, through their universities, interested students who wish to attend the program.An important point I wish to share here on the present conference is that not many journals from OIC countries are indexed in ISI and Scopus. From among those which are indexed, journals with an IF from only a minority. Since the establishment of ISC, citation analysis has come under focus not only in Iran but also in OIC countries. Journal seek to publish original research with the objective to promote the status of science in the society, to increase scientific and research collaboration among research and scientific institutions in Iran and the OIC countries and expand knowledge frontiers. Attaining this objective depends greatly upon the scientific and research infrastructure of each member state.As specified in its charter, ISC has been bestowed with the responsibility to hold workshops and seminars to improve the status of ICS-indexed journals and, of course, facilitate journal submission by interested bodies to ISC. The present conference is indeed the second of this type- the first one was held two years back- which is being held for editor-in chiefs of scientific journals from Iran and the OIC region.The respected editor-in-chiefs here are invited to make the best use of the potential available in universities, research institution and societies to enhance the status of their journals. To enhance the quality of journals, a number of steps need to be taken:The editor-in-chiefs as well as the editorial boards of scientific journals should be picked up from among outstanding scientific figures. These people are those whose effort cans most contribute to the enhancement of scientific journals.Another point of great moment in enhancing the status of academic journals goes back to the nature of the peer-review process. Qualified and experienced referees can guarantee the quality of articles – and their originality as well.Yet another important issue pertains to the referencing mechanism used in journals. Studies undertaken on the referencing issue reveal that journals quite often do not follow in-text and out-text citation standards. Inconsistencies are observed among journals, even between different issues of a given journal and even at times between different articles of a single journal issue. To ease indexing in ISC, journals need to abide by citation standards. Mismatch in out-text citation may not cause any problem in information databases but they can be a big problem in citation systems like ISC. Hence, it is highly recommended that ISC-indexed journals move towards adapting sort of citation standards. One further point contributing to the quality of journals goes back to the issue of author affiliations. In general, author affiliation is drawn on in a number of research areas including ranking of universities and research institutions, production of science maps, assessing research quality, ranking authors, departments, etc.During the past few years, the increase in the volume of journals has been astronomical. We witness that journal editors are showing ever increasing tendency towards e-publishing. The reasons for such tendency are two-fold: First, journals try to keep abreast of the recent trend in publishing namely the open access movement. Second, journals are faced with budgeting problems and such constraints have forced them to adopt e-publishing as a substitute policy. E-publishing is today deemed as a routine in many countries of the world especially emerging scientific countries.Today, electronic copies of a large number of scientific journals are freely accessible. E-publishing is easier, faster and requires less budgeting. An inherent advantage of e-publishing is that it provides the grounds needed for crawlers to retrieve journals and to use the data for indexing purposes. For e-publishing to perform maximally, there is of course a need for an online journal submission system by the use of which journals can receive articles, send them for peer-review and also form their own online archives for later reference and use.Plagiarism is also deemed as an important issue in the scientific community today as it has been for so long. This phenomenon can harm the quality and status of journals. Indexing systems are apt to exclude journals from their systems due to plagiarism traces observed in them. Thus, it is a must for editor-in-chiefs of journals to be familiar with plagiarism, plagiarism detecting software and the strategies needed to avoid or at least minimize this problem in scientific production process thereby guarantee the copyright issue.Before closing my speech, I would like to make some proposals:1- To establish a publishing agency, with international scope, to publish scientific and research journals from the OIC countries. This will facilitate their indexing in ISC substantially and will be a great help to journals financially.2- To establish ISC local branches in different OIC countries.3- To encourage consistent interaction between ISC and journals with the aim of enhancing the quality and status of ISC-indexed journals.4- To schedule regular visits to ISC (for ISC-indexed editor-in-chiefs) and to OIC countries (for ISC directing body or staff to mark the problems and to make proposals for their removal).5- To hold ISC's conferences in OIC countries. ISC will help financially to hold such conferences.6- To use ISC for citation analyses, science mapping and scientific and research performance assessments in the OIC countries.7- To hold workshops at national and international levels to publicize research and scientific potential of the OIC countries, especially their universities and research institutions. Thank You
Die Inhalte der verlinkten Blogs und Blog Beiträge unterliegen in vielen Fällen keiner redaktionellen Kontrolle.
Warnung zur Verfügbarkeit
Eine dauerhafte Verfügbarkeit ist nicht garantiert und liegt vollumfänglich in den Händen der Blogbetreiber:innen. Bitte erstellen Sie sich selbständig eine Kopie falls Sie einen Blog Beitrag zitieren möchten.
In recent months, Israeli officials have gotten into the habit of equating Hamas with ISIS. This framing has obvious benefits for Israel, which hopes to garner global sympathy by comparing its enemy to a group widely viewed as the pinnacle of early 21st century evil.But it also leads to a thorny question. If Hamas is indeed as bad as the Islamic State, then why should its leaders continue to find shelter in multiple Arab states?In the case of Qatar, where Hamas's political leaders have been based since 2012, the answer is pragmatic. Israel needs a reliable mediator in order to reach a deal for the return of Hamas-held hostages. Doha has already shown its worth by facilitating talks that secured the release of 105 hostages during a week-long ceasefire in November.But that arrangement may have an expiration date. Israeli security officials have threatened to kill Hamas leaders wherever they are, even if that means an attack on Qatari soil. More moderate Israeli voices argue that Doha's arrangement with Hamas simply can't last."The United States and Israel still need to lean on Doha to use its leverage with Hamas to achieve some essential wins — even if Qatar must ultimately cut ties with the organization," Yoel Guzansky, a former Israeli security official, recently wrote in Foreign Affairs.As wars rage in Gaza and Ukraine, neutral states are coming under increasing pressure to pick a side. Switzerland, once thought of as the prototypical global referee, has joined sanctions on the Kremlin and even closed its airspace to Russian planes. Finland has joined the NATO alliance, and Sweden could follow suit by the summer. Qatar — long seen as the ideal Israel-Hamas mediator — may soon have to pick between its American patron and the Palestinian militant group.This is natural to some extent. When it comes to neutrality, war is where the proverbial rubber hits the road. Belligerents almost always view their conflict in terms of true good vs. total evil, a framing that neutral states call into question by their very existence."Under just war theory, neutrality is not possible," said Pascal Lottaz, a professor at Kyoto University and an expert on neutrality. "Whenever good fights evil, not fighting evil is equal to being evil."Yet war-fighting states have long leaned on neutrals as mediators, especially when military force shows limited chances of success. So what happens if the neutrals disappear?Switzerland by any other nameIn some ways, Qatar came upon neutrality by accident. The tiny Gulf state was seen as a Saudi dependent until the mid-1990s, when it embarked on an ambitious plan to protect its security by making friends with just about every other country in its fractious region. A few years into this project, Doha realized that it now had a significant competitive advantage. "It allowed them to be strategically positioned to act as a conduit between actors that didn't otherwise talk to each other," said Mehran Kamrava, a professor of government at Georgetown University Qatar. Pragmatic as they are, Qatari officials played to their strengths and started to pitch themselves as an Arab Switzerland. By the late 2000s, Doha had already mediated major peace talks in Chad, Sudan, and Yemen. Despite crises stemming from the Arab Spring and a later spat with its Gulf neighbors, Qatar's reputation for neutrality has stuck. Its diplomats have led high-profile talks between the U.S. and its most bitter enemies and even helped secure the release of Ukrainian children taken to Russia. Of course, Doha isn't neutral in the traditional sense. For states like Switzerland and Austria, neutrality is a formal commitment to stay out of the fighting that allows them to preserve their security without going to war, according to Lottaz. The arrangement is passive: If you don't mess with me, then I won't mess with you. Qatar's version of neutrality is both less formal and more ambitious. Like traditional neutrals, Doha's primary goal is to stay out of danger in a conflict-prone region. But a second key objective is to raise Qatar's profile such that the tiny state can have an influence over major geopolitical disputes without losing its independence. This helps explain why Qatar's highest officials often participate directly in mediation. When Hezbollah threatened to tank negotiations during a Lebanese political crisis in 2009, the emir personally called Syrian leader Bashar al-Assad and asked him to pressure his ally to break the deadlock. This type of neutrality relies on a stream of diplomatic fictions. Yes, Qatar has a major U.S. military base on its territory, but that doesn't make it a member of the Western bloc. Yes, Qatar hosted Taliban leaders, but that doesn't make it an Islamist ally. In a black and white world, Doha is infuriatingly gray. In practice, Qatar takes every chance it gets to build geopolitical leverage, backstopped by the country's seemingly endless supply of liquid natural gas. This brings us to Doha's relationship with Hamas. Qatari officials say they invited Hamas's political leaders to Doha in 2012 at the behest of the Obama administration, shortly after the militant group fled from Syria amid tensions with Assad. (The earliest Hamas-Doha ties date to 2006, when the Bush administration asked Qatar to open communication channels with the group.) Qatar jumped at the opportunity to both improve ties with the U.S. and improve its competitive advantage as a mediator. But that wasn't enough to shield the Gulf state from criticism after the Oct. 7 attacks. U.S. officials undermined Qatar in the days following the attack by pulling out of a Doha-mediated deal through which Iran got access to billions of dollars in frozen assets following a U.S.-Iran prisoner swap. Hawkish voices in Congress and the American press also leaped to condemn Doha for supporting Hamas, using as evidence Qatar's policy of paying civil servants in Gaza (with Israel's approval). Andreas Krieg, a security studies professor at King's College London, says this is mostly bluster. He describes the rhetorical pressure on Qatar as little more than a "circus in Washington to be seen as being supportive of Israel no matter what." The U.S., Krieg says, has not taken any concrete steps to pressure Qatar on this front. Rather, Washington has given Doha extra leeway to pursue talks. And even if Hamas is somehow destroyed by the war, Qatar will be a prime candidate to mediate with whatever new Islamist movement takes its place, Krieg argues. Only time will tell. Qatari neutrality could face a deep crisis if Israel follows through on its pledge to hunt down Hamas leaders "in every location." But Qatar is nothing if not pragmatic, and Kamrava of Georgetown predicts that Doha's leadership would gladly assent to kicking out Hamas leaders if it meant strengthening ties with the U.S., the most powerful state over which it has significant leverage.The question we're left with is whether this is good for America. Mohamad Bazzi of New York University argues that it's not. "[I]t would be a mistake to force Hamas leaders out of Qatar," Bazzi wrote in a recent op-ed. "[T]hey would probably go to Iran, Lebanon or Syria – and Israel, the US and Europe would have a harder time negotiating with them indirectly." In other words, kicking Hamas out of Qatar would likely make one of the world's most complex conflicts that much more intractable.Cold wars and hot peaceQatar's problems are a microcosm of trends playing out across the world today. The UAE and Turkey have brokered major deals between Russia and Ukraine — deals that less independent states could never have pulled off — and the West have largely repaid them with sanctions and condemnation. To some extent, it should come as little surprise that powerful states balk at neutrality. "It's usually the stronger party of the two belligerents that will put more pressure on the neutrals," Lottaz said. "The weaker one, the one that has more to lose, usually has more to gain from keeping others neutral." He points to the Ukraine conflict as a case in point. The U.S. and its allies condemn neutrality toward the war both on moral grounds and because they see their side as stronger. Russia, for its part, knows that it can benefit more from states remaining neutral than it ever could from its allies voicing their support for Russian policy. Some states have managed to dodge angry powers by keeping a low profile, as in the case of Oman, a rarely mentioned Gulf state that played a crucial role in the talks leading up to the Iran nuclear deal in 2015. But quieter neutrals are not exactly quick to get involved in intractable conflicts that don't affect their vital interests, leaving them outside of most issues entirely. Qatar, by contrast, seems to revel in the chance to take on well-known conflicts, even when — as in Israel-Palestine — the chances of success are limited. Neutral states, Lottaz reminds us, are intimately involved in the causes they mediate. To the extent that Doha views its mediator image as crucial for its security, it will aggressively seek out leverage points in every conflict it can. This worked reasonably well when the U.S. was the only true great power on the world stage. But aggressive neutrality is a tougher sell today as Washington has come to view its ties with both Moscow and Beijing in increasingly zero-sum terms. The dawn of a new cold war has given states some room to balance these powers against each other, but the space for forceful independence — especially for smaller states like Qatar — has begun to shrink. A few hot wars have certainly not helped. So is neutrality dying? It's tough to say for sure. But it's hard to shake the feeling that powerful states will miss it when it's gone.
Key words: sports activities, sports activities legal regulation, temporary laws, ambushmarketing, image rights, local rulemaking The article analyses the legal regulation of the use of intellectualproperty in sports activities. The relevance of the study is justified by the fact that theincome of the global sports industry is increasingly depending on the use of the intellectualproperty by sports organizations.The author notices that adoption of temporary laws aimed at protecting the intellectualproperty rights of sports organizations who organize major sporting events ina country are distinctive features of sports activities. There were two similar laws inthe Ukrainian legislation. Although these laws contained some gaps, this experienceshould become a basis for the introduction of the concept of ambush marketing on aregular basis in the domestic law.Analysis of international agreements in the sporting sphere shows that nowadaysamong the world sports organizations, only intellectual property of InternationalOlympic Committee has an exclusive basis of protection. At the same time, the factthat in general the use and protection of intellectual property is given too little attentionin international agreements in the field of sports gives greater importance tolocal regulations adopted by sports authorities.According to the established practices of foreign sports organizations, professionalrules and contracts between the athlete and the organization contains mutual restrictionsof the use of a number of intellectual property objects constituting the athlete'simage. To date, in Ukrainian practice, only regulations and contracts of several footballorganizations contain the similar provisions, which at the same time have a numberof shortcomings. One of the issues is terminological ambiguity in image rightslegal phenomena, which is still new to Ukrainian practice, and therefore requires theconsistency of definitions between different sports organizations.Thus, although Ukrainian legislation creates the background for domestic sportsorganizations to benefit from their intellectual property, it still requires the adoptionof some new important definitions. ; Ключові слова: спортивна діяльність, правове регулювання спортивної діяльності,закони тимчасової дії, паразитичний маркетинг, право на образ, іміджеві права,локальна нормотворчість У статті міститься огляд нормативно-правових актів, що регулюють відносини у спор-тивній діяльності в розрізі використання об'єктів права інтелектуальної власності у сферіспорту. На основі аналізу законодавства України, міжнародних договорів і особливостейлокальної нормотворчості визначено проблемні аспекти розпорядження об'єктами праваінтелектуальної власності у вітчизняному спорті. Окреслено світові тенденції, що роз-кривають специфіку використання об'єктів права інтелектуальної власності у спорті таповинні стати орієнтиром для законодавця та спортивних організацій України. Список використаних джерел: 1. Clark J. Changing the game. Outlook for the global sports market to 2015. PriceWaterhouseCoopers. 2011. P. 40 URL: https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/hospitality-leisure/pdf/changing-the-game-outlook-for-the-global-sports-market-to-2015.pdf (дата звернення 30.04.2021). 2. Лавренюк О. Ю. Цивільно-правове регулювання відносин інтелектуальної власності у сфері спорту : дис. … канд. юрид. наук. Одеса, 2019. 236 с. 3. Про фізичну культуру і спорт : Закон України від 24.12.93 № 3809-XII. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 1994. № 14. С. 80. 4. Про підтримку олімпійського, паралімпійського руху та спорту вищих досягнень в Україні : Закон України від 14.09.2000 № 1954-III. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2000. № 43. С. 370. 5. Про антидопінговий контроль у спорті : Закон України від 07.02.2017 № 1835-VIII. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2017. № 11. С. 102. 6. Про організацію та проведення фінальної частини чемпіонату Європи 2012 року з футболу в Україні : Закон України від 19.04.2007 № 962-V. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2007. № 31. С. 405. 7. WIPO. Sport & IP — Licenses and Sponsorships in Sport. URL: http://www.wipo.int/ip-sport/en/licenses.html (дата звернення 08.04.2021). 8. Дорошенко Д. О. Захист від паразитичного маркетингу як один з пріоритетів спортивного права України / Тези доповідей міжнародної науково-практичної конференції «Спортивне право України: сучасний стан і перспективи розвитку» (19 жовтня 2018 року). Навчально-науковий «Центр спортивного права», Запорізький національний університет, Запоріжжя, 2018. C. 74. 9. Brazil. General Law of the World Cup. Law No. 12.663 of June 5, 2012 URL: https://wipolex.wipo.int/en/text/335085 (дата звернення 08.04.2021). 10. Cape Town, South Africa. 2010 FIFA World Cup By-law, 2009. Published in Province of Western Cape: Provincial Gazette no. 6594 on 16 January 2009 URL: https://openbylaws.org.za/za-cpt/act/by-law/2009/2010-fifa-world-cup/eng/ (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 11. Про забезпечення охорони та захисту прав інтелектуальної власності УЄФА під час проведення в Україні фінальних матчів Ліги чемпіонів УЄФА та Ліги чемпіонів УЄФА серед жінок сезону 2017/2018 : Закон України від 22.05.2018 № 2444-VIII. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2018. № 22. С. 194. 12. Major Events Management Act 2007. Public Act 2007 No 35. Date of assent 28 August 2007. URL: https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2007/0035/latest/DLM411987.html (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 13. Організація Об'єднаних Націй. Найробський договір про охорону Олімпійського символу (Найробі, 26 вересня 1981 року). URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_995#Text (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 14. Міжнародний Олімпійський комітет. Олімпійська хартія 2020 - DidWeDe, Лозанна, Швейцарія. URL: http://noc-ukr.org/about/officialdocuments/olimpiyska-khartiya/ (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 15. Parrish R. Sports law and policy in the European Union. Manchester University Press. 2003. P. 271. 16. World Athletics. Book C - C2. TECHNICAL RULES (In force from 1 November 2019 and amended on 31 January 2020) URL: https://www.worldathletics.org/about-iaaf/documents/book-of-rules (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 17. Венедиктов В. С. Трудовое право Украины (Общая часть). Харьков : НУВД, 2004. С. 187. 18. University of New Hampshire - Franklin Pierce School of Law. IP Mall. PREMIER LEAGUE CONTRACT URL: https://ipmall.law.unh.edu/sites/default/files/hosted_resources/SportsEntLaw_Institute/Agent%20Contracts%20Between%20Players%20&%20Their%20Agents/6_PREMIER%20LEAGUE%20PLAYERS%20CONTRACT.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 19. Галузева Угода між Громадською спілкою «Федерація футболу України», Об'єднанням професіональних футбольних клубів України «Прем'єр-Ліга», об'єднанням футбольних клубів «Професіональна футбольна ліга України», та Всеукраїнською професійною спілкою «Футбол України», Всеукраїнською асоціацією футболістів-професіоналів у сфері професіонального футболу України на 2017-2022 роки. Київ-2017. URL: http://dev.pfl.ua/docs/07d3098c0649d1810a8a75fb1f1740a7.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 20. Федерація футболу України. РЕГЛАМЕНТ Федерації футболу України зі статусу і трансферу футболістів. Київ-2018 URL: https://uaf.ua/about-ffu/library (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 21. The Football Association Premier League L.imited. Handbook Season 2020/21 URL: https://resources.premierleague.com/premierleague/document/ 2020/09/11/dc7e76c1-f78d-45a2-be4a-4c6bc33368fa/2020-21-PL-Handbook-110920.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 22. Turkish Airlains EoroLeague. EUROLEAGUE BYLAWS. URL: https://www.euroleague.net/rs/85b6m5hxnomx8xap/84bd1f8d-134d-42a0-a8ee-cd688d29aaa2/d0c/filename/201718elbylaws.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). ===================== 1. Clark J. Changing the game. Outlook for the global sports market to 2015. PriceWaterhouseCoopers. 2011. P. 40 URL: https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/hospitality-leisure/pdf/changing-the-game-outlook-for-the-global-sports-market-to-2015.pdf (data zvernennia 30.04.2021). 2. Lavreniuk O. Yu. Tsyvilno-pravove rehuliuvannia vidnosyn intelektualnoi vlasnosti u sferi sportu : dys. … kand. yuryd. nauk. Odesa, 2019. 236 s. 3. Pro fizychnu kulturu i sport : Zakon Ukrainy vid 24.12.93 № 3809-XII. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 1994. № 14. S. 80. 4. Pro pidtrymku olimpiiskoho, paralimpiiskoho rukhu ta sportu vyshchykh dosiahnen v Ukraini : Zakon Ukrainy vid 14.09.2000 № 1954-III. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2000. № 43. S. 370. 5. Pro antydopinhovyi kontrol u sporti : Zakon Ukrainy vid 07.02.2017 № 1835-VIII. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2017. № 11. S. 102. 6. Pro orhanizatsiiu ta provedennia finalnoi chastyny chempionatu Yevropy 2012 roku z futbolu v Ukraini : Zakon Ukrainy vid 19.04.2007 № 962-V. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2007. № 31. S. 405. 7. WIPO. Sport & IP — Licenses and Sponsorships in Sport. URL: http://www.wipo.int/ip-sport/en/licenses.html (data zvernennia 08.04.2021). 8. Doroshenko D. O. Zakhyst vid parazytychnoho marketynhu yak odyn z priorytetiv sportyvnoho prava Ukrainy / Tezy dopovidei mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii «Sportyvne pravo Ukrainy: suchasnyi stan i perspektyvy rozvytku» (19 zhovtnia 2018 roku). Navchalno-naukovyi «Tsentr sportyvnoho prava», Zaporizkyi natsionalnyi universytet, Zaporizhzhia, 2018. C. 74. 9. Brazil. General Law of the World Cup. Law No. 12.663 of June 5, 2012 URL: https://wipolex.wipo.int/en/text/335085 (data zvernennia 08.04.2021). 10. Cape Town, South Africa. 2010 FIFA World Cup By-law, 2009. Published in Province of Western Cape: Provincial Gazette no. 6594 on 16 January 2009 URL: https://openbylaws.org.za/za-cpt/act/by-law/2009/2010-fifa-world-cup/eng/ (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 11. Pro zabezpechennia okhorony ta zakhystu prav intelektualnoi vlasnosti UIeFA pid chas provedennia v Ukraini finalnykh matchiv Lihy chempioniv UIeFA ta Lihy chempioniv UIeFA sered zhinok sezonu 2017/2018 : Zakon Ukrainy vid 22.05.2018 № 2444-VIII. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2018. № 22. S. 194. 12. Major Events Management Act 2007. Public Act 2007 No 35. Date of assent 28 August 2007. URL: https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2007/0035/latest/DLM411987.html (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 13. Orhanizatsiia Ob'iednanykh Natsii. Nairobskyi dohovir pro okhoronu Olimpiiskoho symvolu (Nairobi, 26 veresnia 1981 roku). URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_995#Text (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 14. Mizhnarodnyi Olimpiiskyi komitet. Olimpiiska khartiia 2020 - DidWeDe, Lozanna, Shveitsariia. URL: http://noc-ukr.org/about/officialdocuments/olimpiyska-khartiya/ (data zvernennia 08.04.2021). 15. Parrish R. Sports law and policy in the European Union. Manchester University Press. 2003. P. 271. 16. World Athletics. Book C - C2. TECHNICAL RULES (In force from 1 November 2019 and amended on 31 January 2020) URL: https://www.worldathletics.org/about-iaaf/documents/book-of-rules (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 17. Venedyktov V. S. Trudovoe pravo Ukraynы (Obshchaia chast). Kharkov : NUVD, 2004. S. 187. 18. University of New Hampshire - Franklin Pierce School of Law. IP Mall. PREMIER LEAGUE CONTRACT URL: https://ipmall.law.unh.edu/sites/default/files/hosted_resources/SportsEntLaw_Institute/Agent%20Contracts%20Between%20Players%20&%20Their%20Agents/6_PREMIER%20LEAGUE%20PLAYERS%20CONTRACT.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 19. Haluzeva Uhoda mizh Hromadskoiu spilkoiu «Federatsiia futbolu Ukrainy», Obiednanniam profesionalnykh futbolnykh klubiv Ukrainy «Premier-Liha», obiednanniam futbolnykh klubiv «Profesionalna futbolna liha Ukrainy», ta Vseukrainskoiu profesiinoiu spilkoiu «Futbol Ukrainy», Vseukrainskoiu asotsiatsiieiu futbolistiv-profesionaliv u sferi profesionalnoho futbolu Ukrainy na 2017-2022 roky. Kyiv-2017. URL: http://dev.pfl.ua/docs/07d3098c0649d1810a8a75fb1f1740a7.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 20. Federatsiia futbolu Ukrainy. REHLAMENT Federatsii futbolu Ukrainy zi statusu i transferu futbolistiv. Kyiv-2018 URL: https://uaf.ua/about-ffu/library (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 21. The Football Association Premier League L.imited. Handbook Season 2020/21 URL: https://resources.premierleague.com/premierleague/document/2020/09/11/dc7e76c1-f78d-45a2-be4a-4c6bc33368fa/2020-21-PL-Handbook-110920.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 22. Turkish Airlains EoroLeague. EUROLEAGUE BYLAWS. URL: https://www.euroleague.net/rs/85b6m5hxnomx8xap/84bd1f8d-134d-42a0-a8ee-cd688d29aaa2/d0c/filename/201718elbylaws.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021).
Key words: sports activities, sports activities legal regulation, temporary laws, ambushmarketing, image rights, local rulemaking The article analyses the legal regulation of the use of intellectualproperty in sports activities. The relevance of the study is justified by the fact that theincome of the global sports industry is increasingly depending on the use of the intellectualproperty by sports organizations.The author notices that adoption of temporary laws aimed at protecting the intellectualproperty rights of sports organizations who organize major sporting events ina country are distinctive features of sports activities. There were two similar laws inthe Ukrainian legislation. Although these laws contained some gaps, this experienceshould become a basis for the introduction of the concept of ambush marketing on aregular basis in the domestic law.Analysis of international agreements in the sporting sphere shows that nowadaysamong the world sports organizations, only intellectual property of InternationalOlympic Committee has an exclusive basis of protection. At the same time, the factthat in general the use and protection of intellectual property is given too little attentionin international agreements in the field of sports gives greater importance tolocal regulations adopted by sports authorities.According to the established practices of foreign sports organizations, professionalrules and contracts between the athlete and the organization contains mutual restrictionsof the use of a number of intellectual property objects constituting the athlete'simage. To date, in Ukrainian practice, only regulations and contracts of several footballorganizations contain the similar provisions, which at the same time have a numberof shortcomings. One of the issues is terminological ambiguity in image rightslegal phenomena, which is still new to Ukrainian practice, and therefore requires theconsistency of definitions between different sports organizations.Thus, although Ukrainian legislation creates the background for domestic sportsorganizations to benefit from their intellectual property, it still requires the adoptionof some new important definitions. ; Ключові слова: спортивна діяльність, правове регулювання спортивної діяльності,закони тимчасової дії, паразитичний маркетинг, право на образ, іміджеві права,локальна нормотворчість У статті міститься огляд нормативно-правових актів, що регулюють відносини у спор-тивній діяльності в розрізі використання об'єктів права інтелектуальної власності у сферіспорту. На основі аналізу законодавства України, міжнародних договорів і особливостейлокальної нормотворчості визначено проблемні аспекти розпорядження об'єктами праваінтелектуальної власності у вітчизняному спорті. Окреслено світові тенденції, що роз-кривають специфіку використання об'єктів права інтелектуальної власності у спорті таповинні стати орієнтиром для законодавця та спортивних організацій України. Список використаних джерел: 1. Clark J. Changing the game. Outlook for the global sports market to 2015. PriceWaterhouseCoopers. 2011. P. 40 URL: https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/hospitality-leisure/pdf/changing-the-game-outlook-for-the-global-sports-market-to-2015.pdf (дата звернення 30.04.2021). 2. Лавренюк О. Ю. Цивільно-правове регулювання відносин інтелектуальної власності у сфері спорту : дис. … канд. юрид. наук. Одеса, 2019. 236 с. 3. Про фізичну культуру і спорт : Закон України від 24.12.93 № 3809-XII. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 1994. № 14. С. 80. 4. Про підтримку олімпійського, паралімпійського руху та спорту вищих досягнень в Україні : Закон України від 14.09.2000 № 1954-III. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2000. № 43. С. 370. 5. Про антидопінговий контроль у спорті : Закон України від 07.02.2017 № 1835-VIII. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2017. № 11. С. 102. 6. Про організацію та проведення фінальної частини чемпіонату Європи 2012 року з футболу в Україні : Закон України від 19.04.2007 № 962-V. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2007. № 31. С. 405. 7. WIPO. Sport & IP — Licenses and Sponsorships in Sport. URL: http://www.wipo.int/ip-sport/en/licenses.html (дата звернення 08.04.2021). 8. Дорошенко Д. О. Захист від паразитичного маркетингу як один з пріоритетів спортивного права України / Тези доповідей міжнародної науково-практичної конференції «Спортивне право України: сучасний стан і перспективи розвитку» (19 жовтня 2018 року). Навчально-науковий «Центр спортивного права», Запорізький національний університет, Запоріжжя, 2018. C. 74. 9. Brazil. General Law of the World Cup. Law No. 12.663 of June 5, 2012 URL: https://wipolex.wipo.int/en/text/335085 (дата звернення 08.04.2021). 10. Cape Town, South Africa. 2010 FIFA World Cup By-law, 2009. Published in Province of Western Cape: Provincial Gazette no. 6594 on 16 January 2009 URL: https://openbylaws.org.za/za-cpt/act/by-law/2009/2010-fifa-world-cup/eng/ (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 11. Про забезпечення охорони та захисту прав інтелектуальної власності УЄФА під час проведення в Україні фінальних матчів Ліги чемпіонів УЄФА та Ліги чемпіонів УЄФА серед жінок сезону 2017/2018 : Закон України від 22.05.2018 № 2444-VIII. Відомості Верховної Ради України. 2018. № 22. С. 194. 12. Major Events Management Act 2007. Public Act 2007 No 35. Date of assent 28 August 2007. URL: https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2007/0035/latest/DLM411987.html (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 13. Організація Об'єднаних Націй. Найробський договір про охорону Олімпійського символу (Найробі, 26 вересня 1981 року). URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_995#Text (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 14. Міжнародний Олімпійський комітет. Олімпійська хартія 2020 - DidWeDe, Лозанна, Швейцарія. URL: http://noc-ukr.org/about/officialdocuments/olimpiyska-khartiya/ (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 15. Parrish R. Sports law and policy in the European Union. Manchester University Press. 2003. P. 271. 16. World Athletics. Book C - C2. TECHNICAL RULES (In force from 1 November 2019 and amended on 31 January 2020) URL: https://www.worldathletics.org/about-iaaf/documents/book-of-rules (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 17. Венедиктов В. С. Трудовое право Украины (Общая часть). Харьков : НУВД, 2004. С. 187. 18. University of New Hampshire - Franklin Pierce School of Law. IP Mall. PREMIER LEAGUE CONTRACT URL: https://ipmall.law.unh.edu/sites/default/files/hosted_resources/SportsEntLaw_Institute/Agent%20Contracts%20Between%20Players%20&%20Their%20Agents/6_PREMIER%20LEAGUE%20PLAYERS%20CONTRACT.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 19. Галузева Угода між Громадською спілкою «Федерація футболу України», Об'єднанням професіональних футбольних клубів України «Прем'єр-Ліга», об'єднанням футбольних клубів «Професіональна футбольна ліга України», та Всеукраїнською професійною спілкою «Футбол України», Всеукраїнською асоціацією футболістів-професіоналів у сфері професіонального футболу України на 2017-2022 роки. Київ-2017. URL: http://dev.pfl.ua/docs/07d3098c0649d1810a8a75fb1f1740a7.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 20. Федерація футболу України. РЕГЛАМЕНТ Федерації футболу України зі статусу і трансферу футболістів. Київ-2018 URL: https://uaf.ua/about-ffu/library (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 21. The Football Association Premier League L.imited. Handbook Season 2020/21 URL: https://resources.premierleague.com/premierleague/document/ 2020/09/11/dc7e76c1-f78d-45a2-be4a-4c6bc33368fa/2020-21-PL-Handbook-110920.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). 22. Turkish Airlains EoroLeague. EUROLEAGUE BYLAWS. URL: https://www.euroleague.net/rs/85b6m5hxnomx8xap/84bd1f8d-134d-42a0-a8ee-cd688d29aaa2/d0c/filename/201718elbylaws.pdf (дата звернення 30.03.2021). ===================== 1. Clark J. Changing the game. Outlook for the global sports market to 2015. PriceWaterhouseCoopers. 2011. P. 40 URL: https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/hospitality-leisure/pdf/changing-the-game-outlook-for-the-global-sports-market-to-2015.pdf (data zvernennia 30.04.2021). 2. Lavreniuk O. Yu. Tsyvilno-pravove rehuliuvannia vidnosyn intelektualnoi vlasnosti u sferi sportu : dys. … kand. yuryd. nauk. Odesa, 2019. 236 s. 3. Pro fizychnu kulturu i sport : Zakon Ukrainy vid 24.12.93 № 3809-XII. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 1994. № 14. S. 80. 4. Pro pidtrymku olimpiiskoho, paralimpiiskoho rukhu ta sportu vyshchykh dosiahnen v Ukraini : Zakon Ukrainy vid 14.09.2000 № 1954-III. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2000. № 43. S. 370. 5. Pro antydopinhovyi kontrol u sporti : Zakon Ukrainy vid 07.02.2017 № 1835-VIII. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2017. № 11. S. 102. 6. Pro orhanizatsiiu ta provedennia finalnoi chastyny chempionatu Yevropy 2012 roku z futbolu v Ukraini : Zakon Ukrainy vid 19.04.2007 № 962-V. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2007. № 31. S. 405. 7. WIPO. Sport & IP — Licenses and Sponsorships in Sport. URL: http://www.wipo.int/ip-sport/en/licenses.html (data zvernennia 08.04.2021). 8. Doroshenko D. O. Zakhyst vid parazytychnoho marketynhu yak odyn z priorytetiv sportyvnoho prava Ukrainy / Tezy dopovidei mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii «Sportyvne pravo Ukrainy: suchasnyi stan i perspektyvy rozvytku» (19 zhovtnia 2018 roku). Navchalno-naukovyi «Tsentr sportyvnoho prava», Zaporizkyi natsionalnyi universytet, Zaporizhzhia, 2018. C. 74. 9. Brazil. General Law of the World Cup. Law No. 12.663 of June 5, 2012 URL: https://wipolex.wipo.int/en/text/335085 (data zvernennia 08.04.2021). 10. Cape Town, South Africa. 2010 FIFA World Cup By-law, 2009. Published in Province of Western Cape: Provincial Gazette no. 6594 on 16 January 2009 URL: https://openbylaws.org.za/za-cpt/act/by-law/2009/2010-fifa-world-cup/eng/ (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 11. Pro zabezpechennia okhorony ta zakhystu prav intelektualnoi vlasnosti UIeFA pid chas provedennia v Ukraini finalnykh matchiv Lihy chempioniv UIeFA ta Lihy chempioniv UIeFA sered zhinok sezonu 2017/2018 : Zakon Ukrainy vid 22.05.2018 № 2444-VIII. Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy. 2018. № 22. S. 194. 12. Major Events Management Act 2007. Public Act 2007 No 35. Date of assent 28 August 2007. URL: https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2007/0035/latest/DLM411987.html (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 13. Orhanizatsiia Ob'iednanykh Natsii. Nairobskyi dohovir pro okhoronu Olimpiiskoho symvolu (Nairobi, 26 veresnia 1981 roku). URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_995#Text (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 14. Mizhnarodnyi Olimpiiskyi komitet. Olimpiiska khartiia 2020 - DidWeDe, Lozanna, Shveitsariia. URL: http://noc-ukr.org/about/officialdocuments/olimpiyska-khartiya/ (data zvernennia 08.04.2021). 15. Parrish R. Sports law and policy in the European Union. Manchester University Press. 2003. P. 271. 16. World Athletics. Book C - C2. TECHNICAL RULES (In force from 1 November 2019 and amended on 31 January 2020) URL: https://www.worldathletics.org/about-iaaf/documents/book-of-rules (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 17. Venedyktov V. S. Trudovoe pravo Ukraynы (Obshchaia chast). Kharkov : NUVD, 2004. S. 187. 18. University of New Hampshire - Franklin Pierce School of Law. IP Mall. PREMIER LEAGUE CONTRACT URL: https://ipmall.law.unh.edu/sites/default/files/hosted_resources/SportsEntLaw_Institute/Agent%20Contracts%20Between%20Players%20&%20Their%20Agents/6_PREMIER%20LEAGUE%20PLAYERS%20CONTRACT.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 19. Haluzeva Uhoda mizh Hromadskoiu spilkoiu «Federatsiia futbolu Ukrainy», Obiednanniam profesionalnykh futbolnykh klubiv Ukrainy «Premier-Liha», obiednanniam futbolnykh klubiv «Profesionalna futbolna liha Ukrainy», ta Vseukrainskoiu profesiinoiu spilkoiu «Futbol Ukrainy», Vseukrainskoiu asotsiatsiieiu futbolistiv-profesionaliv u sferi profesionalnoho futbolu Ukrainy na 2017-2022 roky. Kyiv-2017. URL: http://dev.pfl.ua/docs/07d3098c0649d1810a8a75fb1f1740a7.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 20. Federatsiia futbolu Ukrainy. REHLAMENT Federatsii futbolu Ukrainy zi statusu i transferu futbolistiv. Kyiv-2018 URL: https://uaf.ua/about-ffu/library (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 21. The Football Association Premier League L.imited. Handbook Season 2020/21 URL: https://resources.premierleague.com/premierleague/document/2020/09/11/dc7e76c1-f78d-45a2-be4a-4c6bc33368fa/2020-21-PL-Handbook-110920.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021). 22. Turkish Airlains EoroLeague. EUROLEAGUE BYLAWS. URL: https://www.euroleague.net/rs/85b6m5hxnomx8xap/84bd1f8d-134d-42a0-a8ee-cd688d29aaa2/d0c/filename/201718elbylaws.pdf (data zvernennia 30.03.2021).